Online Series Review: ‘A Spy Among Friends’

3/11/2023
Updated:
3/11/2023

2023 | TV-MA | 6 episodes | Spy Thriller

They were the most privileged upper crust of British society. Sir Anthony Blunt was even the third cousin of the Queen Mum. However, the members of the so-called “Cambridge Five” spy ring were all committed communists, who betrayed their country to the Soviet Union. MI6 Intelligence Officer Nicholas Elliott (Damian Lewis) was not one of them, but he was very close friends with Harold Adrian Russell “Kim” Philby (Guy Pearce). That puts Elliott in a rather tight spot with rival domestic-focused British intelligence agency MI5 when he fails to capture (or kill) Philby in Beirut, after the double agent’s exposure.

Elliott’s relationship with Philby and his search for a further Soviet mole drive writer-creator Alex Cary’s fictionalized six-part “A Spy Among Friends,” based on Ben Macintyre’s historically based novel, which premieres on MGM+ (formerly Epix).

Much of the series unfolds in flashbacks, prompted by Elliott’s debriefing. MI5 Director General Sir Roger Hollis (Adrian Edmondson) has assigned Lily Thomas (Anna Maxwell Martin) to interrogate him, because he anticipated her no-nonsense, Margaret Thatcher-like, middle-class competence would rub the elitist Elliott the wrong way. Initially, the MI6 spy underestimates Thomas, as so many have before, but he quickly recognizes her keen intelligence.

MI6 Intelligence Officer Nicholas Elliott (Damian Lewis) hunts down spies in British intelligence. (Sony Pictures Television)
MI6 Intelligence Officer Nicholas Elliott (Damian Lewis) hunts down spies in British intelligence. (Sony Pictures Television)
Likewise, she grudgingly acknowledges Elliott is much smarter than most of the blue-blooded English elites that dominate the British intelligence services. They might even be able to work together, sniffing out further moles. However, Elliott still has a lot of explaining to do.

Friendship Over Honor

The MI6 spy did not merely let Philby slip through his fingers during their final meeting in Beirut. He also vociferously vouched for Philby when his friend and colleagues fell under suspicion years earlier, after the embarrassing defections of Donald Maclean and Guy Burgess (Daniel Lapaine and Thomas Arnold, in minor roles)—the first two identified members of the Cambridge Five.

Philby would be the third of the Five to be discovered. Soon, Elliott focuses on Blunt (Nicholas Rowe), trying to smoke out the fourth mole in the notorious spy ring. He also has suspicions regarding the so-called “Fifth Man,” which may or may not include Thomas’s boss, Hollis.

In real life, the MI5 director was not a member of the Cambridge Five, nor was he ever convicted of anything. However, there has been extensive media speculation suggesting Hollis was indeed a high-placed mole, even though several former agents claim he was exonerated.

There is also a significant American player in this drama: James Jesus Angleton (Stephen Kunken), the head of the CIA’s counter-intelligence operations, with whom Philby had also cultivated a close friendship. Although Angleton’s allegiances were never questioned, his long-term impact on the agency is highly controversial.

Lily Thomas (Anna Maxwell Martin) is assigned to work with Nicholas Elliott (Damian Lewis) to find spies, in "A Spy Among Friends." (Sony Pictures Television)
Lily Thomas (Anna Maxwell Martin) is assigned to work with Nicholas Elliott (Damian Lewis) to find spies, in "A Spy Among Friends." (Sony Pictures Television)

A la le Carré

There is some healthy fictional speculation in Macintyre’s novel and Cary’s adaptation, but the broad historical events it documents are true. Of course, it probably sounds familiar to readers of classic spy fiction, because John le Carré largely built his career on re-writing the Cambridge Five cases, most notably in “Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy.”

It is therefore fitting that “A Spy Among Friends” has a very le Carré-esque vibe. Cary and series director Nick Murphy advance the narrative in a meticulously methodical manner. Over and over, key events and conversations are replayed from different angles. In this series, much will turn on a word here, or a phrase there. That makes it quite rewarding for those who enjoy complex espionage thrillers, but it requires the viewer’s full attention.

“A Spy Among Friends” does not paint a particularly rosy picture of the UK’s intelligence services in the 1960s, but the extent to which the Cambridge Five compromised MI5 and MI6 is hard to spin. Furthermore, it never glamorizes the Soviet moles or whitewashes the brutality of Russian communism. Indeed, Elliott is deeply tormented by Philby’s betrayal, because of their many contacts, colleagues, and friends, who were viciously tortured and executed by the Soviets, thanks to Philby.

Spymaster Actors

Pearce does not exactly humanize Philby who is consistently portrayed as an arrogant sociopath, but he manages to cut him down to human size. Cary’s adaptation also implies Philby might have had second thoughts regarding his defection (which the real life Philby and his Russian widow always denied—because they had to). Regardless, in “A Spy Among Friends,” it turns out to be easier for Philby to admire the workers’ paradise from afar than to live under it.
Nicholas Elliott (Damian Lewis, L) was once close friends with Kim Philby (Guy Pearce), in "A Spy Among Friends." (ITV)
Nicholas Elliott (Damian Lewis, L) was once close friends with Kim Philby (Guy Pearce), in "A Spy Among Friends." (ITV)

Yet, perhaps the real star of the series is Damian Lewis, who is magnetic as the brilliant but humbled Elliott. His portrayal of the spymaster is also quite witty and sly, which helps make the very cerebral story more accessible. Anna Maxwell Martin is perfectly cast as Thomas, the patronized counter-spy; but she basically plays the same mousy-on-the-outside, steely-on-the-inside persona that she is accustomed to playing in a a host of other British series such as “The Bletchley Circle.”

Obviously, British intelligence went through quite the rough patch. This series compellingly shows all the infamous scandals from the perspective of the honest intelligence officers, who upheld the trust placed in them by their country and their colleagues. It is a carefully crafted, deliberately paced thriller that might not fully appeal to action-oriented James Bond fans (even though Bond author Ian Fleming makes a small but amusing appearance).

Enthusiastically recommended for fans of intricately plotted, fact-based espionage fiction, “A Spy Among Friends” starts streaming March 12.

Kim Philby (Guy Pearce) was once a close friend of M16 intelligence officer Nicholas Elliott (Damian Lewis) in "A Spy Among Friends." (MGM+)
Kim Philby (Guy Pearce) was once a close friend of M16 intelligence officer Nicholas Elliott (Damian Lewis) in "A Spy Among Friends." (MGM+)
‘A Spy Among Friends’ Director: Nick Murphy Starring: Damian Lewis, Guy Pearce, Anna Maxwell Martin Rating: TV-MA Running Time: 6 episodes Release Date: March 12, 2023 Rated: 4 stars out of 5
Joe Bendel writes about independent film and lives in New York. To read his most recent articles, visit JBSpins.blogspot.com
Related Topics