Florida Politicians Sound Alarm on Haitian Migration, but Coast Guard Confident in Ongoing Mission

‘The message from the Biden administration to Haiti should be don’t come,’ Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz said.
Florida Politicians Sound Alarm on Haitian Migration, but Coast Guard Confident in Ongoing Mission
Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) leaves a House Republican caucus meeting at the U.S. Capitol in Washington on Oct. 3, 2023. (Drew Angerer/Getty Images)
T.J. Muscaro
3/20/2024
Updated:
3/20/2024
0:00

MIAMI—Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.), Sen. Rick Scott (F-Fla.), and their fellow Floridians in Washington have sounded the alarm on an anticipated influx of Haitian migrants making the journey to the Sunshine State.

The keyword appears to be “anticipated,” however, as the Coast Guard has reported no evidence that the influx is on its way.

“Florida is about to be hammered with a massive wave of Haitian migration,” Mr. Gaetz told The Epoch Times on March 18, echoing concerns that the spike in gang violence and general destabilization of the Caribbean nation will spark this crisis.

He also said that, like those crossing the southern border, they will be able to make asylum claims if they reach American soil.

“Our state cannot handle thousands of Haitians showing up and congregating in these communities,” Mr. Gaetz said.

“Our jail can’t handle it. Our schools can’t handle it. Our hospitals can’t handle it. And, you know, the message from the Biden administration to Haiti should be ‘don’t come,’ and if they don’t make this declaration, they’re essentially putting up a green light and leaving Florida to bear the brunt of a wave of people.”

An official letter signed by Mr. Gaetz and Reps. Gus Bilirakis (R-Fla.), Anna Paulina Luna (R-Fla.), and Daniel Webster (R-Fla.) was sent to President Joe Biden’s desk on March 18.

“We write to request that you exercise your authority under 46 U.S. Code [Section] 70051 and declare an ‘anticipated mass migration of aliens en route to, or arriving off the coast of, the United States’ as urgent circumstances requiring an immediate federal response,” it reads.

Mr. Gaetz said the United States already has an agreement with Haiti that allows the repatriation of all those apprehended at sea, and Executive Order 13276, signed by former President George W. Bush, allows a president “to declare an anticipated mass maritime migration” and afterward activate Department of Defense authorities to keep those migrants out of the country.

The congressmen’s Senate colleagues Mr. Scott and Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) sent their own call to action to the Oval Office three days earlier.

“Floridians and the rest of the American public will not tolerate your administration again opening the floodgates for countless, unvetted foreign nationals to stream into our country, putting our national security at grave risk and creating untold public safety threats for our communities,” the letter reads.

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis also announced on March 13 that he was deploying more than 250 additional officers and soldiers from the Division of Emergency Management, the Florida State Guard, and other state law enforcement agencies to assist with the efforts to repatriate any Haitian migrants.

He also suggested in an interview with Dana Loesch that any Haitians who do land in Florida could be transported to Martha’s Vineyard like previous illegal immigrants were.

But as of March 19, the U.S. Coast Guard says no such flotilla is heading for the Sunshine State.

Florida Not Acting Alone

Coast Guard Public Relations Officer Eric Rodriguez told The Epoch Times that since August 2002, it has operated with its law enforcement agency partners, such as Customs and Border Protection, in an “advanced position” within the Florida Strait and the strait between Haiti and Cuba known as the Windward Passage.
Since 2004, Operation Vigilant Sentry has deployed joint air and surface assets and personnel in the Caribbean “to protect the safety of life at sea and to deter and dissuade a maritime mass migration with our federal, state, and local partners,” according to the Coast Guard.

Florida Fish and Wildlife (FWC) and the United States Coast Guard (USCG) have also confirmed the apprehension of 90 Haitians in two separate incidents. On March 15, FWC confirmed the apprehension of a boat in Sebastian Inlet carrying 25 Haitians along with drugs and firearms on Feb. 29, and the USCG confirmed the repatriation of 65 Haitians on March 12 after apprehending their vessel near the Bahamas on March 7.

As of speaking with The Epoch Times on March 19, Mr. Rodriguez said there had been no interdictions or repatriations of migrants since those 65.

We are more than prepared and capable to deal with any illegal maritime migrations through the Florida Strait, he said.

However, Mr. Gaetz said he believed that this job required more involvement at the federal level.

“You’re dealing with a maritime border that ranges from Key West all the way up to like Indian River County, Florida, and it’s just a huge swath of the Florida straits and even on the Eastern Seaboard,” he said. “And that is not something that can be adequately patrolled by the Coast Guard and local and state law enforcement alone.”

The congressman also said that although the Coast Guard has a fleet of cutters, most of the local and state law enforcement vessels are smaller, designed for nearshore or inshore operations, making them incapable of even safely boarding the Haitian vessels, let alone carrying Haitians back home.

A small U.S. Coast Guard boat ferries Haitians to a larger vessel, 17 miles northeast of Punta Maisi, Cuba, on April 9, 2022. (U.S. Coast Guard photo by Coast Guard Cutter Venturous)
A small U.S. Coast Guard boat ferries Haitians to a larger vessel, 17 miles northeast of Punta Maisi, Cuba, on April 9, 2022. (U.S. Coast Guard photo by Coast Guard Cutter Venturous)

Navy ships have more capacity to collect people, greater intel, and radar and aviation assets to spot any flotillas and “caravans on the water” in order to stop them before they hit the shore, he said.

Mr. Rodriguez rebuked that claim.

The Coast Guard is more than capable and prepared, given that it has multiple assets patrolling the waters, he said.

It’s not just the Coast Guard, Mr. Rodriguez said, referring to a trilateral agreement with the Bahamas and Turks and Caicos, which he said are patrolling those waters with their assets.

Humanitarian Crisis

“Those smuggling networks will profit when every Haitian wants out of Haiti,” Mr. Gaetz said. “But there will also be the more blue-collar smuggling efforts that will consist just of, you know, a single person, you know, constructing, you know, an unseaworthy vessel and then charging whatever they can to get folks on it to get it underway.”

The mass migration has been equated to the Mariel Boatlift, which saw more than 120,000 Cubans come across the Florida Strait from Mariel Harbor to South Florida between April 1980 and October 1980. The comparison is being made not just because of the size of the exodus but also because of its inclusion of people released from prison and insane asylums. As gangs have taken control of Haiti, the prisons have reportedly been emptied, which poses a significant security risk.

However, the distance between Mariel Harbor and Key West was a little more than 105 nautical miles. The distance between Port au Prince, Haiti, to Key West is more than six times that distance.

“What the Coast Guard briefed me on is that it’s very perilous timing the winds and the currents from Haiti into the Florida Strait,” Mr. Gaetz said.

One miscalculation or one squall that gets people in overcrowded boats too far west can result in an extended sail that leads to death by starvation and dehydration. These people also come close to making this journey during hurricane season, which begins on June 1.

Haitians gather outside the U.S. Embassy after the assassination of President Jovenel Moise, in Port-au-Prince, Haiti July 9, 2021. (Estailove St-Val/Reuters)
Haitians gather outside the U.S. Embassy after the assassination of President Jovenel Moise, in Port-au-Prince, Haiti July 9, 2021. (Estailove St-Val/Reuters)

Mr. Rodriguez affirmed this, saying these vessels they find are overcrowded and not necessarily ready for the perils of the sea, especially when it comes to dealing with changes in weather and nighttime navigation.

While the patrols and messaging of Operation Vigilant Sentry continue, Florida’s politicians insist on increased enforcement.

“We can be proactive, and we can stave off the worst humanitarian and economic and public safety consequences by getting the right deterrence in place and then having a catchment system for those people before they get out into the treacherous waters,” Mr. Gaetz said.

The Biden administration recently announced that another $25 million in humanitarian assistance will be sent to Haiti, and Assistant to the Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs retired Rear Adm. John Kirby said he suspected that more money from the United States and its allies would be coming.

“The situation on the ground is dire,” he said on March 15. “We understand that, and we’re doing everything we can to support a truly international effort to—to better improve security and stability for the Haitian people. But it could take some time. We’re going stay committed to it.”

Jacob Burg, John Haughy, and Aaron Pan contributed to this report. 
Born and raised in Tampa, Florida, T.J. Muscaro covers the Sunshine State, America's space industry, the theme park industry, and family-related issues.