A provocative new book by Loyola Medicine radiation oncologist James S. Welsh, MD, “Sharks Get Cancer, Mole Rats Don’t: How Animals Could Hold the Key to Unlocking Cancer Immunity in Humans,” explores how animals can help us understand how the immune system can be used to fight cancer.
Dr. Welsh explores fascinating examples of how, in both animals and humans, the immune system in some cases effectively kills tumor cells, while in other cases cancer cells escape detection. He also explains how, contrary to popular belief, it’s possible to catch cancer — as in the case of Tasmanian devils (marsupials in Australia the size of small dogs).
Tasmanian devils are on the verge of extinction due to a virulent form of contagious cancer. Similarly, clams on the Atlantic seaboard are vanishing due to a contagious leukemia transmitted in sea water. Dogs can contract a contagious cancer as well, but usually overcome it spontaneously. Thereafter, the dogs become impervious to this type of cancer, providing an intriguing clue about the role of the immune system in cancer.
Animals offer many tantalizing clues about the nature of cancer in humans. Contrary to myth, sharks do get cancer. But naked and blind mole rates generally are not susceptible to the disease. In humans, an uncommon form of dwarfism called Laron syndrome confers near total cancer immunity. In another unusual phenomenon, a man died from ovarian cancer after receiving a kidney transplant from a woman who had the disease. In an even odder case, a tapeworm developed “cancer,” which spread throughout the patient’s body. And in perhaps the book’s most extraordinary case, Dr. Welsh describes the seemingly miraculous cure of one of his patients, named Daniel, who had advanced metastatic melanoma.
The highly aggressive cancer had spread to Daniel’s liver and bones, and he appeared to have only a few months to live. Daniel suffered excruciating pain from a tumor in his femur (thigh bone). Dr. Welsh offered Daniel local radiation to shrink the tumor, relieve the pain and reduce the risk of a fracture. This palliative treatment was intended only to relieve symptoms, not cure the disease. But three months later, a CT scan found no trace of cancer anywhere. Daniel benefitted from a rare phenomenon called the abscopal effect, in which localized treatment not only shrinks the targeted tumor but distant tumors as well. It appears the local radiation somehow stimulated Daniel’s immune system to attack cancer throughout his body.
“The abscopal phenomenon represents an extreme example of the immune system’s ability to recognize and occasionally overpower even highly advanced cancer,” Dr. Welsh writes.
Earlier attempts to fight cancer with immunotherapy were disappointing. These treatments strengthened the immune system, but also boosted the strength and number of previously unrecognized or underappreciated immunological guardian cells that actually protect the tumor.
However, newer approaches to immunotherapy are showing promise. “Years of skepticism about cancer immunotherapy are finally fading. . .” Dr. Welsh concludes. “The revolution is on!”
Dr. Welsh is a professor in the Department of Radiation Oncology of Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine.