Mistrial Declared for Ex-Idaho Politician Charged With 1984 Murder of Colorado Girl

Mistrial Declared for Ex-Idaho Politician Charged With 1984 Murder of Colorado Girl
Steven Pankey, a former two-time candidate for governor of Idaho, who has been charged with the abduction and murder of a Colorado girl who vanished in 1984, is seen in this undated mugshot. Weld County District Attorney/Handout via Reuters
|Updated:

DENVER—Jurors deadlocked and a mistrial was declared on Thursday in the kidnapping-murder case against a two-time Idaho gubernatorial candidate charged in the 1984 slaying of a 12-year-old Colorado girl whose remains were unearthed over three decades later.

The 12-member jury found Steven Pankey, 70, guilty on one count of false reporting to authorities but failed to reach a unanimous verdict on charges he abducted and murdered Jonelle Matthews, leading the judge to dismiss most of the prosecution’s case, court officials said.