Analog Revival: Behind Vinyl’s Surprising Comeback

Save
Analog Revival: Behind Vinyl’s Surprising Comeback
While digital music offers greater convenience, many listeners continue to value vinyl for its tactile qualities. Bohdan Chenkaliuk/Getty Images
While digital music offers greater convenience, many listeners continue to value vinyl for its tactile qualities. Bohdan Chenkaliuk/Getty Images
Updated:

Silent rotations, like the globe spinning through space. The needle connects—a sudden, transformative intrusion into the world of the record. A few seconds of static. Then, magic: music first played months, years, or even decades ago suddenly fills the room, as though the musicians are standing right there, strumming and swaying. The listener falls silent, transported.

This is the joy of the record player. It’s a joy well-known to our grandparents, but unlike certain other audio technologies (I’m looking at you, cassette tapes), it hasn’t gone into the dustbin of history. In fact, vinyl has enjoyed a significant resurgence in recent decades. It’s no longer a relic of the mid-to-late 20th century; it’s a firm fixture in the musical world of the 21st.

Glorious Inefficiency

The question is, why the record player? Music is more accessible today than it’s ever been in human history. Streaming services can pull up any song ever recorded with just a few swipes. What’s the need for vinyl, a more cumbersome, less efficient means of listening to music?
Actually, that’s part of the appeal. “Vinylphiles” appreciate precisely the inefficiency of using a record player. “That’s kind of the point … because it’s too easy to stream,” Avi Brown, vinyl enthusiast and founder of Evergreen Vinyl told The Epoch Times. “Streaming can feel like the ‘fast-fashion’ of music. It’s too accessible, we don’t experience the albums and appreciate them to the same degree.”

In the digital era, some music lovers have reached a point of fatigue with the frictionless process of streaming. “We’re so focused on efficiency and simplification in so many parts of our everyday life,” Brown said. “With vinyl, it’s like a backlash. It’s about enjoyment of the ritual, the physical object that carries meaning and a cultural artifact.”

Large-format album artwork offers a visual context that digital music minimizes. Album jackets also include lyrics and production credits that deepen the listening experience. (Tima Miroshnichenko/Pexels)
Large-format album artwork offers a visual context that digital music minimizes. Album jackets also include lyrics and production credits that deepen the listening experience. Tima Miroshnichenko/Pexels
People who use record players are looking for something other than efficiency or convenience. They want an authentic experience, one that is intentionally not frictionless. After all, friction creates vibration. It’s friction that makes music.

Ritual and Intentionality

The “friction”—both literal and metaphorical—of using records and record players fosters intentionality. Playing a record requires forethought, physical steps, and patience. It can’t be turned on thoughtlessly the way digital music can be, nor does it lend itself to skipping tracks.
In the words of Nathan Green, Co-Founder and CEO of New Level Radio, “A record gives you a tactile, ritualistic, and uninterrupted experience with music. Vinyl requires you to pull the sleeve, drop the needle, and flip the record after 20 minutes. It transforms passive background listening into a deliberate, focused activity.”

Calm. Focused. Intentional: These words have become increasingly scarce in the modern vocabulary dominated by efficiency, convenience, productivity, and technological tools that promise to deliver these things. Vinyl offers something different. It’s a nostalgic respite from this diffracted, distracted technological environment. It’s a slowing down that people thirst for.

Vinyl records have experienced a sustained revival in recent years, attracting listeners who value a more bodily experience of listening to music. (Dean Drobot/Shutterstock)
Vinyl records have experienced a sustained revival in recent years, attracting listeners who value a more bodily experience of listening to music. Dean Drobot/Shutterstock
“Now, more than ever, people are burned out on quick access to everything and it leads to information and option overload,” Bob Bradley, a music industry publicist, told The Epoch Times. “People young and old are tapping into nostalgia and ways of doing things that are experiential and keep us focused on one thing at a time.”

Part of this intentional slowing down arises from the physical, tactile aspect of vinyl. The hand, the turntable, and the needle can only move so quickly. It’s a slow, sensuous experience, deeply engaging touch and sight alongside hearing. “The tactile pleasure of flipping through stacks of records, the visual delight of album art—it’s a multisensory banquet,” noted the record player company Fluance on their blog.

The intentionality, the sensory appeal, the precise physical movements—all this has a ritualistic quality to it that deepens the experience. “Listening to an EP or LP on vinyl creates a ritual,” says Bradley. “You pull it out, look at the cover, place it on the player, drop that needle, and listen. Ultimately, there’s a sense of presence to it that streaming and even CDs can’t always provide.” Rituals—from steeping tea to religious ceremonies to playing vinyl—provide us with predictable, meaningful, and stabilizing patterns that ground us both in tradition and in the present moment, connecting us with values that transcend the everyday. They help us find our place as human beings in a chaotic world. The ritual of vinyl has a potency unrivaled by other ways of listening to recorded music.

Selecting albums naturally encourages conversation and participation, making it a shared activity. (Westend61/Getty Images)
Selecting albums naturally encourages conversation and participation, making it a shared activity. Westend61/Getty Images

There’s an artistic benefit to the physical limitations of records, too. Records have physical constraints that, paradoxically, give listeners the freedom to experience a musical album more as it was originally intended. “It’s a ritual which makes you appreciate the music more than shuffling through 80 million songs on autopilot,” according to Brown. “It’s a slower process where you sit with one album and fully focus on it.” With a record, the listener can’t skip around—he has to listen to the album’s songs in order, which is the way the artist originally intended them to be heard. Songs on an album are intentionally arranged to tell a story or to complement one another like pieces of art on a gallery wall. Streaming—with its non-consecutive, mix-and-match approach—often obscures the experience of this artistic decision.

Records’ physical limitations have a benefit, too. Their physical constraints paradoxically give listeners the freedom to experience an album as it was originally intended. “It’s a ritual which makes you appreciate the music more than shuffling through 80 million songs on autopilot,” according to Brown. “It’s a slower process where you sit with one album and fully focus on it.”

With a record, the listener can’t skip around—he has to listen to the album’s songs in order, the way the artist originally intended them to be heard. Songs on an album are intentionally arranged to tell a story or to complement one another like pieces of art on a gallery wall. Streaming’s non-consecutive, mix-and-match approach often obscures the experience of the art.

Sonorous Sound

Vinyl’s authenticity manifests also in its sound quality. Static, flaws, and a warmer tone all can make the music sound more “real.” Brown broke down the differences between digital and analog recordings, and why many people find a richer sound in records:
Digital files offer over 90dB of dynamic range compared to vinyl’s 70dB. Digital is also more consistent. There isn’t any wow-and-flutter, surface noise, wear from repeated plays.
But vinyl has its advantages. Since the mid-90s there has been a “loudness war” since labels wanted tracks to sound louder than the competition. Engineers were tasked to compress the audio heavily, which squashes the dynamic range and loses a lot of the nuance.
A record player produces sound by tracing microscopic grooves in the vinyl with a stylus, converting physical vibrations into music. (Matthias Groeneveld/Pexels)
A record player produces sound by tracing microscopic grooves in the vinyl with a stylus, converting physical vibrations into music. Matthias Groeneveld/Pexels
This is where vinyl has physical limitations that prevents over-compressing and makes it sound more dynamic and alive. Vinyl sounds “warmer” since its distortion runs somewhere between 0.4% and 3% total harmonic distortion, while digital DACs come in at under 0.001%. By every technical measure that’s a flaw… but a lot of ears find it pleasing. It’s an imperfection that can feel more human. Especially with a world that becomes increasingly digital and AI centered.
Just as music is about more than mere efficiency, so too it’s about more than mere technical perfection. Much of what we crave in music is the human element, which is not always efficient, and rarely perfect. That’s the appeal of the turntable. It’s more raw, more intimate, and more human—flaws and all.

Engraving Stories

The imperfections of an old record, worn down through repeated plays, remind us of everything it’s been through. Records have been around for centuries, and each record tells a story of its own.

The first phonograph—an early term for a turntable or record player—was developed by Thomas Edison in 1877. It used indentations embossed into tinfoil by a vibrating stylus, which was wrapped around a rotating cylinder. Emil Berliner improved the process in 1887 by engraving sound grooves in a spiral on a flat disc rather than a cylinder. Berliner’s disc would be used to create a negative, which, in turn, could be a mold for making many copies of the original disc. The records could then be played on a Gramophone.

(Left) German-American engineer Emile Berliner with the model of the first phonograph machine he invented, circa 1920. (Right) Thomas Edison and his phonograph, circa 1877. (Public domain)
(Left) German-American engineer Emile Berliner with the model of the first phonograph machine he invented, circa 1920. (Right) Thomas Edison and his phonograph, circa 1877. Public domain

Manufacturers continued to improve the process so that discs could record longer and longer sections of audio. In 1948, Columbia Records launched the long-playing (LP) record, with a rotational speed of 33 1/3 RPM, which offered up to 30 minutes of playing time per side.

Perhaps the most incredible thing about this relatively simple technology is the way it has endured. As Brown observed, “The vinyl record is an elegantly simple and incredibly durable medium that has outlasted 8-tracks, cassettes, MiniDiscs, and now even CDs.”

Schoolgirls listen to a recording of their voices played on a record player at the National Urban League's Charm School in Brooklyn, New York, 1948. (FPG/Archive Photos/Getty Images)
Schoolgirls listen to a recording of their voices played on a record player at the National Urban League's Charm School in Brooklyn, New York, 1948. FPG/Archive Photos/Getty Images

Though streaming remains king, vinyl continues to experience a renaissance. “Vinyl has grown in sales year-on-year for over a decade now,” Brown said.

The biggest buyers? Surprisingly, it’s young people. A recent survey conducted by Vinyl Alliance found that the percentage of people enjoying physical music, which includes vinyl, cassettes, and CDs, is largest among people 18 to 24. Over 50 percent of Gen Z respondents collect vinyl, as opposed to 49 percent of Millennials and 34 percent of Gen X. There’s a communal and in-person aspect to young people’s interest too, with more than 80 percent shopping for records in-store. Over half prefer brick-and-mortar stores to online purchases. They also want more vinyl community events.
Younger generations are driving vinyl sales, with many preferring to shop for them in person rather than online. (Nick David/Getty Images)
Younger generations are driving vinyl sales, with many preferring to shop for them in person rather than online. Nick David/Getty Images

The vinyl community is thriving. They even have a dedicated day: “Record Store Day,” a semi-annual event founded in 2008 to celebrate the vinyl subculture.

Sydney, a young millennial mother, musician, and music lover, expressed to The Epoch Times a common sentiment among young people who want to recover older ways of doing things. “I think there’s a cultural desire to go back in some ways. I think we’re drawn to a time when we didn’t have the world at our fingertips.” The “inconvenience,” intentionality, and grittiness of vinyl offer a response to that desire.

“I think we’re all longing for a slower, more peaceful life and the truth is that the more technology we have to make things ‘efficient’ the less time and peace and calm we have,” she said. “I think a lot of people are longing for a time when our minds were able to calmly focus on the task in front of us and we didn’t have access to … everything … all of the time.”

As a busy mom, Sydney finds vinyl’s soothing quality especially important. “I have found that when you have kids, it’s even more essential to find ways to slow down and enjoy a moment.”

For vinyl enthusiasts, that’s what it’s all about: taking a breath, making space, and letting the music waft over you as the record turns round and round, like the revolving rhythms of our days, years, and decades. Through all the changes of recent centuries, records have remained with us. It doesn’t look like they’re going anywhere soon.

AD