Chinese Counterfeits Exceed Carcinogen Limits by 930 Times, Posing Global Health Risk

Chinese counterfeit products have been found to contain dangerously high levels of carcinogenic heavy metals
Chinese Counterfeits Exceed Carcinogen Limits by 930 Times, Posing Global Health Risk
File photo shows workers assembling dolls at a production line in Guangdong, China, on Sept. 4, 2007 (Feng Li/Getty Images)
Lisa Bian
Sean Tseng
2/1/2024
Updated:
2/1/2024
0:00

As consumers globally grapple with rising costs, Chinese online retailers like AliExpress and Pinduoduo’s international counterpart, Temu, are gaining traction with their ultra-low-priced offerings.

Their products are swiftly penetrating retail markets in countries such as the United States and South Korea. However, the allure of affordability is overshadowed by the significant health risks these cheap Chinese goods present.

A recent investigation by the South Korean government has sounded the alarm: many Chinese counterfeit products have been found to contain dangerously high levels of carcinogenic heavy metals. This revelation comes in the wake of a focused crackdown by the South Korean Customs Service, which has observed a sixfold increase in counterfeit goods over the past four years.

Between Nov. 6 and Dec. 1 last year, a staggering 142,930 counterfeit items were confiscated. Approximately 90 percent of these items originated from China, with 62.3 percent coming from mainland China and 27.5 percent from Hong Kong. Vietnam accounted for an additional 10 percent.

This surge in counterfeit goods coincided with the peak online shopping season, including major discount events in November. The crackdown targeted various import channels, such as express delivery, postal services, and general imports.

The types of counterfeit goods varied, with clothing, shoes, and bags being the most common. At Incheon International Airport near Seoul, the focus was on fashion items, whereas Incheon Port saw a surge in counterfeit electronic products and food items. Pyeongtaek Port dealt with an influx of fake watches and electronics.

In terms of volume, clothing constituted the largest share at 40 percent, followed by stationery (16 percent), accessories (14 percent), keychains (8 percent), and bags (5 percent). Toys, shoes, and wallets each accounted for 2 percent of the seized items.

The Korean Central Customs Laboratory conducted a detailed analysis of 83 types of skin-contact products, including earrings and leather bags, due to concerns over compliance with safety standards. Shockingly, 30 percent of these products were found to contain excessive levels of lead and cadmium, with some exhibiting lead and cadmium levels up to 930 times the permissible limit.

For instance, among 24 popular fashion items, including counterfeit earrings claiming to be from renowned brands like Louis Vuitton, Dior, and Chanel, 83 percent contained cadmium. Some of these items also had dangerously high levels of lead. In a startling discovery, a counterfeit Chanel brooch had lead levels 153 times above the safety standard.

The study indicated that to cut costs, counterfeit manufacturers not only use cadmium in surface treatments but also incorporate lead and cadmium as primary materials. Of the earrings containing cadmium, 75 percent had levels exceeding the safe limit by 600 times, with some reaching 930 times the permissible amount.

Moreover, several counterfeit bags and wallets were also found to have excessive levels of these harmful metals.

The dangers of cadmium exposure include increased risk of cancer and damage to various bodily systems, according to the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the National Cancer Institute (NCI).
Similarly, lead, as determined by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), is a known carcinogen affecting nearly every organ system, particularly the nervous system. Long-term exposure to lead can result in significant health issues, including anemia, kidney damage, and cognitive decline.

In light of these findings, the Korea Customs Service has issued a stark warning: the distribution and consumption of counterfeit products are not just a matter of intellectual property infringement but pose a “serious threat to health.”

China Tops South Korea’s Online Shopping Market in 2023

In a significant shift, China overtook the United States in 2023 to become the dominant player in South Korea’s cross-border e-commerce market. The development marks the first time China has led South Korea’s overseas online shopping market, reflecting the growing influence of Chinese e-commerce on international retail landscapes.
Data from the Korea Customs Service highlights this trend. During the first three quarters of 2023, South Korea’s cross-border e-commerce market expanded by 20.4 percent year-on-year. Within this burgeoning market, China claimed a substantial 46.4 percent share, outpacing the United States, which accounted for 29.1 percent.

This rise in China’s market share is noteworthy, with the value of Korean consumers’ purchases from China surging by an astounding 106 percent year-on-year, a stark contrast to the modest 9.7 percent increase in purchases from the United States.

The growth in direct purchases from China is further evidenced by the record-breaking issuance of personal customs clearance codes in South Korea. By the end of 2023, over 25 million such codes were issued, an unprecedented number equal to half of the South Korean population.

These codes, specific to overseas direct purchases, facilitate smoother transactions and customs processes. Purchases from the United States under $200 are exempt from customs duties, while the threshold for other countries is $150.

This influx of Chinese e-commerce has spurred public debate in South Korea, with many advocating for stronger non-tariff barriers and strategies to bolster the competitiveness of South Korean e-commerce platforms.

Adding to the complexity of this issue, Li Yuanhua, a China affairs expert and former associate professor of history at Beijing’s Capital Normal University, told The Epoch Times on Jan. 29 that the low pricing of many Chinese products is not solely due to intellectual property infringements but also the use of banned or toxic substances to cut costs. According to Mr. Li, these products often sacrifice quality, misleading consumers with substandard goods.

Mr. Li emphasized the need for vigilance and regulatory action. He advocates for the abolition of tariff exemptions and the implementation of stringent restrictions and testing for online-purchased products. These measures aim to shield consumers in various countries from the risks posed by infringing, inferior, and potentially toxic products.

Toxic Chinese Products: UK and Japan Incidents Spark Alarm

The issue of substandard and hazardous products originating from China extends far beyond South Korea, affecting numerous countries worldwide. Recent incidents in the United Kingdom and Japan underscore the global reach of this problem.
In a disturbing event in the UK, an 11-year-old girl suffered severe burns after using an artificial nail polish kit sold by Temu. British media reported on Jan. 26 that Chloe Norris, a young girl from Kent, England, used a nail polish kit purchased by her father on Temu’s website.

Chloe’s mother recounted the harrowing experience, describing how her daughter felt intense burning and pain shortly after applying the polish. Despite initial home treatment, Chloe developed large blisters and was subsequently diagnosed with severe skin burns at the hospital.

She underwent two skin graft surgeries and was warned of potential lifelong scarring.

The alarming incident led Chloe’s parents to advocate for a ban on the sale of such hazardous products. They revealed that the nail polish was purchased for less than 1 pound (approximately $1.30). Temu offered them compensation in the form of coupons worth £1,750 (about $2,200), but the family has vowed never to use the site again.

Another concerning case emerged in Japan at the end of 2023. A Japanese consumer suffered skin necrosis after using a mole removal cream purchased from the Chinese online retailer AliExpress. This prompted Japanese authorities to issue a stern warning about the product.

The National Consumer Affairs Center of Japan (NCAC) reported on Dec. 13, 2023, that it had received multiple complaints about the cream, including three cases of serious skin damage. The NCAC’s investigation revealed that the cream had a highly alkaline pH level of 14, posing a severe risk of skin damage. Consumers were strongly advised to cease using the product.

These incidents highlight the urgent need for increased vigilance and regulatory oversight to protect consumers from the dangers posed by toxic and inferior products circulating in the global market.

Kane Zhang contributed to this report.
Lisa Bian, B.Med.Sc., is a healthcare professional holding a Bachelor's Degree in Medical Science. With a rich background, she has accrued over three years of hands-on experience as a Traditional Chinese Medicine physician. In addition to her clinical expertise, she serves as an accomplished writer based in Korea, providing valuable contributions to The Epoch Times. Her insightful pieces cover a range of topics, including integrative medicine, Korean society, culture, and international relations.
Related Topics