Scholars believe that the high level of artisanal skill evident in the carved cup points to the Egyptian city of Alexandria as the site of its creation. In antiquity, Alexandria was famously a center for the working of hard stones. The vessel’s material is commonly called sardonyx: It is a form of agate with parallel bands of reddish-brown and white. The raw material may have originated in India, which was known in the ancient world for its natural resource of high-quality banded agates.
Patron of Arts
The first documented owner of the sardonyx cup is Abbot Suger (circa 1081–1151). Suger was elected abbot of the Royal Abbey Church of Saint-Denis in 1122. One of the most important patrons of the arts of his time, this powerful churchman was also an influential statesman as a key advisor to two French kings.
Suger is best remembered for his rebuilding of the early medieval Abbey of Saint-Denis. Saint Denis, the first bishop of Paris, was regarded as the patron saint of the French people as well as its monarchy. As a result, most French kings were buried in the abbey.
By the time Suger became abbot, the complex was in need of refurbishment. Suger oversaw the builders that fashioned the abbey from 1137 to 1144 into the first true manifestation of the Gothic style. This type of architecture, which prioritized light flooding through richly colored stained glass windows, would dominate Europe for centuries.
Art historians believe that merchants brought the sardonyx cup to Paris in the first half of the 12th century where it was purchased by Suger. Around 1137 to 1140, Suger had it set in gilded silver mounts adorned with jewels and golden filigree wire in coiling patterns. This transfiguration turned the hard-stone vessel into an ecclesiastical object, a Catholic chalice for the revitalized Abbey of Saint-Denis.
“When you look at this cup, you notice a wonderful sense of movement that pervades both the stone, the swirling, spiraling veining that winds its way over the surface and is broken up by the fluting and the spiral coils of wire that cover the surfaces of the goldsmith work.”
Its visual effect is enhanced by the high polish of the sardonyx.
Other precious items acquired by Suger for the abbey’s treasury that have survived are now part of the Louvre’s collection. The “Eleanor Vase” and “Sardonyx Ewer” are also composed of historic hard-stone vessels from other cultures with medieval metal mountings of exceptional quality. The shared characteristics of these three objects suggest that they were set in the same Parisian workshop.
Rehoming the ‘Suger Chalice’
The “Chalice” is documented in both written inventories as well as works of art during its time at the abbey. An engraving from 1706 shows it grouped with other precious items from the Treasury of Saint-Denis. It remained in use at the abbey until 1791.
It was removed during the French Revolution as a law was passed ordering the nationalization of the monastic orders. The “Chalice” was sent to the Cabinet National des Médailles et Antiques and put on public display.
One February night in 1804, during the Napoleonic Wars, it was stolen from the Cabinet National, along with other objects. The “Chalice” was smuggled out of the country in a plaster bust of an ancient sculpture and deposited in England.
In July of 1804, the thief sold the cup to the famed English collector Charles Townley (1737–1805). It seems that it remained with the Townley family until around 1920, when it was purchased by a London dealer. Shortly thereafter, it traveled to a New York gallery and was soon acquired by the Philadelphia-based collector Joseph E. Widener, one of the NGA’s most prolific benefactors.
Although some modifications have been made to it over the centuries, including the replacement of some gems, medallions, and the handles, the “Chalice” is remarkably intact given its age and history. It is as precious and wondrous as when it was first created.
