Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s office on Tuesday dropped a murder charge against a bodega worker who was captured on camera stabbing a man who went behind the counter and attacked him.
“Following an investigation, the People have determined that we cannot prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was not justified in his use of deadly physical force,” said a motion filed Tuesday by Bragg’s office. “As such, the People will not be presenting the case to a Grand Jury and for the reasons provided in the attached memorandum, hereby move to dismiss the complaint.”
Jose Alba, 61, killed Austin Simon, 35, after Simon went behind the counter, shoved Alba, and stood over him as Alba sat against the wall. The footage showed Alba trying to get past Simon before he grabbed a knife and stabbed Simon several times.
Bragg’s office received criticism for charging Alba with second-degree murder, for initially requesting $500,000 bail, and for detaining Alba at New York City’s notorious Rikers Island jail. Bodega groups, tabloid newspapers, and New York City Mayor Eric Adams came to the clerk’s defense, saying he acted in self-defense and was being attacked by a bigger, younger man.
Self-Defense
Tuesday’s motion (pdf) filed by Bragg’s office noted that Alba could have argued that he acted in self-defense should the case go to trial.
“One potential defense is that Alba reasonably believed that Simon was about to use deadly physical force,” the dismissal memo said. “The law provides that a person may use deadly physical force to defend oneself if the person reasonably believes that another person is using or about to use deadly physical force.”
The motion continued: “Simon’s conduct in entering the store’s small, private area, throwing Alba against the wall to a place he could not escape, and grabbing him by the collar could inspire deep fear in an older and shorter man as to what might be in store next.”
Alba might have assumed he was about to be robbed or attacked, the memo said, adding that Simon could have been committing a crime by cornering the bodega worker against the wall.
“It is a crime in New York to use physical force to intentionally restrict a person’s movements by moving him from one place to another or by confining him,” the motion stated. If Alba suspected “Simon was committing or attempting to commit a burglary of an occupied building, then Alba was permitted to use deadly physical force upon Simon if Alba reasonably believed it to be necessary to prevent or terminate the commission of the burglary.”
Alba supporters, including Francisco Marte, president and founder of the Bodega and Small Business Group, said that the videos “make it clear that it’s a case of self-defense.”
United Bodegas of America spokesman Fernando Mateo told the New York Post that Bragg “did the right thing” by dropping the charges. “He has proved people wrong.”
