Beijing Pioneering Citizens’ ‘Points’ System Critics Brand ‘Orwellian’

November 20, 2018 Updated: November 20, 2018

BEIJING—Beijing’s municipal government will assign citizens and firms “personal trustworthiness points” by 2021, state media reported on Nov. 20, pioneering China’s controversial plan for a “social credit” system to monitor citizens and businesses.

The system’s rollout has attracted international headlines, sparking comparisons to George Orwell’s novel “Nineteen Eighty-Four,” with critics saying it could massively heighten the Chinese Communist Party’s already strict control over society.

In a roadmap plan released in 2014, China said by 2021 it would create a “social credit system” to reward or punish individuals and corporations using technology to record various measures of financial credit, personal behavior, and corporate misdeeds.

But it had not made any mention of using points, as proposed by Beijing’s municipal government in a new plan released Nov. 19 to improve the city’s business environment.

Lists of data, actions and measures will be used to create a trial system of “personal trustworthiness points” for residents and companies in the capital. The term used can also be translated as “creditworthiness” or “integrity.”

Information from the system could impact market access, public services, travel, employment and the ability to start businesses, with trustworthy individuals being provided a “green channel” and those who are blacklisted being “unable to move a step.”

“This is an important novel approach by Beijing to assess individuals’ credit and tie it to their whole life,” an unnamed official from the municipal state planner said, according to state media Xinhua news agency.

The plan should serve as an example to the rest of the nation for how to improve the behavior of individuals and businesses, Xinhua said.

A second system will also be set up to assess the trustworthiness of government officials and departments by measuring whether contracts and promises are honored, the results of which will be included in performance assessments.

The social credit system, which is being built on the principle of “once untrustworthy, always restricted,” will encourage government bodies to share more information about individual and business misdeeds in order to coordinate punishments and rewards.

Some experts say the system remains nascent and could help tackle social problems like fraud or food security, as well as noting that punishments are mostly restricted to industry specific blacklists rather than a holistic score.

A system for penalizing individuals blacklisted for such offenses as failing to pay a court-mandated fines that was put in place by the central government was extended in March. The penalties include banning offenders from making luxury purchases, such as tickets for flights or high-speed rail, for up to a year.

Besides recording minor infractions like jaywalking or smoking in public, the system could also record and punish citizens for making dissenting speeches.

In compliance with the regime’s directives, China’s major social media sites have already implemented a similar system to muffle users who say what is prohibited. Weibo, China’s equivalent of Twitter, has already rolled out a “credit score” system to measure how much a user is compliant with the site’s speech policies.

The social credit system is an extreme continuation of social controls that are fundamental to all communist systems.

By Christian Shepherd. The Epoch Times contributed to this report.