Hatch Chile Fever

Green chile season is heating up in New Mexico, where the fiery peppers are an indispensable part of the local cuisine—and daily life
By Eric Lucas
Eric Lucas
Eric Lucas
Eric Lucas is a retired associate editor at Alaska Beyond Magazine and lives on a small farm on a remote island north of Seattle, where he grows organic hay, beans, apples, and squash.
August 25, 2021 Updated: August 25, 2021

“First I turn the heat way up. Then I dial it back down.”

Hoisting a 40-pound burlap sack of green chiles into the gas-fired roaster at Chile Fanatic in Hatch, New Mexico, Jesus Soto explained how he prepares the surrounding valley’s famous peppers. The flames roared; chiles tumbled in the rotating wire cage; the thick, sharp scent spread through the store. Soto stood by the controls administering his prescription: high heat, then low.

He might just as well have been describing the quintessential New Mexico dinner: chips and salsa; flat enchiladas blanketed with green chile—the name for both the peppers and the stew made from them—and topped with a fried egg; and a moderating dessert of sopaipillas with honey butter.

Roasting chiles
High heat, then low: Jesus Soto roasts freshly harvested Hatch green chiles at Chile Fanatic in Hatch, N.M.Every late summer to fall, local roasting stands fill the air with the thick, smoky scent of roasting chiles. (Eric Lucas)

These chiles are the centerpiece of the meal, which is itself the pinnacle of New Mexico cuisine, a distinctive craft in which the Land of Enchantment takes such pride in that it has adopted the slogan “Chile Capital of the World,” made chiles the official state food, and designated “Red or green?” the “official state question,” referring to which kind of chile diners prefer on their enchiladas. The harvest begins most years in late July and extends into October; the Labor Day Hatch Chile Festival, which is like a county fair, is the centerpiece of the season.

New Mexico State University and its Chile Pepper Institute is the world’s leading institution for the study and propagation of chiles. Horticulturists there were responsible for breeding the varieties that kicked off the state’s chile production industry in the early 20th century.

Today, New Mexico leads the United States in chile production: more than 68,000 tons a year. And while there are numerous places in the state where many kinds of chile are grown, the Hatch Valley is the capital—its 30,000 arable acres are responsible for a third of the state’s production. Add in adjoining areas, and the Hatch region produces 80 percent of the state’s chiles.

“The stars are all aligned right here for the best chile-growing,” said local grower Keith Franzoy, who farms 60 acres of chiles. “We have the alkaline soil, water for irrigation, warm days, and cool nights chiles need. I know I’m biased, but … ours are the best.”

In a broad floodplain along the Rio Grande a half-hour north of Las Cruces, thunderheads built over the Black Mountains in the northwest distance and columns of rain sent pearlescent shafts to the ground. In the fields, lush green plants drooped with heavy loads of chiles—thick-walled varieties for harvesting green and roasting, and thinner Sandia types that’ll ripen to rubies and be dried for ristras, chile powder, and just plain decoration.

Franzoy is a descendant of the first family to begin growing chile commercially in the valley. Ironically, his great-grandparents were from Austria, immigrants who left Europe in 1917 to escape the ravages of World War I. At first, they thought the hot chiles their neighbors grew in backyard gardens were dangerous (a sentiment first-time chile tasters often still feel today). But Joseph Franzoy and his family grew to love the chiles, began to produce and sell them in the valley, and initiated an industry.

Agricultural,Field,Of,Hatch,Valley,Red,And,Green,Chiles,During
Chile fields in Hatch, New Mexico, the self-proclaimed “Chile Capital of the World.” (Giovanni Nastukov/Shutterstock)

Chiles of the World

Those first chiles were what are called landrace varieties, a term referring to crop types that people develop by saving seeds and adapting them to their specific growing area.

“Chiles and chile seeds were no doubt traded up and down the Rio Grande Valley for centuries among indigenous peoples, then Hispanic settlers,” said Stephanie Walker, an associate professor at New Mexico State who came to New Mexico as a child and has spent her entire adult life studying and adapting chile varieties. “The distinctive chiles so familiar today date back to the early 20th century.”

Now, she noted, “I can’t imagine daily life without chile.”

In the world, there are literally thousands of chile types. They originated in Mesoamerica and spread rapidly across the globe after Christopher Columbus brought New World foods back to Europe. In Africa, southern Europe, Asia, and the Pacific, backyard growers did their own breeding, just as New Mexico growers did.

Of those thousands of chile types, the ones that form the backbone of Hatch pepper production are called—surprise—“New Mexican pod” varieties, and the original types have been supplemented often with new cultivars developed at New Mexico State.

Chile farming today is vastly different from a century ago. Most of the fields have buried drip irrigation that feeds steady moisture to the plant roots. A six-year rotation schedule fends off soil-borne diseases; when they aren’t growing chiles, Hatch farmers produce alfalfa, onions, and cotton, among other crops.

The Hatch Chile Association has obtained a federal type certificate and a trademark for chiles grown there. But there’s more than one kind of “Hatch chile,” ranging from modern mild types to older, hotter varieties. Charger chiles, a medium-hot favorite grown to be used green, can range from 500 to 3500 on the Scoville scale (which extends past 1 million for ghost peppers and such); Big Jims are milder, Anaheim-like; Sandias are hotter and grown for ripening; Lumbres are hotter still, and the list goes on.

And if the list of thousands of chile varieties, all with different shapes, colors, flavors, and levels of heat, isn’t complex enough, consider that all of those chile types produce fruits that vary from plant to plant—sometimes from pod to pod on the same plant.

Traditional,Outdoor,New,Mexico,Ristra's
Some chiles are ripened and dried to make ristras. (KevinCupp/Shutterstock)

Hooked on the Heat

I taste-tested this in a field of Charger chiles with Preston Mitchell, another Franzoy descendant who helped build Hatch’s chile fame with his company, The Hatch Chile Store (Hatch-Green-Chile.com). Mitchell’s business has no storefront. Instead, the company ships chiles (fresh, roasted, and dried) and value-added chile products across the country and around the world. On assignment in Australia for two years and miss green chile? Mitchell’s workers will get it to you. Rellenos, powders, and canned chiles are all available through the wonders of modern commerce.

In one of the fields from where he buys chiles, Mitchell handed me a green pod as pretty as an emerald. I broke it open and took a bite: It had a mild, juicy, and slight acrid aftertaste. Then I tried one that was already crimson ripe: Now there’s a sharp bite of capsaicin, the alkaloid that gives chile its heat. I smiled. The deep color; full-bodied, citrusy juice; and earthy after-taste are lush and evocative.

“We provide people a connection to happiness,” Mitchell said of his business, which ships 2 million pounds of chiles per year. “People will order 250 pounds, invite friends and family, throw a party in their backyard, and roast the chiles.”

Preston chiles
Preston Mitchell stands in a field of Charger chiles. His company, The Hatch Chile Store, ships Hatch chiles and chile products across the country and around the world. (Eric Lucas)

My introduction to green chile came on my 18th birthday at a long-gone restaurant in Albuquerque’s North Valley. The restaurant was an old territorial adobe set amid autumn-gold cottonwoods along the Rio Grande; the evening light was butterscotch; the breeze lifted the day’s warmth into the trees. My girlfriend, a New Mexico native, ordered for me—that quintessential plate of flat enchiladas with green chile and an egg on top.

My palate sizzled with capsaicin. Sweat poured down my face. Endorphins fizzed in my veins like butter. It was the start of a lifelong love affair, and chiles have been a constant in my diet ever since. I grow my own and hang a ristra of dried New Mexico chiles in my kitchen as a key ingredient in winter stews—it’s marvelous with lamb, for example.

“Once you get hooked, you can’t get unhooked,” declared Keith Franzoy, whose family and friends around the country require him to ship them chiles. “It’s an addiction, but it’s a good one.”

RECIPE: Green Chile Stew

Eric Lucas
Eric Lucas
Eric Lucas is a retired associate editor at Alaska Beyond Magazine and lives on a small farm on a remote island north of Seattle, where he grows organic hay, beans, apples, and squash.