Roman Catholic Diocese Warns of Fake Bishops, Priests in California

Roman Catholic Diocese Warns of Fake Bishops, Priests in California
St. Joachim Catholic Church in Costa Mesa, Calif., on Jan, 17, 2023. (John Fredricks/The Epoch Times)
Katabella Roberts
10/24/2023
Updated:
10/24/2023
0:00

A Roman Catholic diocese in California has warned churchgoers to be alert for imposters pretending to be Catholic clergymen and charging “exorbitant fees” for blessings and sacraments.

In an Oct. 20 alert, the Diocese of Stockton urged churches and churchgoers in the city of Modesto to be on the lookout for people “purporting to be Spanish-speaking Catholic bishops and priests” but who actually “engage in fraudulent activities related to the sacraments and sacramentals.”

“These imposters are misappropriating the identities of genuine priests in Mexico and conducting unauthorized celebrations of baptism, confirmation, First Communion, and house blessings under false pretenses,” the Diocese of Stockton wrote.

Officials of the Diocese of Stockton have verified that the fake Catholic bishops and priests have used the names of legitimate priests in Mexico, including Father Jose Adan Gonzalez Estrada and Bishop Raul Gomez Gonzalez of the Archdiocese of Toluca to lure in churchgoers who are then charged “exorbitant fees” by the imposters to celebrate sacraments, teach classes, and issue certificates, the alert said.

Even more worryingly, the alleged fraudsters have demanded birth certificate submissions from those participating in the sacraments, which has prompted concerns about human trafficking and identity theft, the Diocese said.

The culprits are allegedly using threats and intimidation when questions are raised regarding their credibility.

“They resort to intimidation tactics against anyone questioning their identity or authority, often threatening legal action for defamation, although these threats lack substance,” the Diocese said.

Law enforcement officials in Modesto, California, have been alerted to the issue, according to the Diocese, however, only victims who have personally been targeted by the imposters can currently file complaints and initiate investigations.

“It’s imperative to note that the police do not inquire about the caller’s immigration status; their primary concern is combatting criminal activities,” the Diocese said.

‘Wolves in Sheep’s Clothing’

The Diocese of Stockton also stressed that—with few exceptions—Catholic sacraments are typically administered within Catholic churches, meaning that victims will likely have to have the sacraments performed again at a later date by legitimate officials.

“The Diocese strongly advises the public not to be deceived by these ‘wolves in sheep’s clothing,’” the alert concluded.

According to Diocesan spokesperson Erin Haight, the fake Catholic clergymen are charging various victims “thousands of dollars” for communions and confirmations.

“They’re even charging people to use the seats they provide at these ceremonies,” Ms. Haight told NBC News, adding that the Catholic Church would never charge such an amount.

Ms. Haight also stressed that the fraudsters are mainly preying on illegal immigrants, migrant workers, and others who “might be afraid to go to law enforcement.”

Sharon Bear, a Modesto police spokesperson, confirmed to NBC News that the Diocese of Stockton has been in contact with the department over the fake clergymen.

However, the spokesperson noted that no investigation is currently underway because no victims have come forward and filed a complaint.

“We advised them to notify the other churches in the area and encourage people who have been harmed to contact us,” Ms. Bear said. “There’s not much more we can do at this point.”

The latest warning comes after the Diocese of Stockton in March cautioned churchgoers that a former Stockton priest who was dismissed from the clerical state was celebrating invalid Masses in private homes and halls.

Churchgoers were warned not to participate in any of the events conducted by Leo Suarez because it “ruptures their communion with the Catholic Church and may, in some circumstances, result in the invalid administration of a sacrament.”

Mr. Suarez was dismissed from the clerical state in 2016 after being twice accused of sexually abusing a minor. He first self-reported the abuse in 2009, CBS News reported.