Journalist’s Passport Held Hostage by Chinese Consulate in Canada

August 16, 2010 1:51 pm Last Updated: March 14, 2012 7:10 pm

TORONTO—Zhang Zhaopei, a Chinese Canadian journalist, says his Canadian passport is being held hostage by the Chinese Consulate in Toronto because he refused to provide detailed information about his personal life in Canada.

Zhang applied for a visa to visit China from the Chinese Consulate in Toronto on Friday, submitting his Canadian passport as part of the process. But when he went to pick up his visa, he was given a blank sheet of paper and told to list extensive personal information about his work, family, and personal history.

He refused, saying he would abandon his visa application. But Zhang says he was told he still wouldn't get his Canadian passport back if he didn't provide the requested details.

“I never thought they can do this thing,” said Zhang, a reporter for New Tang Dynasty Television and a Falun Gong practitioner.

Zhang was attempting to return to China to visit his family who he has been unable to see in nine years.

Zhang had tried to return to China from Singapore in 2002 and 2004, only to be sent packing once he landed in Beijing and Shanghai respectively. At that time, he was told it was because he practiced Falun Gong, a traditional Chinese meditation practice that became the target of persecution in China in 1999 and has since put up a spirited defence of human rights.

Mr. Zhang immigrated to Canada in 2005 and has since become a citizen.

He said he wasn’t surprised he was denied a visa this time around, though having his passport withheld did come as a shock.

New Tang Dynasty Television has encountered interference from the Chinese regime in the past. The regime previously pressured a European satellite carrier to drop the station’s signal into China and has also attempted to exclude NTDTV from a press event inside Parliament Hill.

NTDTV and The Epoch Times made headlines in the lead-up to the G-20 this June when a press conference with Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Chinese leader Hu Jintao failed to take place due to the regime’s insistence that both media outlets be prohibited from attending, a request the Parliament Hill Press Gallery refused to accommodate.

Zhang said the information the consulate requested would have made it easier for the consulate to interfere and monitor his daily activities—something he didn’t want to facilitate.

“I think they just want to control everything of myself, including my work and everything. … They want to control everything,” he said.

Zhang told the consulate worker handling his case that if they didn’t return his passport, he would contact the police. A supervisor there told him to go ahead, he said.

After going to a police station to report the theft, he was told to return to the consulate and call the police from there. But when an officer arrived, Zhang was told there was nothing the officer could do.

A spokesperson for the Toronto Police Service told The Epoch Times that the case is unusual and not something they would get involved in, citing diplomatic reasons.

Because it is a passport seized by the Chinese Consulate and the passport is property of the Canadian government, the spokesperson said it did not qualify as theft.

The RCMP was also stumped as to how to handle the case.

“This is an unusual practice; this is not something that we have heard of,” said Const. Dave Banham, a media relations officer.

Banham surmised that the situation was due to a misunderstanding but could not offer any specific reason the police would not get involved, instead referring the matter to Passport Canada.

Passport Canada said Monday the document should be returned to the Canadian government.

"The Government of Canada remains the owner of all passports and if it has been seized it should be handed over to Passport Canada," said Veronique Robitaille, spokesperson for Passport Canada. She declined to comment further.

Joel Chipkar, a spokersperson for the Falun Dafa Association of Canada, said the case was an example of the Chinese regime's interference in Canada.

"The Chinese regime needs to understand that it is not the government of Chinese Canadians, and the Canadian government should make this point clear once and for all."

The Chinese Consulate did not answer repeated calls for comment.