Former DNC Chair Says Democrats Missed the Mark on Redistricting

In a new post on Substack, former DNC Chair Jaime Harrison urges national standards and independent commissions for redistricting.
Former DNC Chair Says Democrats Missed the Mark on Redistricting
Democratic National Committee Chairman Jaime Harrison speaks in Charlotte, N.C., on Nov. 2, 2024. Mike Stewart/AP Photo
|Updated:
0:00

Former Democratic National Committee (DNC) Chairman Jaime Harrison is pressing Democrats to make redistricting reform a top priority, calling partisan map-drawing “the singular cancer in our democracy.”

In a Substack post, he argued that Democrats “missed the moment” to pass national guardrails when they held more power and said durable change now requires federal standards and independent commissions in every state.

Harrison wrote that partisan gerrymandering lets “politicians pick their voters instead of voters picking their politicians,” locking in safe seats and fueling extremes. He faulted Democrats for failing to advance voting-rights legislation when they had a path to act, saying a filibuster carve-out died in the Senate.

“And here’s where Democrats must face the mirror,” he said. “We had our chances to stop this. When Democrats briefly held 60 votes in the Senate during the Obama administration, we should have passed a series of democracy reforms including one that outlawed extreme gerrymanders nationwide.”

Harrison went on to discuss Democrats failing to enact the John Lewis Voting Rights Act to “set strong federal guardrails.” They were hamstrung, he said, by two Democrats turned Independents—then-Sens. Joe Manchin of West Virginia and Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona—who refused to vote yes on a carve-out in the filibuster rules to pass it in the Senate.

“These two often talked about the need for more bipartisanship and cooperation in Congress,” he said. “It is ironic that they couldn’t see the forest for the trees. They were too enamored with the filibuster and couldn’t recognize that the greatest threat to a functioning Congress was gerrymandered districts. Because of them, we lost the moment.”

The Epoch Times reached out to Manchin and Sinema for comment on Harrison’s assessment, but did not hear back prior to publication.

As a remedy, Harrison backs stronger Voting Rights Act protections, nationwide rules against extreme gerrymanders, and commissions that draw maps under uniform criteria.

He pointed to states such as Arizona and Michigan as models and said commissions must be adopted “everywhere” to avoid a patchwork that only binds some states. He also called for transparent map drafting, clear “communities of interest” standards, and neutral review.

“We must adhere to the racial guidelines established by the Voting Rights Act,” he wrote. “Draft maps are public. Challenges go to neutral arbiters—not party bosses. This isn’t starry-eyed idealism. It’s how you rebuild trust in democracy.”

Republicans counter that Democrats have also pursued aggressive maps in states where they have full control of government. Missouri recently became the third state to redraw its federal congressional map for partisan purposes, following Texas and California. Missouri’s new map could help Republicans gain an additional U.S. House seat from that state in the 2026 midterm elections.

This past summer, Texas Republicans approved a new congressional map aimed at flipping multiple Democratic-held seats, which prompted California Democrats to push their own changes, underscoring that both parties see the lines as central to House control.

Californians will go to the polls on Nov. 4 to vote on a referendum over whether to authorize replacing the state’s current congressional map with one designed to favor Democrats.

Harrison said any fix must be national to restore trust and competition. He urged Democrats to pledge support for federal standards and independent commissions and, if necessary, to change Senate rules for voting-rights legislation.

“If you want a healthier middle, give it a fair map,” he wrote. “If you want a Congress that works, stop treating democracy like a game of lines and start treating it like a promise. Commissions in every state. Voters choosing leaders. Leaders accountable to voters. That’s not a partisan dream. That’s the minimum standard for a country that wants to call itself a democracy.”

Aldgra Fredly, Joseph Lord, and Jackson Richman contributed to this report. 
Google LogoMark Us Preferred on Google
Chase Smith
Chase Smith
Author
Chase is an award-winning journalist. He covers national politics for The Epoch Times. For news tips, send Chase an email at [email protected] or connect with him on X.
twitter