Macron’s Fired Former Guard Defends Himself at French Senate Inquiry

September 19, 2018 Updated: September 19, 2018

PARIS—French President Emmanuel Macron’s closest security officer, fired after video showed him beating May Day protesters, defended himself before a Senate inquiry on Sept. 19, saying he was neither a police officer nor a genuine bodyguard.

Alexandre Benalla, whose case erupted into a political scandal, with accusations of unchecked abuses of power in the presidential palace, was questioned for more than two hours about the nature of his job as Macron’s security shadow.

Speaking under oath, the neatly dressed former logistics aide at the Elysee was not questioned about the May Day beatings in Paris, but rather his very rapid ascent within Macron’s inner circle and how he had gained the right to carry a firearm.

“I was not Macron’s bodyguard and never was … I had a job of ensuring general organization, of security in general,” the 27-year-old, who has been accused of abusing his office and exercising powers that he should never have been granted.

Complaining of what he described as a media frenzy around him, Benalla calmly answered questions about how he came to carry a Gluck 43 pistol and to what extent his logistics job overlapped with the self-attributed role of bodyguard.

He said much of his role had involved liaising between Macron’s political office and the official security body charged with protecting the president, known as GSPR and made up of top-level gendarmes and senior police officers.

Political Scandal

The Senate inquiry is being conducted in parallel with a judicial investigation into the May 1 incident, which involved Benalla manhandling protesters during a police-led crowd control operation. While Benalla had asked to be present at the event as an observer, he ended up directly engaged in security and was seen on video wearing some police-marked clothing.

What turned the incident into a broader political scandal—the most serious of Macron’s 15 months in office—was the fact Benalla was fired only after the smartphone video became public on July 19, more than six weeks after the events.

That fueled a public perception that the office and people around Macron, whose approval rating has plunged to about 30 percent from highs of 60 percent, were either inept or slack or both when it came to matters of policing and security.

Macron’s ministers have rounded on the opposition-controlled Senate, warning members that they risk undermining the presidency and overreaching with their decision to summon Benalla even though a separate judicial investigation is underway.

In response, opponents have denounced what they regard as an unprecedented attack by the presidency on parliament.

“If only the executive office would leave parliament, in the capacity of the Senate, to carry out its work, all would be well with the republic,” said Jean-Pierre Sueur, a socialist senator, dismissing criticism leveled by the government’s spokesman.

Benalla himself initially refused to testify, calling the senators “illegitimate” and the investigation’s chairman a “little marquis.” He flatly apologized on Sept. 19, saying he had felt under pressure by the “media frenzy.”

Responding to senators’ questions without hesitation, Benalla said he requested a firearms permit for his personal safety rather than any bodyguard role.

By Brian Love