Why Prescribing Xanax May Make Your Doctor Uncomfortable

Benzodiazepines are to anxiety what opioids are to pain—and that's a prescription for addiction
By Arash Javanbakht
Arash Javanbakht
Arash Javanbakht
November 4, 2019 Updated: November 4, 2019

As an academic psychiatrist who treats people with anxiety and trauma, I often hear questions about benzodiazepines and receive referrals for patients who are on these medications and reluctant to discontinue them.

There has been rising attention toward the long-term risks of benzodiazepines, including the potential for addiction, overdose, and cognitive impairment. The overdose death rate among patients receiving both benzodiazepines and opioids is 10 times higher than those only receiving opioids, and benzo misuse is a serious concern.

What Are Benzodiazepines?

Benzodiazepines are a class of anti-anxiety medications, or anxiolytics, that increases the activity of the gamma-aminobutyric acid receptors in the brain. GABA is a neurotransmitter, a molecule that helps brain cells, or neurons, communicate with each other. GABA receptors are widely available across the brain, and benzodiazepines work to reduce anxiety by enhancing GABA inhibitory function.

The benzo family includes diazepam or Valium; clonazepam, or Klonopin; lorazepam, or Ativan; chlordiazepoxide, or Librium; and the one most commonly known to the pop culture, alprazolam, or Xanax, among others.

Different benzos have similar effects, but they differ in strength, how long it takes for them to work, and half-life, a measure of how long the drug stays in your system. For example, while diazepam has a half-life of up to 48 hours, the half-life of alprazolam can be as short as six hours. This is important, as a shorter half-life is linked with higher potential for addiction and dependence. That is one reason physicians typically aren’t excited about prescribing Xanax for long periods of time.

When Are They Used?

Benzos were introduced to the market in the 1950s and were considered a safer alternative to the barbiturates then used to treat anxiety. By the 1970s, benzos were among the most highly prescribed medications.

Benzos are mainly used to treat anxiety disorders, such as phobias, panic disorder, and generalized anxiety disorder. They are mostly used for a short period at the beginning of the treatment. That is because it may take a few weeks for the main pharmacological treatment for anxiety—antidepressants—to kick in. During that time, if anxiety is severe and debilitating, benzodiazepines may be prescribed for temporary use.

Benzos are also prescribed for occasional situations of high anxiety, such as that caused by phobias. The main treatment of phobias, such as excessive fear of animals, places, and social interactions, is psychotherapy. Sometimes, however, phobias can interfere with one’s functioning just sporadically, and the person may not be interested in investing in therapy. For example, a person with a fear of flying who may fly on a plane once or twice a year may choose to take a benzo before flying. However, for a businessman or woman who flies several times a month, psychotherapy is recommended.

Benzos may also be used for situations of short-term stress, such as a stressful job interview.

Benzos are also used for other medical conditions, such as treatment of seizures or alcohol withdrawal in the hospital. There is no good evidence for the use of benzos for post-traumatic stress disorder.

So Why the Worry?

Doctors have a Hippocratic oath to “first do no harm.”

A major risk of long-term use of benzos is addiction. That means you may become dependent on these meds and must keep increasing the dose to get the same effect. Actually benzos, especially Xanax, have street value because of the pleasant feeling they induce. In 2017, there were more than 11,000 deaths involving benzos alone or with other drugs, and in 2015, a fifth of those who died of opioid overdose also had benzos in their blood.

Benzos are to anxiety what opioids are to pain. They both are mostly for short-term use, have a potential for addiction, and aren’t a cure. Benzo overdose, especially when mixed with alcohol or opioids, may lead to slowed breathing and potentially death. Benzo misuse can also lead to a lack of restraint of aggressive or impulsive behavior.

As benzos are sedating medications, they also increase the risk of accidents and falls, especially in the elderly. This is worse when they are mixed with other central nervous system suppressants like alcohol or opioids.

Recently, we have been learning more about the potential cognitive, memory, and psychomotor impairment in the long-term use of benzodiazepines, especially in older adults. Cognitive functions impacted may include processing speed and learning among others. Such effects may persist even after ending long-term use of the benzos.

Stopping benzos abruptly, especially a high dosage, can cause withdrawal symptoms, such as restlessness, irritability, insomnia, muscle tension, blurred vision, and a racing heart. Withdrawal from high doses of benzos, especially those that are shorter-acting, may be dangerous and can lead to seizure. Getting off of these medications should be done under the supervision of a physician.

Safer Options Abound

There are safer effective treatments for anxiety, but they require patience to work. The first-line treatment for anxiety disorders is psychotherapy, mainly cognitive behavioral therapy. During therapy, the person learns more adaptive coping skills and corrects cognitive distortions to reduce stress.

Exposure therapy is an effective treatment for phobias, social phobia, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and post-traumatic stress disorder. During exposure therapy, the person is gradually exposed to the feared situation under the guidance of the therapist, until the situation doesn’t create anxiety anymore. Importantly, the skills learned during therapy can always be used, allowing a better long-term outcome compared to medications.

Medications are also used for the treatment of anxiety disorders. The main group of such medications is selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, commonly known as antidepressants. Examples of such medications are fluoxetine, sertraline, and citalopram. Especially when combined with psychotherapy, these medications are effective and are safer options than benzos, and without risk of addiction.

is an assistant professor of psychiatry at Wayne State University. This article was originally published on The Conversation.

Arash Javanbakht
Arash Javanbakht