Arias, convicted in 2013 for the brutal murder of her former lover Travis Alexander, claims her lead defense lawyer, Laurence Kirk Nurmi, violated attorney-client privilege to get material for his book “Trapped with Ms. Arias” which he self-published.
Nurmi had already been disbarred over the book, which is the first of a three-part series.
A statement released by Jody Arias’ lawyer says, “Mr. Nurmi’s self-published book about his representation of Ms. Arias revealed confidential and privileged information, and violated his most basic ethical and fiduciary duties to Ms. Arias.
“What he did was knowingly and intentionally wrong.
“His book violated his duty to protect confidential information and also contained false statements about Ms. Arias and gross misstatements about her case. He wrote the book in a selfish attempt to ‘redeem’ his public image and enrich himself to the extreme detriment of Ms. Arias.”
The lawsuit asks that all of Nurmi’s proceeds from the book be paid to Arias.
An Attempt at Redemption?
Nurmi claims that the trial ruined his life.
At first Nurmi thought the high-profile case would be good for his career. He soon learned that Arias was an aggressive and demanding client. In 2011 he resigned from the Public Defender’s office, but the judge in the case demanded that he stay on as lead attorney.
It took five years for the case to finally reach a jury. Arias was found guilty of first-degree murder but the jury was deadlocked on the penalty. This resulted in a second, penalty-phase trial which ended in 2015 with Arias receiving a life sentence.
In all Jodi Arias and her crime consumed almost eight years of Nurmi’s life.
The defense attorney became the object of public hatred for defending Arias, whom the public found unsympathetic, to say the least. Nurmi received hate mail and even death threats for doing a job he was legally obligated to do.
While the case was ongoing, Murmi was legally barred from speaking out in his own defense. now that it is over Nurmi says he is writing three volumes about the case, to tell the public what really went on.
“People still see me as a character: Nurmi the evil defense attorney who supports Jodi Arias,” Nurmi told reporter and author Shanna Hogan, who has written a book and several articles on the case.
“If the public wants to hate me—fine,” he told Hogan, “Just do it on the facts, the reality, not just their impressions from TV.”
In November of 2016 Nurmi was disbarred for publishing “Trapped with Ms. Arias: Part 1 of 3 From Getting the File to Being Ready for Trial.”
Jodi Arias hired attorney Karen Clark to protest the book, claiming Nurmi had revealed confidential communications and used them to disparage Ms. Arias.
Clark’s appeal to the Arizona State Bar Association said, in part, “Mr. Nurmi violates numerous ethical rules in his single-minded quest to rehabilitate his public image and line his pocket book at the expense of all others involved—most especially, and egregiously, his client Ms. Arias.”
The Bar Association agreed.
“The book, in its entirety, presents a negative view of [Arias] and her case,” states the State Bar of Arizona’s Agreement for Discipline by Consent, dated Nov. 14, 2016.
Nurmi agreed to accept a four-year suspension of his lawyer’s license, which Arias planned to dispute. Before any new papers could be filed, Nurmi agreed to a full disbarment.
It should be noted that Nurmi’s fees for the case amounted to an estimated $2.5 million.
Prosecutor Following Suit
Juan Martinez, the deputy county attorney who prosecuted the Arias case, has also written a book about it—and has also received several state Bar complaints.
These would be the fourth and fifth complaints filed against Martinez since 2015. The first three concerned other cases.
One of the new complaints was filed by an unknown individual and directly concerns Martinez’ book, “Conviction: The Untold Story of Putting Jodi Arias Behind Bars.”
Some legal ethicists feel the book is in violation because it was written before the case was out of Appeals Court.
The fifth complaint, filed by the Arizona Attorneys for Criminal Justice, pans at least 10 years of Martinez’s career and many of the cases he tried.