The Epoch Times
The Epoch Times
AD
The Epoch Times
Support Us
SHARE
USEducation

Columbia Students Suing Pro-Palestinian Protest Organizers Had ‘Jarring’ Experience: Attorney

Attorney Daniel Suhr is representing three Columbia University students and two graduates in the challenge.
Copy
Facebook
X
Truth
Gettr
LinkedIn
Telegram
Email
Save
Columbia Students Suing Pro-Palestinian Protest Organizers Had ‘Jarring’ Experience: Attorney
Student organizer and negotiator Xueda Polat addresses the press on campus at Columbia University in New York on April 29, 2024. Juliette Fairley/The Epoch Times
Juliette Fairley
By Juliette Fairley
8/20/2024Updated: 8/20/2024
0:00

The attorney representing three graduates of Columbia University and two current students in a suit against pro-Palestinian protest organizers said his Jewish clients had a “jarring” experience when the Ivy League campus was occupied by protestors during the Spring semester.

The five plaintiffs sued students, activists, unions, and three members of Congress on Aug. 5, alleging they were denied access to in-person classes, campus facilities, and graduation and experienced bullying and harassment.

“The students described feeling so unsafe that they organized text groups to make sure that no Jewish student had to cross campus alone,” the plaintiffs’ attorney, Daniel Suhr from Hughes & Suhr LLC, told The Epoch Times on Aug. 16.

The Columbia University campus became the epicenter of student anti-war protests for Gaza on April 17. Other universities nationwide followed with rallies of their own for the same cause.

“What happened at Columbia was not a spontaneous organic event,” Suhr said. “It was part of a nationwide strategy of well-networked, well-coordinated radical organizations that don’t care about breaking the law to advance their agenda.”

The class action lawsuit names federal lawmakers Reps. Jamaal Bowman (D-N.Y.), Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.), and Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) as defendants.

Related Stories
Columbia University Deans Step Down After Disparaging Texts During Anti-Semitism Meeting
8/9/2024
Columbia University Deans Step Down After Disparaging Texts During Anti-Semitism Meeting
Columbia University Settles Lawsuit With Jewish Student, Promising Extra Safety Measures
6/6/2024
Columbia University Settles Lawsuit With Jewish Student, Promising Extra Safety Measures
Ocasio-Cortez reportedly toured the encampment in person on April 26, as well as Omar and Bowman, who posted Instagram videos of their campus visits. In a post from the encampment on the lawn at the center of campus, Omar stated: “These students are joyfully protesting for peace and an end to the genocide taking place in Gaza. I’m in awe of their bravery and courage.”
“The three members of the squad were illegally trespassing on Columbia’s property at a time when the university was closed to people who weren’t part of the Columbia community,” Shur alleged. “It’s very well established that the First Amendment does not protect incitement or encouraging people in the moment to engage in illegal behavior. That’s exactly what happened here with these three members of Congress where they were inciting, encouraging these students and other activists to continue breaking the law.”
Student groups and their representatives, such as Columbia Students for Justice in Palestine, Columbia-Barnard Jewish Voice for Peace, Within Our Lifetime, and Faculty and Staff for Justice in Palestine, are all named as defendants along with the Student Workers Union (SWU) of Columbia, also known as UAW Local 2710.

None of the organizers or the lawmakers have responded to requests for comment from The Epoch Times on the allegations.

As previously reported by The Epoch Times, student negotiators rejected concessions and labeled them bribes.
The court will now determine whether the case can proceed or lacks merit.

Nationwide Movement

The encampment occupied the lawn in the middle of Columbia’s campus, where graduation ceremonies were scheduled to take place on May 15. The protest, which included vandalism and occupation of buildings and classrooms, was not completely disbanded until June 2. As a result, the main commencement ceremony for the graduating class that was scheduled for May 15 was canceled.

“A jury of everyday people, of parents and grandparents, can put a value on missing graduation, and those are going to be real dollar figures,” Suhr said. “They’re going to be significant and when you multiply it across the class, it will be in the tens of millions easily.”

The proposed class consists of some 36,000 Columbia University students.

Last week, President Nemat “Minouche” Shafik became the third Ivy League chief to resign over criticism of the university administration’s handling of the protests.

Groups and their representatives, such as Columbia Students for Justice in Palestine, Columbia-Barnard Jewish Voice for Peace, Within Our Lifetime, the People’s Forum, and Faculty and Staff for Justice in Palestine, are also named as defendants, along with the SWC-UAW Local 2710.

“Students for Justice in Palestine, which is both a Columbia and national network, was behind the encampments on all of the campuses but then it extends to the faculty who facilitated and enabled them,” Suhr said. “Those faculty were organized by and through their union, the Student Workers of Columbia, which represents the adjunct faculty and teaching assistants.”

The UAW Region 9A, which includes UAW Local 2710, is one of 28 unions that signed a joint statement posted on Twitter on April 23 in support of the Columbia students and student workers who were participating in the encampment and related protests.

Columbia University spokesman Ben Chang declined to comment.

Individuals who were visible and may have spoken at daily campus press conferences are also named as defendants. None of the individual defendants or groups contacted by The Epoch Times responded to requests for comment.

Three of the plaintiffs are returning to Columbia this fall while the other two plaintiffs are graduates from the class of 2024.

“The students who are going back to Columbia are very apprehensive about what they’re going to find,” Suhr said.

Juliette Fairley
Juliette Fairley
Freelance reporter
Juliette Fairley is a freelance reporter for The Epoch Times and NTD and a graduate of Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism. Born in Chateauroux, France, and raised outside of Lackland Air Force Base in Texas, Juliette is a well-adjusted military brat. She has written for many publications across the country. Send Juliette story ideas at [email protected]
Author’s Selected Articles

5 Mexican Nationals Charged After Migrant Boat Capsizes Off California, Killing at Least 3

May 07, 2025
5 Mexican Nationals Charged After Migrant Boat Capsizes Off California, Killing at Least 3

Shooting at Arizona Restaurant Leaves 3 People Dead, 5 Injured

May 06, 2025
Shooting at Arizona Restaurant Leaves 3 People Dead, 5 Injured

Illinois Landlord Sentenced to 53 Years for Killing 6-Year-Old Palestinian Boy

May 02, 2025
Illinois Landlord Sentenced to 53 Years for Killing 6-Year-Old Palestinian Boy

Bread Sold in 6 States Recalled Due to Glass Contamination

May 02, 2025
Bread Sold in 6 States Recalled Due to Glass Contamination
Save
The Epoch Times
Copyright © 2000 - 2025 The Epoch Times Association Inc. All Rights Reserved.