Film Review: ‘Night Will Fall,’ Documenting the Concentration Camps

January 24, 2015 Updated: January 21, 2015

It was a case of one legendary director replacing another. Billy Wilder was in and Alfred Hitchcock was out, but the project was not a suspense-thriller, like “Double Indemnity.” It was a Holocaust documentary that was to incorporate devastating footage shot by Allied film crews during the liberation of National Socialist concentration camps. Only years later would a partial, incomplete cut see any sort of meaningful exhibition.

However, the British Imperial War Museums have recently reconstructed and restored the intended director’s cut of the bureaucratically titled “German Concentration Camps Factual Survey.” Yet, there is still more to the story that is finally told in Andre Singer’s documentary, “Night Will Fall,” which premieres this coming Monday on HBO.

Some Hitchcock completists will be familiar with what was retitled “Memory of the Camps” when it aired on PBS, but the print was decidedly rough and the final reel was missing. Technically, it had never been completed (a problem the restoration team rectified using the surviving screenplay and cue lists). While it was generally known that Hitchcock was more of an adviser than a hands-on director, Singer and company actually make a compelling case that his vision largely guided the direction and aesthetic of the planned documentary.

The Americans still wanted a picture to convince Germans of their national guilt, so they recruited Wilder to recut some excerpts into the documentary short “Death Mills.”

While Hitchcock researchers really should consider it part of his filmography, producer Sidney Bernstein was the man most responsible for its day-to-day production and editing. Unfortunately, he would not see it to completion. With signs of the Cold War already surfacing during the early days of the Occupation of Berlin, the Allies essentially put the project in turnaround. The Americans still wanted a picture to convince Germans of their national guilt, so they recruited Wilder to recut some excerpts into the documentary short “Death Mills.”

As fascinating as the story is, Hitchcock fans will be disappointed he does not factor into “Night” to a greater extent, but he was only assigned to the project for a month. Nevertheless, they will gain a considerable appreciation for Bernstein, his team of editors, and the brave military cameramen who recorded the nightmarish footage in the first place. Ultimately, it is a tribute to their work, which in many cases left deep psychological and spiritual scars.

A scene from the documentary
A scene from the documentary “Night Will Fall,” which revisits Alfred Hitchcock’s work on a film about Nazi concentration camps. (RatPac Documentary Films)

There are some dramatic interviews with surviving veterans, and the excerpts from the finally finished film are truly horrific. “Night” also supplies a good deal of explanatory context that ought to be quite familiar to most viewers, but sadly is probably necessary given the declining level of historical awareness among younger generations and the precipitous rise of anti-Semitism abroad.

At just 75 minutes, “Night” is brisk but surprisingly comprehensive. It also further burnishes Hitchcock’s reputation and gives Bernstein his long overdue acknowledgment. One can imagine it works best screening in conjunction with the restored “Factual Survey” (as it did at last year’s Berlinale), but it easily stands alone.

Highly recommended for general audiences and particularly for students of history and cinema, “Night Will Fall” debuts Monday, Jan. 26, and repeats on various arms of HBO over the following days and weeks.


‘Night Will Fall’
Director: Andre Singer
Running time: 1 hour, 15 minutes
Release date: Jan. 23
Not rated

3.5 stars out of 5

Joe Bendel writes about independent film and lives in New York. To read his most recent articles, please visit