Family of American Woman Murdered in Costa Rica Sues Airbnb

December 22, 2018 Updated: December 22, 2018

The family of American Carla Stefaniak, who was murdered in or near an Airbnb rental in Costa Rica, filed a lawsuit against the company following her death.

Stefaniak, 36, a Florida resident, traveled to the Central American country in November to celebrate her birthday.

She was allegedly murdered by an illegal immigrant from Nicaragua who was working as a security guard at the hotel La Mares, also known as Villa le Mas, which rents out rooms through Airbnb, police officials said.

Her body was found near the rental on Dec. 3.

Stefaniak’s family filed the suit on Dec. 20, alleging that the company didn’t do a proper background check on Bismark Martinez, the illegal immigrant working as a security guard.

bismarck martinez arrest
Bismarck Espinoza Martinez, 32, was arrested for the murder of Carla Stefaniak in San Jose, Costa Rica on Dec. 4, 2018. (Costa Rica Office of Judicial Investigation)

“The security guard was not even legally authorized to be in Costa Rica, he was in the county illegally. He certainly wasn’t properly licensed as a security guard. He wasn’t even authorized to be employed,” Jack Gordon, the family’s lawyer, told Fox 13.

“Yet he was provided with his own apartment directly next to where Carla was staying.”

Gordon said Martinez was given free rein at the listing, handling the master keys to all the rentals and roaming the property.

They also said dangers and hazards at the vacation rental were ignored by the company despite being highlighted by customers who left negative reviews after staying there.

“A simple Google search was able to demonstrate there were a number of negative reviews, complaints that were made about this particular resort, about these particular owners and about this particular staff at the resort,” Gordon said. “Yet interestingly enough, there didn’t appear to be the same negative reviews on Airbnb.”

Stefaniak arrived at the rental around 5 p.m. on Nov. 27, and texted a friend that it was “pretty sketchy here,” including a picture of the Airbnb, friend Bugra Demirel of Tallahassee told the Associated Press.

carla stefaniak selfie
Carla Stefaniak, 36, went missing on Nov. 27, 2018. Her body was found on Dec. 3, 2018, near the Airbnb at which she was staying in San Jose, Costa Rica. (Carla Stefaniak/ Facebook)

Forensic analysis of the body indicated that “multiple persons were involved in removing and disposing” of her body, according to the lawsuit, reported the Tampa Bay Times. A report recently citing a source indicated that police officials believe three or four people were involved in the murder.

Airbnb removed Villa le Mas—a compound with seven vacation apartments—from its site after the murder. The company said representatives reached out to the family and expressed condolences.

Frederico Jenkins, the villa’s attorney, said previously that the owners are cooperating with the authorities.

The owners nor Jenkins have not responded to the lawsuit.

Airbnb said in a statement to the Times that it was “standing by to support (the) investigation, as justice must be served quickly.”

“Our hearts are broken for Carla’s family, friends, and loved ones,” the statement said. “We reached out to provide support to them during this unimaginably difficult time.”

The company did not directly address the allegations in the lawsuit.

From NTD News

Follow Zachary on Twitter: @zackstieber