As China’s Xi Arrives in Moscow, Experts Say Peace Efforts a Smoke Screen

As China’s Xi Arrives in Moscow, Experts Say Peace Efforts a Smoke Screen
Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese leader Xi Jinping attend a meeting at the Kremlin in Moscow, Russia on March 20, 2023. (Sputnik/Sergei Karpukhin/Pool via Reuters)
Adam Morrow
Venus Upadhayaya
3/20/2023
Updated:
3/27/2023
0:00

Chinese leader Xi Jinping arrived at Moscow’s Vnukovo Airport on March 20 for a three-day state visit to Russia, during which he is slated to hold talks with Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin.

The meeting comes as Russia slowly makes advances in its monthslong operation to capture the eastern Ukraine city of Bakhmut. The bloody battle has led to massive losses on both sides, especially the Russians.

Xi and Putin are meeting at a time when the war in Ukraine is entering a stage in which it could end conclusively or drag out into a stalemate, according to Madhav Nalapat, a strategic affairs analyst and vice chair of the India-based Manipal Advanced Research Group.

“Putin is under pressure from his commanders to unleash the full fury of Russian weapons against Ukraine rather than have the war get prolonged,” he told The Epoch Times. “Xi clearly wants to know whether Putin will go all out or continue with the present tactics.”

Chinese leader Xi Jinping walks past honour guards during a welcoming ceremony at Moscow's Vnukovo airport on March 20, 2023. (Anatoliy Zhdanov/Kommersant Photo/AFP via Getty Images)
Chinese leader Xi Jinping walks past honour guards during a welcoming ceremony at Moscow's Vnukovo airport on March 20, 2023. (Anatoliy Zhdanov/Kommersant Photo/AFP via Getty Images)

The “hasty arrangement and secret get together” of Xi and Putin is because the Russian military is on the “brink of collapse” in Ukraine, says Frank Lehberger, a Germany-based sinologist.

“Xi Jinping, who is ... the sole autocrat of China, is anxious not to let this happen, because a military rout of Russian armies in Ukraine would be the end of Putin’s autocratic and anti-Western regime of Russia,” he told The Epoch Times in an email.
The Russian army has lost nearly 200,000 soldiers since the war began, according to Western officials, and at least 500,000 Russians have fled the country. Lehberger says Russian elites and nationalist hardliners are angry with Putin and hold him responsible for the situation, while seeking an end to Putin’s dream to recreate a Russian empire in Europe.

“Putin desperately needs Xi to come now and pledge his help, or it will be too late for Putin and his dreams of an autocratic empire,” he wrote.

“Xi knows all this, and he also desperately needs Russia to fight on ... not only against Ukrainians but by association against the entire democratic West or NATO, which are the CCP’s [Chinese Communist Party] existential enemies.”

Airmen with the 436th Aerial Port Squadron use a forklift to move 155 mm artillery shells ultimately bound for Ukraine, at Dover Air Force Base in Delaware on April 29, 2022. (Alex Brandon/AP Photo)
Airmen with the 436th Aerial Port Squadron use a forklift to move 155 mm artillery shells ultimately bound for Ukraine, at Dover Air Force Base in Delaware on April 29, 2022. (Alex Brandon/AP Photo)

Nalapat said that Russia losing a war to Ukraine would weaken China’s position significantly in the international order and the timing of the meeting is mindful of that.

Upon his arrival, Xi told reporters that Moscow and Beijing sought to act in tandem to “uphold the U.N.-centric international system” and “safeguard the world order based on international law and the fundamental norms of international relations [based on the] principles of the UN Charter.”

Xi, who secured an unprecedented third term earlier this month, said he planned to hold wide-ranging talks with Putin regarding bilateral relations and other issues of mutual concern.

He also voiced confidence that his visit would lend “new impetus” to the development of China–Russia relations and a “new era” of strategic cooperation.

Ukraine on Agenda

Shortly before Xi’s arrival, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov also confirmed that the two leaders would discuss a Chinese proposal for resolving the conflict in Ukraine, which was invaded by Russia in February 2022.

“The topics that were touched upon in this [Chinese] plan will inevitably be raised during the exchange of views on Ukraine,” Peskov said.

The issue of Ukraine, he added, “will feature on the agenda.”

Offered by Beijing earlier this month, the 12-point plan calls for a cessation of hostilities, the resumption of negotiations, guarantees to ensure global supply-chain security, and an end to unilateral sanctions and what it calls the “Cold War mentality.”

Ukrainian servicemen fire an M777 howitzer at Russian positions near Bakhmut, Ukraine, amid the Russian invasion of Ukraine on March 17, 2023. (Aris Messinis/AFP via Getty Images)
Ukrainian servicemen fire an M777 howitzer at Russian positions near Bakhmut, Ukraine, amid the Russian invasion of Ukraine on March 17, 2023. (Aris Messinis/AFP via Getty Images)

In a March 19 article published in the CCP-run newspaper People’s Daily, Putin voiced appreciation for Beijing’s “well-balanced stance on events in Ukraine” and its “understanding of their historical background and root causes.”

Putin also welcomed what he described as Beijing’s “readiness to make a meaningful contribution to the settlement of the crisis,” according to the Kremlin’s translation of the article.

Later in the same article, Putin asserts that Moscow “is open to the political and diplomatic resolution of the Ukraine crisis.” He also claims that it “was not Russia who broke off the peace talks [with Kyiv] back in April 2022.”

According to Putin, the future of the Russia–Ukraine peace process “depends solely on the will to engage in a meaningful discussion taking into account current geopolitical realities.”

Lethal Arms for Russia

There has been rising apprehension about China supplying assistance to Russia. U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken said in February that China is already providing “non-lethal” weapons to Russia during the war and is considering supplying lethal assistance. Beijing denies those claims.

Experts say that Xi’s purported role as peacemaker in the conflict is just a smoke screen, pointing to Beijing’s supply of “dual-use” equipment to Moscow that supports its military efforts.

Geopolitical analyst Brandon Weichert said that China has long been providing “vital support and supplies” to Russia.

“The Biden administration knows full well that there are Chinese ‘technicians’ working alongside Wagner Group units in Bakhmut, helping them to maintain the drone fleets that Chinese drone makers have sold to the Russians,” he said, referring to the private mercenary group.

The Wagner Group purchased more than 2,500 Chinese drones in a deal between the mercenary group and Russian and Chinese intelligence, British media outlet Daily Mirror reported, citing a UK intelligence report.
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken speaks at the 2023 Munich Security Conference (MSC) in Germany on Feb. 18, 2023. (Johannes Simon/Getty Images)
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken speaks at the 2023 Munich Security Conference (MSC) in Germany on Feb. 18, 2023. (Johannes Simon/Getty Images)

Nalapat said that misleading the enemy is a “standard operating procedure” for the CCP, noting that the regime is supplying arms to Russia through discreet channels.

“Do you believe that the flood of weapons, many sophisticated, coming to Russia from North Korea and Iran have all been made in those two countries?” he said.

According to a recent Politico report citing customs data, Chinese firms have exported 1,000 assault rifles and other equipment to Moscow that could be used in the conflict.

In June 2022, for example, Russian firm Tekhkrim imported rifles from China North Industries Group Corp. Ltd., a large state-owned defense contractor. The data also showed that Russian companies received 12 shipments of drone parts and more than 12 tons of body armor from China via Turkey in late 2022.

White House National Security Council spokesman John Kirby told The Epoch Times in response to that report that the Biden administration couldn’t confirm that China has in fact provided lethal aid to Russia.

“All these activities are in contravention of current international sanctions,” Lehberger said, adding that the reported efforts are only the tip of the iceberg.

North Korean leader Kim Jong Un watches a fire assault drill at an undisclosed location in North Korea on March 10, 2023, in this photo released by North Korea's Korean Central News Agency (KCNA). (KCNA via Reuters)
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un watches a fire assault drill at an undisclosed location in North Korea on March 10, 2023, in this photo released by North Korea's Korean Central News Agency (KCNA). (KCNA via Reuters)

In addition to Iran and North Korea, China also is sending arms to Russia through other countries such as Burma (also known as Myanmar), Serbia, Turkey, and Belarus, which is a staunch Russian ally in Eastern Europe, according to Lehberger.

After his summit with Putin, Xi will talk via satellite link to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy for the first time since the invasion. Lehberger termed this as Xi’s “make-believe peace mission.”

Xi will aim for a temporary ceasefire to earn recovery time for Putin’s depleted army and Russia will “at a later time” attack Ukraine more fiercely, Lehberger said.

He said that the CCP will continue to supply arms to Russia for at least another two years, because he believes that Xi has plans to take over Taiwan in 2025 and would thus wish to use prolonged Ukraine–Russian conflict to stun or weaken the United States and other Western powers.

US: Ceasefire Under Beijing Plan ‘Unacceptable’

On the same day that Putin’s article was published, Kirby said calls for a ceasefire in Ukraine by Putin and Xi would be “unacceptable.”

“All that’s going to do is ratify Russia’s conquests to date,” he said in televised comments. “All that’s going to do is give Mr. Putin more time to refit, retrain, remain, and try to plan for renewed offensives at a time of his choosing.”

U.S. officials, along with their counterparts in Ukraine’s capital Kyiv, have ruled out any negotiations until Russian forces entirely withdraw from what they see as occupied Ukrainian territory.

That includes the Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson, and Zaporizhzhia regions, which Moscow effectively annexed last September, and the Black Sea region of Crimea, which since 2014 Moscow has viewed as Russian Federation territory.

A destroyed Russian T-72 tank is seen near Pokrovy Presvyatoyi Bohorodytsi Church, in the city of Svyatohirs'k in the Donetsk region of Ukraine on March 1, 2023. (Ihor Tkachov/AFP via Getty Images)
A destroyed Russian T-72 tank is seen near Pokrovy Presvyatoyi Bohorodytsi Church, in the city of Svyatohirs'k in the Donetsk region of Ukraine on March 1, 2023. (Ihor Tkachov/AFP via Getty Images)

Last year, high-level peace talks were held in Istanbul between Russian and Ukrainian officials. At one point, the talks appeared to be making progress, with both sides reportedly willing to make concessions.

Negotiations were scuttled, however, following Ukrainian claims that Russian forces had killed civilians in the town of Bucha, near Kyiv. The United States and its NATO allies backed Kyiv’s claims, while Moscow insists they were fabricated.

China’s Economic Stake

Experts said that China has long-term economic agendas vis-a-vis the Russia–Ukraine war and its economic goals over the next decades are linked with Beijing’s subjugation of the Russian economy.

“Russia is squarely in the camp of China’s new empire; the vast Russian wilderness will become protein for which the dragon can feed on as it rises over the next decade, and Putin will become a powerful vassal prince under Xi Jinping,” said Weichert, who added that fusing the Chinese and Russian economies would be a major victory for Xi and, for that, it would need Russia to be ensnared in a protracted conflict with Ukraine.

Shipping containers stacked in the container terminal at the port of Busan, South Korea, on Nov. 5, 2021. (Chung Sung-Jun/Getty Images)
Shipping containers stacked in the container terminal at the port of Busan, South Korea, on Nov. 5, 2021. (Chung Sung-Jun/Getty Images)

Russia has become China’s most important supplier of industrial raw materials at discounted prices, Nalapat said. The two countries want to work together to topple the U.S. dollar (USD) as the global reserve currency.

“A weakened U.S. dollar would in their view boost their own currencies, especially the RMB [Chinese yuan]. For some time, much of U.S. deficit funding has come from increases in overseas purchases of USD as a reserve currency, and a dollar reset would significantly crimp the ability to spend of the U.S. government,” he said.

Xi wants the United States not only to be weakened but also be deprived of reliable and functioning allies within Europe, according to Lehberger, who sees the Ukraine war as vital to Beijing’s economic game plan against Washington.

“A weak [European Union] will then be earmarked to become an economic dependency of China.”