Ask the Builder: Why Tiny Houses Are Big, Bad Ideas

Living in a tiny house on your own might be doable but add in another person and you could have trouble.
Ask the Builder: Why Tiny Houses Are Big, Bad Ideas
This is a tiny house built on a trailer frame. It’s nearly identical in size to any common travel camper. Would you like to live out your life in a home this small? (Tim Carter/Tribune Content Agency/TNS)
2/2/2024
Updated:
2/2/2024

I live in central New Hampshire on the west shore of Lake Winnisquam. This is the third-largest lake in the state. I kayak on the crystal-clear water as often as possible. The state owns the 7.2 square miles of water, but citizens own any islands that dot the lake.

Due east of my boat dock is a very small island that is less than 2,000 square feet in size. It’s about 50 feet in diameter. On this island is a tiny house. Several years ago, I was kayaking on a glorious summer day and saw the owners outside eating lunch sitting at a picnic table near their dock.

“Hello!“ I said. ”I’m Tim Carter. I live just across the lake from you. In the winter I often see a glow coming from your window that faces my house. Do you live here year-round?”

The older couple invited me to come sit with them. They were like teenage sweethearts and had a strong glow about them. We chatted about how they do live on the island year round. I was astonished, to say the least.

Their tiny house measured only 12 feet by 20 feet as best as I could estimate. That’s 240 square feet. It was smaller than a two-story shed I had built the previous year up above my leach field. I built my shed as a tiny house, and I sell the plans to folks on a regular basis.

After sharing a drink with them, I departed and kayaked around the other two larger islands. I couldn’t get my mind off how two people could live year-round in a nothing more than a very small cabin. As I paddled back to my dock, I decided to research how big the average log cabin was that settlers built centuries ago.

It turns out the average size of a log cabin built in the Northeast was 16 feet long by 14 feet wide. That’s 224 square feet of living area.

Are you entranced with the concept of downsizing and moving into a tiny house? Think of how small your heating and cooling bills would be. Imagine how fast you could clean your entire house! Ponder how long it might be before you’d quarrel with your significant other unless you were constantly bumping beaks like the lovebirds that live across the lake from me.

There are all sorts of advantages to living in a tiny house. We already know it’s possible, as our ancestors did it. There are also many disadvantages of compacting your lifestyle into a space not much bigger than a motel room.

The best way, in my opinion, to test your ability to survive in a tiny house is to rent a travel camper for a week. Take it to a local campground and hook it up to the on-site utilities so you can enjoy all the comforts of electricity, running water and sewer. Keep in mind not all campgrounds have a sewer connection. Without this important convenience, you’ll be stunned how fast you’ll fill up your onboard sewage holding tank.

My guess is you’ll find the first day somewhat fun and interesting. You’ll marvel at how the camper designers have made use of every cubic inch of storage space. This is very important to do in a tiny house as well.

If you conduct this test solo, you’ll have a much better chance of survival. If you have a partner, I predict by the late afternoon of the second day, thoughts will cross your mind about what excuse you can make to take a hike or make your sixth trip of the day to the campground general store.

By midweek, a large tear will develop in the fabric of your relationship. The smallest character flaw will balloon into grounds for a divorce. Your mood will darken.

My guess is that on the fifth day you’ll be calling the campground rental office to see if you can get a discount for returning the camper two days early. Your nerves will be as raw as a fresh trout you snagged from the campground lake.

What are you going to do with all your stuff? Do you park your car and pickup outside because your garage looks like a hoarder’s paradise? When you make the decision to live in a tiny house, all your stuff becomes flotsam and jetsam as you hand the keys of your large, traditional home to the new owner. Think long and hard about how you can live without all your books, memorabilia, clothes, shoes, Christmas decorations and so forth.

You now know why I’m known in my household as the Dream Crusher. I didn’t come up with the nickname, my kids did. Every time they’d float some idea at the dinner table, I’d start to ask questions. It was the realist in me.

I’m also old enough to remember the craze over geodesic dome houses and A-frames, among other housing fads. If you notice, you don’t see many of those around where you live. There’s a reason. I believe the tiny house fad has also floundered on the reef of silly ideas. If I’ve crushed your dream of living in one, trust me, you’ll thank me at some point.

Dear Readers: We would love to hear from you. What topics would you like to read about? Please send your feedback and tips to [email protected].
Tim Carter is the founder of AsktheBuilder.com. He's an amateur radio operator and enjoys sending Morse code sitting at an actual telegrapher's desk. Carter lives in central New Hampshire with his wife, Kathy, and their dog, Willow. Subscribe to his FREE newsletter at AsktheBuilder.com. He now does livestreaming video M-F at 4 PM Eastern Time at youtube.com/askthebuilder. (C)2022 Tim Carter. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
Related Topics