Popcorn and Inspiration: ‘Crooked Arrows’: Lacrosse: The Healing Medicine Game

The story of a Native American lacrosse team who overcomes the odds to try to win a prep school league tournament.
Mark Jackson
10/31/2021
Updated:
10/31/2021

When the underdog Native American high school lacrosse team, the titular Crooked Arrows, starts winning toward the end of “Crooked Arrows,” a prep schooler sitting in the bleachers says, “When did Indians start playing lacrosse?”

A flashback in history to the Native American origins of lacrosse, the "Medicine Game," in the sports-drama "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
A flashback in history to the Native American origins of lacrosse, the "Medicine Game," in the sports-drama "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
Most Americans know by now that North American natives invented lacrosse. The game became more formalized with written rules in 1867, after which it became a competitive sport in elite prep schools and colleges, primarily in the northeastern United States. A line from the movie states the reason for its invention: “Long ago the Creator gave us the Medicine Game, that we all come together and heal each other.”
“Crooked Arrows” is a warm-hearted, inspiring little movie. It has, granted, a ton of Native American cinematic clichés, such as dream sequences featuring spluttering, staccato wooden flutes, soaring eagles, and so on, but it works nicely.

Rite of Passage for the Coach

Brandon Routh, one of our former cinematic Supermen, plays Joe Logan, former star lacrosse player now turned slick businessman, who’s looking to upgrade the casino on the reservation he grew up on. This upgrade means opening ancestral land to developers.

As his father (Gil Birmingham) and the rest of the tribal council can easily see, while the young man might have entrepreneurial skills, he’s also fairly shallow and lacks integrity. In order to show he’s mature enough to make such momentous decisions, he’s put to the test. He has to coach the reservation’s directionless, under-inspired, and under-equipped lacrosse team.

The classic storyline ensues: egotistical and noncommittal coach, and a team of listless and resentful players. The odds of winning against vastly superior and well-funded teams is too overwhelming to take practice seriously.

It dawns on coach Joe Logan (Brandon Routh) that he's got his work cut out for him, in the lacrosse movie "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
It dawns on coach Joe Logan (Brandon Routh) that he's got his work cut out for him, in the lacrosse movie "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)

The coach then incurs some personal losses, has a dark night of the soul, and thereby taps into his Native American spiritual heritage, thus fundamentally changing his conventional thinking.

A cute, can-he-win-her-back romance also starts up with Joe’s former cheerleader girlfriend Julie (Crystal Allen), who has returned with a Ph.D. to teach at the high school.

Dr. Julie Gifford (Crystal Allen) previously dated coach Joe Logan (Brandon Routh) in the high school they now both work at, in the sports-drama "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
Dr. Julie Gifford (Crystal Allen) previously dated coach Joe Logan (Brandon Routh) in the high school they now both work at, in the sports-drama "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)

Then come the get-in-shape and motivational montages, the get-smacked-around first games, the back-to-the-drawing-board sequences—and the first win.

Jimmy Silverfoot (Tyler Hill) plays attack position against an opposing team player, in "Crooked Arrows," about a Native American high school lacrosse team making it to a prep school league tournament. (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
Jimmy Silverfoot (Tyler Hill) plays attack position against an opposing team player, in "Crooked Arrows," about a Native American high school lacrosse team making it to a prep school league tournament. (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)

Rite of Passage for the Kids

Next up is the rejuvenating of the cultural heritage within the team, and the drawing on of Native American traditions such as the vision quest and the sweat lodge—all of which were originally designed to turn boys into men. A tribal elder speaks of the Creator and the origins of the game. The whupping and smackdowns of the snooty prep school boys commences—let the fun begin.
Jimmy Silverfoot (Tyler Hill, L) faces off against an opposing player (Matthew Eriksen) in a prep school league tournament. (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
Jimmy Silverfoot (Tyler Hill, L) faces off against an opposing player (Matthew Eriksen) in a prep school league tournament. (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)

As mentioned, there are a lot of clichés. There’s a fair amount of bad acting, but it’s nevertheless inspiring to see the boys hanging earned warrior hawk feathers off their helmets. It’s further inspiring to see how not only their morale but their moral standard rises as they take sanctuary in their spiritual heritage, and to compare that with the other team’s culture of taking pride in getting away with cheating.

Player Jimmy Silverfoot (Tyler Hill) and coach Joe Logan (Brandon Routh, R), in the sports-drama "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
Player Jimmy Silverfoot (Tyler Hill) and coach Joe Logan (Brandon Routh, R), in the sports-drama "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
Best line of the movie: “We often give our enemies the means to our defeat. Look inside yourself to find the origin of your downfall.” Maybe the Creator ... gave America the Medicine Game, that we all come together and heal each other? Imagine if all our sports had that as an end goal?

“Crooked Arrows” is straight-up popcorn and inspiration for a Saturday night in the home entertainment den!

Movie poster for the sports-drama "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
Movie poster for the sports-drama "Crooked Arrows." (Kent Eanes/Peck Entertainment/20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Freestyle Releasing)
‘Crooked Arrows’ Director: Steve Rash Starring: Brandon Routh, Gil Birmingham, Crystal Allen, Chelsea Ricketts, Dennis Ambriz, Jimmy Silverfoot Running Time: 1 hour, 45 minutes MPAA Rating: PG-13 Release Date: May 18, 2012 Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars
Mark Jackson is the chief film critic for The Epoch Times. In addition to the world’s number-one storytelling vehicle—film, he enjoys martial arts, weightlifting, Harley-Davidsons, vision questing, rock-climbing, qigong, oil painting, and human rights activism. Mark earned a bachelor's degree in philosophy from Williams College, followed by a classical theater training, and has 20 years’ experience as a New York professional actor, working in theater, commercials, and television daytime dramas. He recently narrated the Epoch Times audiobook “How the Specter of Communism is Ruling Our World,” which is available on iTunes and Audible. Mr. Jackson is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic.
Related Topics