Film Review: ‘Beloved Sisters,’ Two Sisters, in Love With the Same Man

January 8, 2015 Updated: January 7, 2015

It is a love letter to love letters. Without the benefit of email and cellphones, Friedrich Schiller maintained ardent relationships with both von Lengefeld sisters, often communicating through neatly folded missives. Of course it was a secret, but only from society and not the siblings themselves.

Naturally, there were complications, developing and intensifying over the course of years in Dominik Graf’s “Beloved Sisters.”

The von Lengefelds are technically aristocrats, but they hardly have a mark to their names—hence Caroline’s marriage to the wealthy but boorish von Beulwitz. It is an unhappy union, but it provides the necessary support for Lengefeld’s younger sister Charlotte, nicknamed “Lollo,” and their overbearing mother.

Reluctantly resigned to her fate, Caroline tries to spend as much time as she can with her sister, who has been entrusted to her socially connected godmother, in hopes she can arrange a suitable match.

As a commoner known to advocate a radical Enlightenment philosophy, Schiller would hardly qualify. Nonetheless, when the younger von Lengefeld sister spies him from her window, he makes quite the roguish impression. When Caroline subsequently meets him during a holiday, she is also quite taken. It eventually leads to an understanding of sorts to share Schiller as best they can.

Of course, this is easier said than done, especially for a married woman like Caroline von Beulwitz. Eventually marital statuses will change, but the two sisters’ respective relationships with Schiller, Lollo’s future husband, will necessarily remain unequal. This consequently leads to almost three hours’ worth of drama.

Yes, “Beloved” essentially revolves around a sort of ménage à trois situation, but Graf emphasizes the literary and philosophical tenor of the times more than the potential luridness of his subject matter. In fact, the film is relatively chaste, all things considered, but there is still plenty of passion and jealousy. Yet, bigger issues loom over their private scandals, especially the French Revolution, which initially thrills and then horrifies Schiller and his intellectual circle.

Like the three-hour historical epics of old, “Beloved” is a big, chewy melodrama, filled with simmering yearning and cold sweats. Supposedly inspired by Schiller’s only letter to Caroline she did not manage to destroy before her death, Graf’s screenplay relies on considerable speculation, but the earnestness of the central trio gives it all the ring of truth.

While Caroline might have the short end of the ménage, Hannah Herzsprung gets the juiciest scenes as the divorcée turned romance novelist, making the most of them. It is a wonderfully complex and tragic character. However, Lollo is no shrinking violet either, nicely played by Henriette Confurius, who convincingly segues from her youthful coquetry to her more mature resolve.

If anyone is underwritten here, it is Schiller, but Florian Stetter portrays him with enough charismatic likability to suspend disbelief and generally hold the proceedings together.

Like the three-hour historical epics of old, “Beloved” is a big, chewy melodrama, filled with simmering yearning and cold sweats.

In a sense, “Beloved” is like a sequel to Philipp Stölzl’s “Goethe in Love” (whose protagonist Graf references but never shows), but it calls and raises its predecessor in nearly every category (especially running time, but it never feels that long).

It is a smart, literate, emotionally involving film that could honestly be considered old-fashion, in a good way. Recommended for patrons who enjoy quality period pictures, “Beloved Sisters” opens this Friday, Jan. 9, at Lincoln Plaza Cinemas and Landmark Sunshine Cinema.


‘Beloved Sisters’ (‘Die geliebten Schwestern’)

Director: Dominik Graf
Starring: Hannah Herzsprung, Florian Stetter, Henriette Confurius
Running time: 2 hours, 18 minutes
Release date: Jan. 9
Not rated

4 stars out of 5

Joe Bendel writes about independent film and lives in New York. To read his most recent articles, please visit