Everyday Ethics: The Short Story ‘The Idiot’s Journalism Scheme’

John Kendrick Bangs’ story from the turn of the 20th century examines what matters more in the news: sensational tales or stories of real virtue.
Everyday Ethics: The Short Story ‘The Idiot’s Journalism Scheme’
Newspapers are displayed at a newsstand in San Francisco on Oct. 26, 2009. Whatever the paper, readers can be sure that juicy stories abound. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Kate Vidimos
Updated:
0:00
Published as Chapter 6 in his book “The Idiot” (1895), John Kendrick Bangs’ short story “The Idiot’s Journalism Scheme,” shows how simple-minded people (as sometimes perceived by others) more aptly recognize the truth than others. For, in their simple thoughts, they grasp truth more readily than their critics.
A 1922 photograph of John Kendrick Bangs, writer and satirist. (Public Domain)
A 1922 photograph of John Kendrick Bangs, writer and satirist. Public Domain

The Meditative Idiot

Though they criticize the Idiot for being “thoughtless,” the School-Master and the Bibliomaniac grow nervous when the Idiot becomes meditative. They fear that “he is conspiring with himself against them.”

In an attempt to disrupt the Idiot’s meditations, the School-Master and Bibliomaniac ask him what he’s thinking. The Idiot merely states that he has a business plan. He considers sharing it with the Bibliomaniac and a Mr. Pedagog. All he “requires [is] capital and the assistance of those two gentlemen to launch it on the sea of prosperity.”

When asked what area he will pursue, the Idiot says, “Journalism.” He believes that, if he pursues his current idea in journalism, his exploit will be worth millions. Should any of the gentlemen present consider investing, they will double their money by the next year.

The Idiot explains that he will start a new newspaper. However, the new paper isn’t the key. Rather, the idea that the paper contains is the key: “I propose to start a new paper in accordance with the plan which the idea contains,” he says.

The paper will be a daily paper, but his will be different from any other daily newspaper. The Idiot even mentions the unique invention of the “evening post”: “I know of an evening paper the second edition of which is published at mid-day. That’s an old dodge, and there’s money in it, too—money that will never be got out of it.”

Yet the Idiot emphasizes that, no matter what time of day the papers are published, they all function under the same ideas. Most of the dailies “go in for every horrid detail of daily events.” Every day brings the same mundane news, so that everyone knows who committed the crime and who was the victim.

Every Day Ethics

The Idiot goes on to say that his newspaper seeks to break away from the ideas that the others follow. Rather than focusing on and highlighting all of the bad that happens, his paper will focus on the good, or “telling what hasn’t happened.”

For example, the Idiot says that his newspaper will say something like: “‘Superintendent Smithers, of the St. Goliath’s Sunday-school, who is also cashier in the Forty-eighth National Bank, has not absconded with $4,000,000.’” By stating this, the newspaper doesn’t give fame to vices, but rather highlights the virtues of “Superintendent Smithers.”

Through this story, Bangs showed how the supposed “thoughtless” Idiot possesses simple ideas that successfully grasp the basic human desire for good news and virtue. His “thoughtless” ideas seek to build up the human character by highlighting characters worth emulating.

Whether literature or expository writing in a newspaper, the written word has the power to inspire. (Biba Kayewich)
Whether literature or expository writing in a newspaper, the written word has the power to inspire. Biba Kayewich

In “The World Crisis Vol 2: 1915,” Winston Churchill encapsulates the significance of Bangs’ story when he said: “The conviction came into my mind with absolute assurance that the simple soldiers and their regimental officers, armed with their cause, would by their virtues in the end retrieve the mistakes and ignorances of Staffs and Cabinets, of Admirals, Generals and politicians.”

Thus, by being simple, the Idiot rises above those who seem to be his superiors. His simple-mindedness finds the beautiful every day ethics which breath light into the mundane world.

What arts and culture topics would you like us to cover? Please email ideas or feedback to [email protected]
Kate Vidimos
Kate Vidimos
Author
Kate Vidimos is a 2020 graduate from the liberal arts college at the University of Dallas, where she received her bachelor’s degree in English. She plans on pursuing all forms of storytelling (specifically film) and is currently working on finishing and illustrating a children’s book.