Film Review: ‘Avatar: The Way of Water’: Mostly Outstanding

Mark Jackson
12/21/2022
Updated:
1/5/2024

The biggest cinematic mistake I made this year was getting impatient, and watching “Avatar: The Way of Water” in 2D. Do not do this! I need to watch it again, in its natural habitat of 3D and IMAX. And if I feel compelled to see a film twice, in a short period of time, it gets an automatic 4.5 out of 5 stars. So 3D will put “Avatar” at a solid 5 stars.

Let me just quickly say at the outset that, while the movie is amazing in terms of the magic cinema it has to offer, I have an issue with one of the story’s themes: its let’s-kill-humans-and-save-the-planets narrative. More on this later.

Ambition: Oscar

That said, if there was an Oscar for pure ambition, director James Cameron’s rivals might as well just forget about it. His original “Avatar” (2009), a 3D action epic about 9-foot-tall, blue-skinned, tiger-striped, green-eyed extraterrestrials, remains, by some measures, the most successful movie ever made.
Neytiri (Zoe Saldana) and Jake Sully (Sam Worthington) fleeing their jungle home for an ocean-based lifestyle, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Neytiri (Zoe Saldana) and Jake Sully (Sam Worthington) fleeing their jungle home for an ocean-based lifestyle, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
“Avatar: The Way of Water” (it’s definitely a franchise now) throws every kind of popular appeal up against the wall to see what sticks—and it pretty much all sticks. The paradoxes inherent in its themes automatically provide enough tension to make it riveting. That is, it’s family-friendly but violent, militaristic but pacifistic; and it pays homage to the beauty of nature by showcasing overwhelming, gut-churning, government-mandated, capitalist rape and exploitation of pristine planets.
Neytiri (Zoe Saldana) and Jake Sully (Sam Worthington), in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Neytiri (Zoe Saldana) and Jake Sully (Sam Worthington), in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
James Cameron is modern cinema’s greatest advocate of the power of big-screen spectacle. And “Avatar: The Way of Water” runs the gamut of a visual feast of sublimely colored fantasy landscapes, the rousing action-spectacle of tribal versus U.S. military battles on sea, air, and land, and fantastic beasts of all of the above environments—all nailed down with the kind of trippy hyperrealism that only a hyperambitious manic-obsessive artist with an operating budget of nearly half a billion can pull off.

What’s most impressive about “The Way of Water” are the nature-appreciation themes, and the honoring of the lost traditions of the human community and tribal life. And while the wondrous world of Pandora can be taken as utopian and idealistic, Cameron grounds all of the above in life’s inherent messiness, as well as the bonds we all form, while at the same time reminding us of how simple it is to achieve happiness.

Lo'ak (Britain Dalton) swimming with his giant new whale friend, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Lo'ak (Britain Dalton) swimming with his giant new whale friend, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)

Quick Recap

Underlying their science fiction trappings, the “Avatar” films are basically an extended romantic adventure tale about a colonizer who “goes off the reservation” and “native,” a tradition that’s as long and venerable as the art of storytelling itself.

By the end of the first “Avatar” film, former Marine Jake Sully (Sam Worthington) had abandoned his human body to live an avatar life as a Na’vi (aforementioned blue aliens), who live in tribal harmony with nature on Pandora, an idyllic, lush, triple-canopy jungle moon situated a galaxy away from Earth, where all the flora is luminescent and all the fauna have two sets of eyes. In the 13 years between the films, Jake Sully and his Na’vi mate Neytiri (Zoe Saldana) have raised four children.

Jake then leads a band of Na’vi insurgents against the resource-hoovering “Sky People” (human invaders). Jake’s former commanding officer, Miles Quaritch (Stephen Lang), the first film’s villain, returns as an even bigger threat because now he’s got his own Na’vi avatar body (with memories and personality uploaded)—all the better to infiltrate the natives. His transformation, however, is strictly camouflage; in his heart he remains a semper fi, gung-ho jarhead with the sole mission of ending Jake Sully.

Is that perhaps some ridiculous pseudoscience silliness? All of the “Avatar” franchise is pure pseudoscientific bunk. So are the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the DC Universe, and most movies ever made. Who cares? What’s important is that Stephen Lang’s powerful performance will make you forget all that.

On the Lam

Jake and his family are forced to flee, and eventually they take refuge with an ocean-dwelling clan known as the Metkayina. This is where one almost expects to see plaques like at New York’s Museum of Natural History: “Metkayina, a subspecies of Aquatic Na’vi.” They’re turquoise-skinned, have more tribal tats and bigger muscles, plus marine-adaptations such as a finned tail, and broad, fin-like forearms.
Two warrior chieftains meet: Jake Sully (Sam Worthington) greets Tonowari (Cliff Curtis), in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Two warrior chieftains meet: Jake Sully (Sam Worthington) greets Tonowari (Cliff Curtis), in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)

But before Colonel Quaritch arrives, there’s plenty of time for the family to get situated in their new digs, go exploring, and for all the combined tribal kids to make friends (and rivalries) and take us with them on adventures.

Each of Jake’s four kids play a pivotal role. While Jake may no longer be human, he’s still the kind of powerful Southern military father whose kids show respect and call him “sir.” However, younger son Lo’ak (Britain Dalton), unlike his older brother, is not his dad’s pride and joy and has trouble adjusting to aquatic life and marine hunting grounds, and feels like a n’er-do-well in his dad’s eyes.

Sons of Sully: Older brother Neteyam (Jamie Flatters, L) and Lo'ak (Britain Dalton) try to fit in with the ways of their hosting tribe, the Metkayina, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Sons of Sully: Older brother Neteyam (Jamie Flatters, L) and Lo'ak (Britain Dalton) try to fit in with the ways of their hosting tribe, the Metkayina, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)

Lo’ak is the movie’s emotional core. His loneliness and his eventually finding sanctuary in the ocean, with its exciting creatures, is as touching on an emotional level as the underwater sequences and visuals are truly gorgeous.

Lo'ak (Britain Dalton) bonding with his harpoon-wounded whale friend when he realizes they are both outcasts, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Lo'ak (Britain Dalton) bonding with his harpoon-wounded whale friend when he realizes they are both outcasts, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)

More on the Kids

Kiri (Sigourney Weaver) is Jake Sully's adopted daughter, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Kiri (Sigourney Weaver) is Jake Sully's adopted daughter, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)

Sigourney Weaver plays a dual role here, in flashbacks as Dr. Grace Augustine of the first “Avatar” and also as Kiri, who was born of Grace’s Na’vi body (talk about pseudoscience). While it’s a bit of a stretch for 73-year-old Weaver to play a 14-year-old teen, she turns in such a highly convincing, youthful performance that one can’t imagine anyone else in the role.

Spider (Jack Champion) and Kiri (Sigourney Weaver) fight the U.S. Marines trying to capture Jake Sully, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Spider (Jack Champion) and Kiri (Sigourney Weaver) fight the U.S. Marines trying to capture Jake Sully, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Then, there’s Colonel Quaritch’s kid, Miles (Jack Champion), who was too young to be transported back to Earth and was raised on Pandora with the Na’vi and the handful of human scientists allowed to remain on Pandora. Quaritch’s avatar is not technically Miles’s (now nicknamed “Spider”) dad. Spider is like one of those hopping kittens raised in a rabbit litter.

But there’s an undeniable bond between father and son. Their relationship is powerful and conflicted as father-son bonds tend to be, and further complicated by the fact that Quaritch is a mission-obsessed, merciless killer-Marine, but also undeniably human and actually surprisingly relatable.

Marine Col. Quaritch (Stephen Lang) in his avatar form (L) and human form on the computer screen, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
Marine Col. Quaritch (Stephen Lang) in his avatar form (L) and human form on the computer screen, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)

Overall

The calm first hour of “The Way of Water” is worth sitting through to get to the action-packed climax (which puts all Marvel and DC equivalents to shame), not to mention the sheer beauty of the colors and creatures. It builds excitingly throughout, and peaks in its final hour with probably the best action sequences of Cameron’s career.

The film is a refreshing ode to traditional family values, and while the whole story line about settling into a new home has an enjoyable 1950s’ vibe, the scale is ultimately grand, the stakes immense, and the final sea battle filled with incredible moments and even humor.

The talented and intuitive Kiri (Sigourney Weaver) learns to hold her breath interminably, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)
The talented and intuitive Kiri (Sigourney Weaver) learns to hold her breath interminably, in "Avatar: The Way of Water." (20th Century Studios)

As mentioned at the outset, “Avatar: The Way of Water” is the one film you absolutely must see in 3D and IMAX. And while this ocean-going version of Pandora is unquestionably the film’s greatest character in the same way the jungle version was before it, and while the Sully family is captivating, and things don’t wrap up as cleanly as in the original (it’s gotta set the stage for the third chapter), this episode still feels complete and totally satisfying.

If for nothing else, see the film to enjoy this smorgasbord of visual marine delights, bequeathed to us with love by the director who digs the sea so much that in 2012, he spent a record-breaking six hours in a submersible, diving 2.3 miles down in the pitch-black ocean all by himself to the notorious Mariana Trench. Talk about your thorough research.

In conclusion, while this film is lots of fun, the main problem with the “Avatar” movies is that they’re couched in Cameron’s hippy-ish ethos of planet saving, as well as hammering on the fact that this is capitalism gone wrong (as in government-backed), and makes the military look absolutely heinous. Add to that the fact that this “Avatar” links the military exploitation with a fictitious, Aussie-led, super-techno-sophisticated whaling outfit on planet Pandora, and a truly excruciating whale-hunt scene such that “Avatar” will have you hating the U.S. military.

That’s just not good. And so I’m giving “Avatar: The Way of Water” a 5 out of 5 for movie magic, and a 2.5 out of 5 for subversive themes that are ultimately destructive to society. I do applaud its family values, though—too bad it’s not humans with those human values.

“Avatar: The Way of Water” is in cinemas from Dec. 15.
Movie poster for "Avatar: The Way of Water"
Movie poster for "Avatar: The Way of Water"
‘Avatar: The Way of Water’ Director: James Cameron Starring: Sam Worthington, Zoe Saldana, Sigourney Weaver, Stephen Lang, Kate Winslet, Cliff Curtis, Jamie Flatters, Britain Dalton, Jack Champion MPAA Rating: PG-13 Running Time: 3 hours, 12 minutes Release Date: Dece.15, 2022 Rating: 5 stars out of 5
Mark Jackson is the chief film critic for The Epoch Times. In addition to the world’s number-one storytelling vehicle—film, he enjoys martial arts, weightlifting, Harley-Davidsons, vision questing, rock-climbing, qigong, oil painting, and human rights activism. Mark earned a bachelor's degree in philosophy from Williams College, followed by a classical theater training, and has 20 years’ experience as a New York professional actor, working in theater, commercials, and television daytime dramas. He recently narrated the Epoch Times audiobook “How the Specter of Communism is Ruling Our World,” which is available on iTunes and Audible. Mr. Jackson is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic.
Related Topics