Bruins and Habs Renew NHL’s Oldest Rivalry

April 13, 2011 Updated: April 13, 2011
RIVALRY: Boston's Nathan Horton and Montreal's Tomas Plekanec should see a lot of action against each other in the next few days. (Elsa/Getty Images)
RIVALRY: Boston's Nathan Horton and Montreal's Tomas Plekanec should see a lot of action against each other in the next few days. (Elsa/Getty Images)

It seems the Habs and Bruins just can’t get enough of each other. Once again Montreal and Boston meet in the Stanley Cup playoffs. The NHL’s greatest hockey rivalry is set to write it’s 33rd chapter.

The Canadiens have won 24 of 32 prior playoff series against the Bruins but very recent history favors Boston. Two years ago, the first-place Bruins swept the eighth-place Canadiens. Montreal won the regular season series 4–2, however Boston won two of the last three meetings including a 7–0 drubbing on Mar. 24.

This chapter in the rivalry sets up particularly nicely given a series of highly talked-about events during the six-game regular season series between the two teams.

On Feb. 9, Boston beat Montreal 8–6 in a fight-filled game that brought back memories of the old-time hockey played in the 1970s when Don Cherry coached the Bruins and Scotty Bowman was in charge of the Canadiens.

Montreal bounced back to win the next meeting 4–1, but toward the end of the game Boston’s 6-foot-9-inch defenseman Zdeno Chara sent Montreal forward Max Pacioretty head first into the stanchion that demarcates where the glass begins on top of the boards. The devastating hit sidelined Pacioretty with a broken neck and concussion. Chara escaped any suspension.

Big, Bad Bruins?

Certainly, at first blush, it’s the big, bad Bruins against the smaller, faster Canadiens. The theme appears to be no different than what has been typical throughout the long history the two rivals share. Boston’s top six forwards average 6-feet-1-inches whereas Montreal’s are 5-feet-10.5-inches.

But if we scratch below the surface, we find that Montreal is far more undisciplined. While the two rivals put up roughly the same total penalty minutes, it was Montreal that was second worst in the league in taking minor penalties while Boston took the sixth fewest. Essentially, Boston took a lot more fighting majors and misconduct penalties, which don’t give the opposition a man advantage.

Then, the question becomes strength on special teams. Montreal has the edge here with a better penalty killing and power play unit (both ranking seventh best in the league) whereas Boston languishes in 20th and 16th place respectively.

Montreal can’t rely on its power play to win games and cannot give Boston chance after chance on its power play. If the regular season is a predictor of the post-season, the Bruins will give the Habs relatively few power play opportunities despite their tag of being the “big bad Bruins.”

What the Bruins lack in special teams is more than compensated for with their five-on-five play. The Bruins boast five players that are +25 or better while the Canadiens best in this category is Jaroslav Spacek at +9. With referees calling fewer penalties in playoff hockey, five-on-five play becomes more important than special teams.

Pacioretty Loss Hurts

In that famous 7–0 win, the talk leading up to the game revolved around retribution for Pacioretty and how the Habs would respond to Boston’s intimidation. While that game certainly is not a barometer for the Habs–Bruins matchup, it did show that Boston has some highly talented players and doesn’t need to use intimidation as a tactic. Montreal needs to prove that loss left no psychological effects.

Pacioretty had a terrific regular season against Boston. Josh Gorges was an important part of Montreal’s first two victories against Boston. Both players are not available for this series.


PRESSURE: Carey Price bears the weight of Montreal's hopes on his shoulders. (Elsa/Getty Images)
PRESSURE: Carey Price bears the weight of Montreal's hopes on his shoulders. (Elsa/Getty Images)
DO OR DIE: Tim Thomas had a terrific regular season but now he needs to prove himself in the playoffs. (Elsa/Getty Images)
DO OR DIE: Tim Thomas had a terrific regular season but now he needs to prove himself in the playoffs. (Elsa/Getty Images)
Be prepared to see some great goaltending in this series. Montreal’s Carey Price and Boston’s Tim Thomas are two of the league’s best albeit in different ways.

Thomas seems to have no particular style. His unorthodox methods have nevertheless led him to a .938 save percentage and 2.00 goals against average, which are best in the league. Price is very sound fundamentally and is Montreal’s MVP.

Thomas has the edge in playoff experience but Montreal should not be concerned about Price’s lack of it. Price may not be able to pull off the heroics Jaroslav Halak did last year but there’s no reason to believe he won’t continue his impressive regular season form.

With two terrific goalies, it will come down to which one consistently delivers the big saves and energizes his teammates. Both goalies are capable of doing this and it would be hard to say one will do it better than the other.


P.K. Subban has emerged this season as a superstar in the making for the Canadiens. But Boston’s Zdeno Chara is an established superstar on defense.

Montreal’s defense, aside from Subban, is not particularly mobile. While defensemen like Hal Gill, Paul Mara, Jaroslav Spacek, and Roman Hamrlik aren’t speedsters, they are experienced and fulfill their roles well. James Wisniewski is capable of supporting the attack and playing on the power play but his defensive weaknesses can be alarming at times.

Boston’s defensive corps behind Chara got a big boost with the addition of Tomas Kaberle. The veteran Kaberle adds offense and is no slouch on defense. Youngster Adam McQuaid is reliable defensively and at 6-feet-5-inches can be an effective physical force.

Boston has the advantage on defense as Montreal is without Andrei Markov and Gorges and their replacements aren’t of the same quality, not surprisingly.


Boston’s top line features power forwards Milan Lucic and Nathan Horton. Lucic is a throwback to Cam Neely, a forward who would intimidate opposing defensemen with his physicality while popping in a few goals as well. Lucic racked up 30 goals and Horton chipped in with 26.

Montreal’s top six forwards have been very inconsistent resulting in the fewest goals scored of any playoff team. But they have the snipers in Brian Gionta, Michael Cammalleri, and Andrei Kostitsyn. These are guys who can get hot and score goals in bunches.

Montreal’s problem is not having Pacioretty and the need to play a true third or fourth-liner on one of the top two lines.

While Montreal-Boston has to be one of the most highly anticipated matchups in the first round, it could be quite lopsided in favor of Boston. If Montreal is to win this series, Carey Price will have to steal it for them.

Prediction: Boston in five games.

Follow Rahul Vaidyanath on Twitter.

Follow Rahul on Twitter: @RV_ETBiz