Film Review: ‘Stars at Noon’: A Star Rises for Andie MacDowell’s Daughter

Mark Jackson
10/17/2022
Updated:
1/5/2024

Trish Johnson (Margaret Qualley, daughter of actress-model Andie MacDowell of “Groundhog Day”) is an American journalist stuck in Nicaragua, having had her press credentials and passport yanked by the local authorities. She’s been reduced to begging for freelance travelogue-type journalism work, with a side-line of prostitution. She’d love to escape to Costa Rica.

Trish soon encounters Daniel DeHaven (Joe Alwyn), a blond, white-suited, surreptitiously gun-toting, well-connected British businessman. He’s mysterious but candid, sexy but shady, kindly but dangerous, which for some women is catnip, and is for Trish, too, but more alluring is the fact that he can pay $50 USD. And so there ensues much rum drinking and sex.

Margaret Qualley plays a struggling journalist and Joe Alwyn plays a mysterious businessman in Claire Denis’s “Stars at Noon.” (A24)
Margaret Qualley plays a struggling journalist and Joe Alwyn plays a mysterious businessman in Claire Denis’s “Stars at Noon.” (A24)

Their pasts don’t really matter; “Here, there, and yonder” is all she’ll answer when asked where she’s from. He’s married back home, and in-country for business instead of pleasure, but offers a bland, generic spy-type cover story when pressed, and won’t go into detail.

As mentioned, Trish is looking to escape to Costa Rica, but nothing really happens until authorities start trying to apprehend Daniel, and he’s forced out of his upscale hotel and into her ratty motel, where the thick air is stirred lazily by ceiling fans but not conditioned. More sex and rum.

Joe Alwyn and Margaret Qualley in Claire Denis’ “Stars at Noon.” (A24)
Joe Alwyn and Margaret Qualley in Claire Denis’ “Stars at Noon.” (A24)

What are their goals, dreams, ambitions? How does this story fit into the context of the larger world around them? Few answers. Those types of basic elements of storytelling (the who’s, what’s, where’s and why’s) would appear to be treated with a Gallic “pfffft!” and eye-roll by French director Claire Denis. What are we to make of these two? The French (and Europeans in general) love these types of long-winded, slowly meandering stories where nothing ever really happens.

Of course, it’s not all that hard to guess early on that there’s more to Daniel than just business interests. Is he a secret agent man? He’s being shadowed by a Costa Rican policeman (Danny Ramirez, who played a pilot in “Top Gun: Maverick”) with follow-up by an American consultant (Benny Safdie). “Consultant” of course is the standard euphemism for “OGA” (Other Government Agency) and “OGA” is the standard euphemism for CIA.

Joe Alwyn plays a mysterious businessman in Claire Denis’s “Stars at Noon.” (A24)
Joe Alwyn plays a mysterious businessman in Claire Denis’s “Stars at Noon.” (A24)

Time and Place

Since her first feature film, 1988’s “Chocolat,” director Denis, who grew up in West Africa with a French civil servant father, likes to deconstruct the problematic influence of Western nations on Third World countries.

In 1984 (the time depicted in the original book), Nicaragua was governed by the Sandinistas and threatened by the U.S.-backed Contras; it was a particularly dangerous time for an American journalist. That much rings true.

However, the story’s been reset to 2021, with streets still empty due to COVID-19. Masks abound. And so this mish-mash of empty streets plus lots of heavily armed 1984-era paramilitary police with automatic weapons standing guard on ubiquitous COVID tents, creates the unintended and slightly disturbing (or is it comical?) effect of depicting the Nicaraguans as having been very, very, very, very serious about folks getting the jab.

There’s definitely an atmosphere of colonialism with a Brit and an American carnally cavorting and bringing their problems and privilege to the Central American jungle, swaggering around like they own the place and dragging the locals into their drama.

But it’s not enough to sustain two-plus hours of runtime. Not even close. Here’s what is interesting, and what the movie really qualifies as: Margaret Qualley’s jumping off point to superstardom.

Qualley

You can always tell when a star is about to be born, like Julia Roberts in “Mystic Pizza,” Matt Damon in “Courage Under Fire,” Brad Pitt in “Thelma and Louise,” Jack Black in “Bob Roberts,” Tim Robbins in “Bull Durham,” Scarlett Johansson in “Ghost World,” and Emma Stone in “Superbad.”

You could already tell with Margeret Qualley from her brief turn in “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood” as the young hippie-chick Pussycat, pressing her dirty bare feet onto the windshield of Brad Pitt’s character’s beige Cadillac. It’s interesting to try and describe the elusive “it” factor. Qualley definitely has it, as do the most mesmerizing movie stars.

Rainey Qualley (L) and Margaret Qualley. (Getty Images)
Rainey Qualley (L) and Margaret Qualley. (Getty Images)

Model-actress Andie MacDowell has two daughters, Margaret and Rainey, with one more model-y and one more actress-y—Margaret being the actress-y one. Which is not to say she’s not also fairly model-y; she’s got her mom’s catwalk body and fountain of wavy black hair. But here’s the physical “it” factor: like Susan Sarandon, she’s got a large degree of white surrounding her greenish-blue irises, which creates that disturbing, glowing orb look that horror movie directors love to cast women with these types of eyes for.

What the rarified quality of powerful actor charisma really is, though, is an ability to live so intensely in the moment, in a place of inner stillness, that the choices made by one’s subconsciousness actually surprise the actor’s consciousness in the moment. Which means they never know what’s coming next. Which means we the audience also don’t know what’s coming next, and so we feel compelled to pay close attention so as to not miss any of the surprises.

Am I going on too long about this? Yes, but “Stars at Noon” consists mostly of Qualley schlepping around in ratty huarache sandals and scanty sundresses, hitting up local officials and whomever she can for drinks, sex, and meals, walking the streets of Managua to a mostly depressing improvised jazz score. And just due to sheer animal magnetism, she makes the movie almost interesting for the first 45 minutes. The titular stars do come out at noon on one occasion—visible stars in a bright blue sky. I still haven’t figured out what that has to do with the story—0ther than that Qualley’s personal star will soon be at zenith.
Movie poster for "Stars at Noon"
Movie poster for "Stars at Noon"
‘Stars at Noon’ Director: Claire Denis Starring: Margaret Qualley, Joe Alwyn, Benny Safdie, Danny Ramirez, John C. Reilly MPAA Rating: R Running Time: 2 hours, 15 minutes Release Date: Oct. 14, 2022 Rating: 2 stars out of 5
Mark Jackson is the chief film critic for The Epoch Times. In addition to the world’s number-one storytelling vehicle—film, he enjoys martial arts, weightlifting, Harley-Davidsons, vision questing, rock-climbing, qigong, oil painting, and human rights activism. Mark earned a bachelor's degree in philosophy from Williams College, followed by a classical theater training, and has 20 years’ experience as a New York professional actor, working in theater, commercials, and television daytime dramas. He recently narrated the Epoch Times audiobook “How the Specter of Communism is Ruling Our World,” which is available on iTunes and Audible. Mr. Jackson is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic.
Related Topics