Film Review: ‘The Alpinist’: Like ‘Free Solo’ but Significantly More Insane

Mark Jackson
1/18/2023
Updated:
1/5/2024
Rock climbing and alpinism have exploded into the public consciousness since climbing’s Yosemite Valley golden era of the late 1960s. The groundbreaking climbers of those days were a peculiar type of long-haired, unwashed hippies, with killer abs, Popeye forearms, and Spiderman lats. And unlike their soft-male ‘70s counterparts, they were hard men with inner grit and supreme mental toughness.

The evolution of climbing styles and ethics has shifted around, at first ditching the adventurous spirit of Yosemite’s (trad climbing) halcyon days, to the safety of sport climbing, with all manner of subcultures and genres sprouting, such as “freebasing.”

Freebasing, having nothing to do with the cocaine version, is when you climb a hard route with no rope (normally known as “free soloing”). Except that you carry a parachute. If you fall off the climb your free solo automatically turns into a free base. Base-jumping is jumping off high, man-made and natural edifices with a parachute, instead of jumping out of a plane.

Master alpinist Marc-André Leclerc on the snow mushroom top of Torre Egger in Patagonia in "The Alpinist." (Red Bull Media House/Roadside Attractions)
Master alpinist Marc-André Leclerc on the snow mushroom top of Torre Egger in Patagonia in "The Alpinist." (Red Bull Media House/Roadside Attractions)

Free Alpinism

The world became aware of free soloing in 2018, with climber-director Jimmy Chin and wife Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi’s groundbreaking climbing doc “Free Solo,” which was released around the same time that co-directors Peter Mortimer and Nick Rosen were wrapping up the shooting of “The Alpinist.”

“Free Solo,” a stirring character study about climbing prodigy and fascinating personality Alex Honnold, also featured IMAX-quality, drone-camera-heavy filmmaking to capture Honnold’s unharnessed 3,000 foot ascent up Yosemite valley’s crown-jewel rock face, El Capitan—and won the Oscar for Best Documentary Feature.

Many comparison’s can be made between “Free Solo” and “The Alpinist,” but here’s the gist of it: “Free Solo” is about a mega-talented dude climbing 3,000 feet with no rope. “The Alpinist” is about even more mind-bogglingly talented alpine climber Marc-André Leclerc climbing routes approximately three times higher than El Cap, in wind, ice, snow, lots of gear, sleeping in thin sleeping bags directly in the snow, and standing on 16th-inch rock ledges using steel crampons and ice axes. Which can accidentally pop off the rock quicker than you can say “death fall.” And climbing large, frozen icicles that can also pop off rocks and shatter at a moment’s notice. And all of this … also with no rope.
Marc-André Leclerc bivouacing in "The Alpinist." (Red Bull Media House/Roadside Attractions)
Marc-André Leclerc bivouacing in "The Alpinist." (Red Bull Media House/Roadside Attractions)
In “The Aplinist,” Alex Honnold pays homage to Leclerc, bowing down, but also distinguishing his own competitive, sport-oriented approach from Leclerc’s chill, quasi-spiritual vertical vision-questing.

The Man Himself

The utterly guileless Leclerc is immensely charming, and while his shy, mildly inarticulate, slightly stoner-dude persona seems completely at odds with the shocking degree of extreme focus and physical prowess needed for his particular brand of adventure, he, much like Honnold (according to both their mothers) are strongly ADHD.

More and more the “Rain Man” aspects that used to be seen as a handicap are now recognized as the flip side of the genius needed to survive and thrive in the midst of these extreme lifestyle choices. When describing high mountain situations that normal people think of as absolutely horrifying, Leclerc, with a disarming goofy grin, nonchalantly uses terms such as “relaxing, just cruisin’ around.”

Mountain climber Marc-André Leclerc in "The Alpinist." (Red Bull Media House/Roadside Attractions)
Mountain climber Marc-André Leclerc in "The Alpinist." (Red Bull Media House/Roadside Attractions)

This endearing, complete lack of social media savvy and egoless presence are incredibly refreshing. Especially in a world where each younger generation becomes increasingly saturated with people using phone cameras as basketball air-pumps to inflate their own Instagram self-images.

There’s zero false modesty with Leclerc. He’s utterly disinterested in acclaim, glory, and especially Instagram likes. At one point, the directors are forced to abruptly regroup after Leclerc becomes bored with filming, disappears off the face of the Earth, only to start appearing on other climbers’ social media pages, having wandered off to enjoy good times with his climber buds. Leclerc’s is the purest, most Zen-like of reasons that climbers climb; not because the mountain is there, or to test himself, but simply because standing in the middle of extreme, death-defying situations is his bliss.

Marc-André Leclerc climbing a frozen waterfall that can disintegrate at a moment's notice in "The Alpinist." (Red Bull Media House/Roadside Attractions)
Marc-André Leclerc climbing a frozen waterfall that can disintegrate at a moment's notice in "The Alpinist." (Red Bull Media House/Roadside Attractions)

And the examples of this are truly astounding. The footage of Leclerc ascending sheer, near-featureless faces of granite and ice are so graceful, so defiant of physics, that it’s almost easy to forget just how unthinkably dangerous it all is. Unless you’ve had a bit of climbing experience yourself, in which case Leclerc’s vertiginous sorcery will leave you with no fingernails after the movie ends.

“The Alpinist,” while primarily a biopic, also spends significant time reinforcing the abundant risks of the sport in general (half of the world’s top alpinists meet the Reaper in high altitude situations, such as avalanches, falls, pulmonary and cerebral edema, hypothermia, wandering off course, rock and ice fall, and so on), ending on a solemn note that sets it apart from “Free Solo” and “The Dawn Wall.” “The Alpinist” leaves it up to audiences to access the risks versus the rewards of adventuring, while Leclerc’s peers struggle to justify his, and their own, recklessness.
“The Alpinist” delivers a highly entertaining and sometimes nerve-shredding cinematic experience. Leclerc doesn’t see his thrilling endeavors as reckless; he must do what he does. It’s his raison d'être. But his humble nature, bright spirit, and innate kindness to strangers are the things that remain with the viewer—the high moral things that those of us who have no talent for the high, frosty alpine pinnacles and spires, can aspire to.
Movie poster for "The Alpinist."
Movie poster for "The Alpinist."
‘The Alpinist’ Director: Peter Mortimer, Nick Rosen Documentary MPAA Rating: PG-13 Running time: 1 hour, 32 minutes Release Date: Sept. 10, 2021 Rating: 4 stars out of 5
Mark Jackson is the chief film critic for The Epoch Times. In addition to the world’s number-one storytelling vehicle—film, he enjoys martial arts, weightlifting, Harley-Davidsons, vision questing, rock-climbing, qigong, oil painting, and human rights activism. Mark earned a bachelor's degree in philosophy from Williams College, followed by a classical theater training, and has 20 years’ experience as a New York professional actor, working in theater, commercials, and television daytime dramas. He recently narrated the Epoch Times audiobook “How the Specter of Communism is Ruling Our World,” which is available on iTunes and Audible. Mr. Jackson is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic.
Related Topics