Hong Kong Filmmakers Say Censorship Law Spooks Investors, Actors

Hong Kong Filmmakers Say Censorship Law Spooks Investors, Actors
Director Kiwi Chow poses for photos after an interview in Hong Kong on May 11, 2023. (Tyrone Siu/Reuters)

HONG KONG—Two years after screening an internationally acclaimed documentary on the democracy movement in Hong Kong, director Kiwi Chow has been forced to complete a new movie with fresh financing after political concerns scared off some investors.

The fears spiked after Hong Kong adopted a new censorship law in October 2021 to bar films that “might endanger national security”, but directors say they now face difficulties lining up funding and even actors, while others have shifted overseas.

“Actors under the Hong Kong film companies are very afraid, and this fear shadows everything,” said Chow, who felt the situation had made performers, and investors, apprehensive about crossing ill-defined “red lines” concerning national security.

“This is what makes it scary, it doesn’t need to suppress you directly, but it has already made all these people scared,” he added.

Director Kiwi Chow poses for photos after an interview in Hong Kong on May 11, 2023. (Tyrone Siu/Reuters)
Director Kiwi Chow poses for photos after an interview in Hong Kong on May 11, 2023. (Tyrone Siu/Reuters)

Chow, feted at the Cannes film festival in 2021 for his documentary, “Revolution of Our Times”, said it was clear when the new law came in that filmmakers would have to steer clear of political topics.

But he did not realize then that people would be so risk-averse, even if he had not been found guilty of anything.

The censorship measure, which follows a national security law Beijing imposed on the Asian financial hub in 2020, means directors now need to steer clear of some topics to avoid putting investors and actors at risk, some filmmakers said.

At least 21 movies and short films have had scenes cut or their release blocked by Hong Kong’s Office for Film, Newspaper, and Article Association (OFNAA) since October 2021, a Reuters tally showed.

In an email statement, the office said it had processed about 5,000 applications for film classification since January 2021, denying approval for public exhibition to six of them.

But it declined to comment on individual films.

Since 2005, the former British colony has injected HK$1.54 billion into the Film Development Fund. But in February, its culture secretary, Kevin Yeung, warned that funds would not be allocated to film projects that might infringe the 2020 law.

It is not immediately clear how much censorship measure has affected such funding.

Replying to a Reuters query, Hong Kong’s Film Development Council, which is mainly responsible for government funding of the industry, said in an email it would have to look into the matter before responding.

Yet filmmakers see little room for maneuver.

Chow scrambled to complete his new film after investors pulled 80 percent of its HK$8 million ($1 million) funding and the main actor withdrew.

Although his film, “Say I Do To Me”, a love story about a young woman who embarks on a journey of self-discovery, is far from political, Chow said investors told him they could not take the risk as they still had to do business with China.

“For them, ‘Revolution of Our Times’ is a very sensitive movie,” Chow added. “They think they have business with China, so even if there is little risk, they all find it unacceptable, not to mention that in their eyes, this is a very high risk.”

In response to a Reuters query, a police spokesman declined to clarify whether watching or downloading the film was illegal, however.

Fresh Funding

About 40 to 50 supporters injected fresh funding to help him complete it, he added.

“'Revolution of Our Times’ made me lose a lot of things, but it has also attracted some other new funding.”

Some actors who wanted to participate in the new film were either pressed not to do so by their management companies, or told by producers that scenes featuring them would be cut from other movies, Chow said.

Some told Chow they had signed contracts barring them from making speeches that violate the national security law or cooperating with people considered a political risk.

“These contracts use economic pressure to restrain them, so that they cannot speak up,” he said.

The makers of three short films screened at the Fresh Wave International Film Festival in June “had chosen to replace the deleted parts with black images and muted sound” after they were censored, organizers said.

Rex Ren and David Chan, co-founders of independent production group Phone Made Good Film, said they had no plan to seek government funds and would keep to small budgets instead.

“It’s because we need to create, so we persist in Hong Kong,” Ren said.

The day before their Loose Narratives short film festival began in April, censors denied approval for their short film “Wake in Silence”, citing “possible seditious intentions.”

The scene in question showed a flag of the now disbanded pro-democracy party Demosisto with the slogan, “100% Freedom.”

The tale of a girl who misses her boyfriend after he left the city was the third film censored in the festival.

“I already feel that the need to be safe has increased a lot, and there are some topics that have become taboo,” said Ho Cheuk-Tin, adjudged Best New Director at this year’s Hong Kong Film Awards for his film, “The Sparring Partner.”

Ho, who has been busy promoting his second movie, “Over My Dead Body,” a comedy about the frenzied real estate market, has chosen to stay on, however.

“I consider myself more commercial, but I still hope to have lots of Hong Kong elements in my movies,” he said.

Others, in contrast, have moved abroad to take Hong Kong films to the diaspora communities and global audiences in Britain, Canada, and the United States.

“We are scared of the disappearance of the culture and arts of Hong Kong,” said Ching Wong, who founded Hong Kong Film Festival UK along with director Ng Ka Leung in 2021. It held more than 60 screenings across seven British cities in March.

Still, for those at home, the scenario remains bleak.

“At this moment, the chance of me finding funds in the Hong Kong market and the Hong Kong government seems to be close to zero,” filmmaker Chow said.

($1=7.82 Hong Kong dollars)

By Jessie Pang