Survey Shows Hundreds of Hong Kong Journalists Moved Overseas; Over 30% of Respondents Continue to Work in the Media

Apple Daily journalists hold freshly-printed copies of the newspaper's last edition while acknowledging supporters gathered outside their office in Hong Kong early on June 24, 2021. The pro-democracy tabloid was forced to close after 26 years under a sweeping new national security law. (Daniel Suen/AFP via Getty Images)

According to the recent survey “Journalists in Exile: A Survey of Media Workers in the Hong Kong Diaspora,” it is believed that a few hundred journalists from Hong Kong have moved abroad. Furthermore, out of the 90 former Hong Kong journalists who responded to the survey, more than 30 percent have worked in the media industry.

The study, undertaken by the Association of Overseas Hong Kong Media Professionals CIC (AOHKMP), conducted from Dec. 17, 2022, to Feb. 20, concluded its two-stage research process. The first stage consisted of a questionnaire survey answered by 101 former Hong Kong journalists, with 90 valid responses. The second stage of the study involved in-depth interviews with participants selected from the questionnaire survey.

The survey results show that over 40 percent of the respondents moved overseas in 2021 and 2022, with more than half going to the UK. Canada (21.1 percent), Taiwan (14.4 percent), and Australia (6.7 percent) were the next most popular locations.

According to the survey, more than a third of respondents had 21 or more years of work experience, 22.2 percent had 6-10 years, and 18.9 percent had 1-5 years.

Nearly 35 Percent Working in Media Industry

The survey found that 65.6 percent (59) of respondents are not working in the media industry. This includes eight students, freelancers, public relations experts, marketing professionals, YouTube channel moderators, baristas, car mechanics, speech therapists, florists, waiters, hotel receptionists, housewives, and 16 retired or unemployed.

Of the 31 surveyed, 34.4 percent reported being employed in the media field. Print journalists, electronic media reporters, and writers make up the majority, with a few editors and directors sprinkled in; other occupations include online program hosts, current affairs commentators, and part-time reporters. Twelve of those surveyed are located in organizations and platforms founded by Hong Kong natives.

Most people surveyed do not plan to return to Hong Kong soon. Eighty percent have no intention of returning, while ten percent plan to do so. Regarding regret, 90 percent don’t have any, while a small percentage, 1.1 percent, feel they made a mistake by leaving.

Hong Kong Journalists Find Jobs in UK Broadcasters

According to the report, public broadcasters welcome former Hong Kong journalists who have emigrated to fill job vacancies because of their knowledge of Chinese and their familiarity with the overall environment of Hong Kong, and the exodus of Hong Kong people overseas.

Public broadcasters actively recruit former Hong Kong journalists who have emigrated abroad to fill job openings. These journalists bring specialized knowledge of the Chinese language and an understanding of the current conditions in Hong Kong and the exodus of its citizens overseas.

The BBC, VOA, and RFA have all employed Hong Kong journalists in the UK. Recently, a former Hong Kong journalist was hired by the BBC freelance after capturing footage of protesters being violently attacked outside the Chinese Consulate General in Manchester.

Insufficient Funding for Overseas Hong Kong Media

According to online information, at least a dozen of Hong Kong current affairs commentators or webcast hosts have emigrated overseas in recent years. The newly established overseas media for Hong Kong people include “The Chaser News, Commons, Green Bean Media, The Points, and Hongkonger Station,” among others.

Jane Poon, former head of digital news at Next Digital and editor-in-chief of The Points, has recently revealed that the Association’s Investigation Report indicated one of the main causes for their struggles was lack of operational capital. To keep the publication afloat for a year, they needed to raise US$320,000, however, only one percent of this target was achieved within the first month after its launch. This funding shortage has been identified as the major factor that disallowed the success of The Points.

Several veteran reporters have stated that it is more challenging for Hong Kong media outlets abroad to secure the necessary funding, so they have no plans to commit to journalism full-time. Moreover, they described such news sources as being under-resourced and having limited personnel, making it an unwelcoming prospect for those hoping to work in the industry.

Former Journalist Turns to Decoration Worker

Last year, Kenny, a former photojournalist for Next Digital’s entertainment section, spoke to the YouTube channel “Go UK (走佬去UK).” During the interview, he shared his recent life-changing experience. Kenny and his family had decided to move to the UK in late 2020 and switch to a career in decorating. Even though he went into the work with trepidation and was worried that he wouldn’t be able to make it, his new profession brought him the security of earning an income more stable than many white-collar jobs.

Cherry, a former journalist, moved to Canada in September and said in an interview she is taking a two-year diploma program to meet Stream A immigration requirements.

Many Media Outlets Shut Down After National Security Law Took Effect

In October 2022, the IFJ released its “Report on Freedom of Expression in Hong Kong,” providing an alarming assessment of the chilling effects of the National Security Law. Since its implementation on June 30, 2020, at least a dozen media outlets have been forced to close down in 2021 and 2022, including Apple Daily, Stand News, DB Channel, Post 852, Citizen News, FactWire News Agency, Polymer, Mad Dog Daily, and other news sources. Freedom of the press has been significantly weakened by the National Security Law, which has impacted press freedom in Hong Kong.

Several media and media professionals were arrested by the National Security Department of the police and prosecuted by the government on various charges. The founder of Next Media Group, Jimmy Lai Chi-ying, was arrested and subsequently indicted under the National Security Law on various charges. He has already been found guilty in multiple cases related to social movements. Under the National Security Law, he is accused of colluding with foreign powers to endanger national security. Lai pleaded not guilty, and his trial is expected to occur in September; he is currently serving a five-year and nine-month sentence for fraud.

The former editor-in-chief of Stand News, Chung Pui-kuen, and the former acting editor-in-chief, Patrick Lam Shiu-tung, have been charged with conspiracy to publish seditious publications. The case is currently in progress in the District Court. In April of 2022, Stand News veteran media blogger Alan Au was arrested by the National Security police on suspicion of “conspiracy to publish seditious publications.” His case has not yet been brought to court.

In September 2022, Tang Cheuk-yu, a former director of Taiwan Public Television and one of the defendants in the PolyU clash case from Nov. 18, 2019, was convicted of possessing an offensive weapon in a public place and sentenced to 15 months in prison.