Government to Target Those Leaving Work ‘For a Life on Benefits’

The chancellor said he will toughen the welfare system as he announced plans to increase the minimum wage to £11 per hour.
Government to Target Those Leaving Work ‘For a Life on Benefits’
Chancellor of the Exchequer Jeremy Hunt arrives on stage to deliver his keynote speech to the Conservative Party annual conference in Manchester on Oct. 2, 2023. (PA Media)
Patricia Devlin
10/3/2023
Updated:
10/3/2023
0:00

Chancellor Jeremy Hunt said the government will toughen sanctions on benefit claimants leaving work “for a life” paid for by the welfare system.

Mr. Hunt said the sanctions regime should make it harder for people to claim welfare while refusing to “look seriously” for a job.

He made the comments alongside a pledge to increase the national minimum wage to at least £11 an hour for workers aged 23 and over from April.

In a speech to the Conservative Party Conference on Monday, he said the move would benefit 2 million of the lowest-paid workers.

Speaking about the benefit system, Mr. Hunt said that since the COVID-19 pandemic, things “have being going in the wrong direction,” with around 100,000 leaving the labour force every year “for a life on benefits.”

He did not announce any details of the new approach, however, with the plans due to be set out in the Autumn Statement in November.

His comments have received widespread criticism from charities, which accused the chancellor of launching an “assault on the poor” and those with disabilities.

Jackie O’Sullivan, acting chief executive of learning disability charity Mencap, said: “Today’s announcement by the chancellor will only compound the problem and move people with a learning disability further from the labour market.

“If the government wants to move people into work, they need to expand funding for supported employment programmes and enable people with a learning disability who can work to achieve their aspirations.”

Civil Service Freeze

Anastasia Berry, Disability Benefits Consortium policy co-chair and MS Society policy manager, said the “benefits crackdown” suggests many disabled people, including those with multiple sclerosis, are choosing a life on benefits.

“The divisive and stigmatising language dehumanises those who are already struggling to make ends meet,” she said.

“Sanctioning won’t get more disabled people into well paid, stable employment. These are deeply cynical proposals and will only punish people already struggling to afford essentials in a cost-of-living crisis.

“This is pushing them further into poverty and forcing them to seek low paid and insecure work—which many are unable to do.”

Plaid Cymru Westminster leader Liz Saville Roberts said, “The Tories’ assault on the poor amid an inequality crisis of their own making reveals just how detached from reality they have become.”

She added: “The notion that people willingly choose hardship on unemployment benefits is detached from reality. No one chooses joblessness, sickness, or poverty.”

Mr. Hunt also announced plans to cut the size of the civil service as he faced Tory demands to slash taxes and trim the size of the state.

The chancellor said the move could save £1 billion a year and indicated that improving public-sector productivity could allow him to reduce the tax burden.

Although he ruled out sizeable tax cuts this year, he left open the door to the possibility of a pre-election giveaway in 2024 as Prime Minister Rishi Sunak seeks to defy the opinion polls and retain the keys to No 10.

In an indication of the pressure on Mr. Hunt to reduce taxes, former Prime Minister Liz Truss addressed a packed meeting with a call to slash corporation tax and cut red tape.

A year on from her short-lived premiership, the size of the crowd gathered at the fringe meeting showed Ms. Truss still had appeal among the party members who backed her over Mr. Sunak in 2022.

Chancellor of the Exchequer Jeremy Hunt leaves 11 Downing Street with his ministerial box, before delivering his Budget at the Houses of Parliament, London, on March 15, 2023. (Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire)
Chancellor of the Exchequer Jeremy Hunt leaves 11 Downing Street with his ministerial box, before delivering his Budget at the Houses of Parliament, London, on March 15, 2023. (Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire)

U-Turn

He suggested improving public-sector productivity levels could allow him to cut taxes.

“If we increase public-sector productivity growth by just half a per cent, we can stabilise public spending as a proportion of GDP,” he said.

“Increase it by more and we can bring the tax burden down. ”

Responding to Mr. Hunt’s comments, Dave Penman, general secretary of the FDA union which represents senior civil servants, said, “With so many public services still on their knees post-COVID, it’s fantasy politics to suggest you can just get the same with significantly less resources.”

The Treasury said the size of the Civil Service will be capped before departments are asked to reduce staffing levels by 63,000.

Mr. Hunt pointed towards a change to “equality and diversity initiatives,” with his spokesman saying there are up to 1,000 officials exclusively working on them.

He said the cap will find the initial savings by curbing a forecast increase to 490,000 civil servants by March 2025 from the total this summer of 457,000.

There will be no compulsory redundancies and the fast stream will be excluded from the plans, he said.

Mike Clancy, general secretary of the Prospect union, said it was a U-turn after previous commitments from the prime minister that there would be no top-down targets for headcount reduction.

He said: “This latest U-turn shreds any remaining doubts about the prime minister’s lack of personal commitment to civil servants and will further undermine vital public services which are already struggling.

“We now have government ministers rushing out policies at Tory conference in a desperate attempt to shore up their own support from the hard right of their party.”

Mr. Hunt used his speech to paint a positive picture about the state of the economy, with a sideswipe at critics for “talking us down.”

“It’s easy to support higher growth, better public services and lower taxes. Harder to make it happen,” he said.

“It’s time to roll up our sleeves, take on the declinists and watch the British economy prove the doubters wrong.”

Former Prime Minister Liz Truss gives a speech on the economy at the Institute for Government in London on Sept. 18, 2023. (Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire)
Former Prime Minister Liz Truss gives a speech on the economy at the Institute for Government in London on Sept. 18, 2023. (Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire)

Truss Support

In a defence of Mr. Sunak’s decision to focus on cutting inflation from its 11 percent peak, Mr. Hunt said: “Nothing hurts families more when it comes to the weekly shop, heating bills, or pump prices, which is why the prime minister has pledged to halve it.

“We’re getting there—it was 11 percent , it’s now down by 40 percent—the plan is working and now we must see it through, just as Margaret Thatcher did many years ago.

“When we halve inflation, that’s not a 1 percent income tax cut, that’s a 5 percent boost to incomes compared to if it stayed the same.”

Mr. Hunt’s speech in the main conference hall came less than two hours after Tory activists had formed a lengthy queue to see Ms. Truss.

She urged members to “unleash their inner conservative” after calling for Mr. Hunt to cut corporation tax to 19 percent or less and to slash government spending.

“Let’s stop taxing and banning things,” she told the packed room.

“Let’s instead build things and make things.”

Ms. Truss said 500,000 homes a year needed to be built, suggesting environmental protections could be torn up to encourage building, and called for ministers to permit fracking.

Meanwhile, speculation continued to mount that Mr. Sunak would finally wield the axe over the HS2 route from Birmingham to Manchester as costs spiral.

Neither the chancellor nor Transport Secretary Mark Harper mentioned the future of the high-speed line in their speeches.

Scrapping the plan to take the line to Manchester would be awkward while the prime minister’s party is gathered in the city and No. 10 insiders insisted no final decision had been made.

Ministers—including Mr. Sunak—have repeatedly refused to guarantee the line will extend beyond Birmingham in recent weeks, fuelling speculation it will be axed or delayed.

ITV and Sky both reported the prime minister had taken the decision to shelve it, with the money instead going to other transport schemes.

A No. 10 spokesman said: “These reports are incorrect. No final decisions have been taken on phase two of HS2.”

PA Media contributed to this report.