Neighbors Split in Swing-Vote Michigan Suburbs

October 16, 2019 Updated: October 16, 2019

LIVONIA, Mich.—At first glance, Cavell Street in Livonia, Michigan, looks tranquil enough—until the subject of the Democratic-led impeachment probe of President Donald Trump comes up.

A kind of suburban trench warfare is simmering amid the small detached houses and neatly trimmed lawns where diehard Trump lovers live next to Trump haters, and both sides are dug in.

Tensions run so high that nobody on the street displays a political yard sign, says Josh Robinson, 35, a steelworker who voted for Trump in 2016. Robinson says he’s “sick and tired” of Democrats’ complaining, noting that the impeachment probe of Trump makes him want to fight harder for the president.

A few doors up, sitting on her front step, Kristine Flaton says she can’t stand the president. “I wish he’d been impeached a long time ago,” said the 39-year-old, who is currently unemployed.

Michigan is a crucial presidential battleground. Trump carried the state by just 11,000 votes in 2016, an unexpected victory that, along with wins in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, propelled his ascent to the White House.

The precinct that includes Cavell Street in the city of Livonia, a suburb northwest of Detroit, split its votes 358–358 for Trump and Democrat Hillary Clinton in the 2016 presidential election, according to data organization OpenElections.

Fast-forward three years and there is little sign that either side has changed its mind about Trump.

If anything, attitudes appear to have been hardened by the House of Representatives’ decision to launch a formal impeachment inquiry three weeks ago after a whistleblower complaint about a July 25 call between President Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. The complaint alleges that Trump pressured Ukraine to investigate 2020 Democratic presidential rival Joe Biden.

In interviews with nearly 50 voters in Livonia and in two other swing suburbs in Michigan, where the vote was also evenly split between Trump and Clinton in 2016, Reuters found only one person who had flipped: Charles Pettyplace, 34, from Livonia, who voted for the Republican but now regrets it.

The impeachment investigation “just adds to the turmoil around him. It’s not what his office should be,” Pettyplace said.

But the clean split over the issue in the Michigan suburbs suggests another close battle in the state in the November 2020 election.

Split and Angry

About 100 miles north of Livonia, in Saginaw Township, Michigan, two precincts were split 876–876 and 765–764 between Trump and Clinton in 2016.

Three years later, voters seemed just as split, and angry.

Ray Kirby, 48, a chef taking a stroll along quiet residential Ann Street, says he was shocked to receive a totally split response when he recently sent a Facebook post supportive of the president.

“I’ve never seen that before. People either love him or hate him,” Kirby said.

Rob Grose, the manager of Saginaw Township, says many people in his town “have agreed to stop talking politics because of their opposing views, because they get into arguments.”

Hank Choate, a district chair of Michigan’s Republican Party and a member of its issues committee, expects the impeachment issue to cause huge voter turnout on both sides.

On one level, it helps his party to turn out more Republican votes, because Trump’s supporters are so energized. Yet he also worries that the same goes for the Democrats.

But the longer the inquiry goes on, the more alienated independent voters will become, predicts Choate, 69.

Carlee Giordano looks at her mobile phone at the Morning Emporium Coffee House in Precinct 7, where the vote was split 876/876 between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton in 2016, in Saginaw Township, Michigan on Oct. 11, 2019. REUTERS/Brian Snyder

Sipping coffee at a cafe in Saginaw Township, Carlee Giordano, 23, says she is afraid of discussing her political views in such a charged environment.

“People are either diehard blue or diehard red and it’s starting to bleed into everything else,” said Giordano, who wrote her college thesis on “toxic masculinity” and wants to see Trump impeached. “Your political views are becoming a personality trait.”

By Tim Reid