How One Teacher Completely Avoids Using Textbooks

How One Teacher Completely Avoids Using Textbooks
Today's high schools often focus on the accumulation of facts, rather than age-appropriate synthesis. Shutterstock
Annie Holmquist
Updated:

A teacher dramatically strumming his guitar, singing a song to giggling high school students, recently graced a Washington Post article by Jay Mathews.

While the guitar serenade is a unique feature of Mark Ingerson’s AP history course, the more intriguing thing about his classroom is that it doesn’t rely on traditional textbooks. Ingerson, Mathews reports, doesn’t believe in them because they offer a firehose of information that students never remember. He keeps a few basic texts on hand, but mostly to satisfy official requirements.

Instead, Ingerson takes a different approach to teaching history. The students learn facts, but in a more interactive way through source material, collaboration, and discussion. Mathews describes the classroom scene:

“This past year teaching AP, he [Ingerson] had each student compile 200 flashcards. They repeatedly paired up to quiz each other. ‘I wanted students to know the material so well that if I said ”Federalist 10,“ literally any student could spout off three to four specific ideas that made that document important and could use that in an argument,’ he said.”

Why does he take this unique approach?

Annie Holmquist
Annie Holmquist
Author
Annie Holmquist is a cultural commentator hailing from America's heartland who loves classic books, architecture, music, and values. Her writings can be found at Annie’s Attic on Substack.
Related Topics