To Prevent Diabetes, One-Size-Fits-All Won’t Work

April 25, 2015 Updated: April 24, 2015

Groups of adults at risk for diabetes harbor different perceptions of the disease, say researchers. The findings could lead to new approaches for education and prevention.

“We found that there are differences in the perceptions of those who are at risk for diabetes that depend on the specific characteristics that place them at risk,” says Shiela Strauss, associate professor of nursing and co-director of the statistics and data management core for NYU’s Colleges of Nursing and Dentistry.

Illness perceptions, the organized cognitive representations and beliefs that people hold about a condition, are recognized as important determinants of self-care behaviors and outcomes in patients. The way that people mentally represent their conditions has a concrete effect on how they manage these conditions and therefore on their prognoses.

With illness perceptions strongly linked to patient outcomes, Strauss’ research, the first in the field to examine illness perceptions in persons at-risk for diabetes based on their individual risk factors, may be influential in designing care to better fit patients on a case-by-case basis.

Strauss and colleagues assessed each participant’s general diabetes knowledge and administered a questionnaire to measure eight dimensions of diabetes illness perceptions among the sample.

They used the data to examine statistically significant differences among the eight dimensions of diabetes illness perceptions according to the presence or absence of their diabetes risk factors.

Perceptions Vary

Among the findings, researchers note that compared to those who had a first-degree relative with diabetes, those who did not were less concerned that they might have diabetes, reported a poorer understanding of the disease, and were less emotionally affected by the possibility of a future diagnosis.

There was also a statistically significant difference in the same three components of illness perceptions according to Latino ethnicity. In particular, those of Latino ethnicity were more concerned that they might have diabetes, reported that they had a better understanding of diabetes, and were more affected emotionally by the possibility of having diabetes, when compared to those not of Latino ethnicity.

The study also found that individuals with a body mass index (BMI) of 25 kg/m2 or more believed that diabetes would have a greater effect on their lives if they developed it, and demonstrated a greater understanding of diabetes when compared to those with a lower BMI.

In addition, persons of at-risk races (black, Native American, Asian, Pacific Islander), as compared with those whose race did not place them at increased risk for diabetes, believed that diabetes would endure for less time, that they would have more personal control over diabetes, that treatment would help their illness, and that they had a better understanding of diabetes.

Due to the progressive nature of diabetes, Strauss stresses the importance of understanding illness perceptions and self-care. According to Strauss, “tailoring diabetes education and outreach to an individual’s perceptions of diabetes can maximize self-care behaviors, and reduce adverse outcomes.”

Differences Among Patients

Because individuals with pre-diabetes—a precursor to diabetes that is characterized by early metabolic abnormalities—may be able to reverse the course of the condition and prevent it from developing into diabetes, Strauss suggests that tailoring diabetes education and outreach to an individual’s perceptions could positively transform the field’s approach and effectiveness in treating the growing diabetes epidemic.

The findings of this study indicate that some diabetes illness perceptions among those at risk for diabetes or with prediabetes may be different from those with frank diabetes.

“It is important for diabetes educators to recognize that these differences exist and to incorporate these differences in their patient education. It’s not one size fits all,” says Strauss.

According to Strauss, the first step in addressing the diabetes epidemic is finding the individuals who are unaware of their condition—whether it be diabetes, or prediabetes—because so many remain uninformed about their condition.

In previous studies, Strauss and her colleagues have shown the dentist’s office to be an opportune site to screen for diabetes.

Funding for the study came from the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research.

Source: NYU. Republished from under Creative Commons License 4.0.

*Image of “insulin syringes” vis Shutterstock