Subscribe

Does Memory Reside Outside the Brain?

By Leonardo Vintini
Epoch Times Staff
Created: August 29, 2008 Last Updated: March 18, 2012
Related articles: Science » Beyond Science
Print E-mail to a friend Give feedback

Morphogenetic Fields

But if memory does not live in the brain, where does it reside? Following the notions of previous biologists, Sheldrake believes that all organisms belong to their own brand of form-resonance—a field existing both within and around an organism, which gives it instruction and shape

An alternative to the predominant mechanist/reductionism understanding of biology, the morphogenetic approach sees organisms intimately connected to their corresponding fields, aligning themselves with the cumulative memory that the species as a whole has experienced in the past.

Yet these fields become ever more specific, forming fields within fields, with each mind—even each organ—having its own self resonance and unique history, stabilizing the organism by drawing from past experience. “The key concept of morphic resonance is that similar things influence similar things across both space and time,” writes Sheldrake.

Still, many neurophysicists insist on probing ever deeper into the cerebrum to find the residence of memory. One of the more well known of these researchers was Karl Lashley, who demonstrated that even after up to 50 percent of a rat’s brain had been cut away, the rat could still remember the tricks it had been trained to perform.

Curiously, it seemed to make no difference which half of the brain was removed—lacking either a left or right hemisphere, the rodents were able to execute the learned actions as before. Successive investigators revealed similar results in other animals.

Picture This

The holographic theory, born from experiments such as those of Lashley, considers that memory resides not in a specific region of the cerebrum but instead in the brain as a whole. In other words, like a holographic image, a memory is stored as an interference pattern throughout the brain.

However, neurologists have discovered that the brain is not a static entity, but a dynamic synaptic mass in constant flux— all of the chemical and cellular substances interact and change position in a constant way. Unlike a computer disc which has a regular, unchanging format that will predictably pull up the same information recorded even years before, it is difficult to maintain that a memory could be housed and retrieved in the constantly changing cerebrum.

But conditioned as we are to believe that all thought is contained within our heads, the idea that memory could be influenced from outside our brains appears at first to be somewhat confusing.

Sheldrake writes in his article “Staring Experiments”:  “… as you read this page, light rays pass from the page to your eyes, forming an inverted image on the retina. This image is detected by light-sensitive cells, causing nerve impulses to pass up the optic nerves, leading to complex electrochemical patterns of activity in the brain.

All this has been investigated in detail by the techniques of neurophysiology. But now comes the mystery. You somehow become aware of the image of the page. You experience it outside you, in front of your face. But from a conventional scientific point of view, this experience is illusory. In reality, the image is supposed to be inside you, together with the rest of your mental activity.”

While the search for memory challenges traditional biological understanding, investigators like Sheldrake believe that the true residence of memory is to be found in a non-observable spatial dimension.

This idea aligns with more primal notions of thought such as Jung’s “collective unconscious” or Taoist thinking that sees the human mind and spirit derived from various sources both inside and outside the body, including the energetic influences of several different organs (except, of course, the brain).

In this view, the brain does not act as a storage facility, or even the mind itself, but the physical nexus necessary to relate the individual with its morphic field.

Follow EpochTimesSci & EpochTimesSpace on Twitter

Find us on Facebook: facebook.com/epochtimessci

Please send any feedback to qa.science@epochtimes.com




  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tall-Desk/100001156758685 Tall Desk

    I have always thought that scientists have figured out everything !  What a dope have I been.

  • 12Gd34

    It’s hilarious that science has been trying to figure this out from an extremely limited intellectual perspective. What if all life on this planet was actually a holograph? What most people call outer space could actually be a meditation zone. But, I guess we’ll get into all that in a few hundred years.

  • justin shin

    a couple questions. 
    If it isn’t stored inside the brain, where is it stored? This “field” idea is less supported then the idea of a physical structure, and this person seems to be claiming memory is from some other dimension or just manifests from thin air.

    If memory is not stored inside the brain, how come if i drove a railroad spike in someones head, it could wipe out some memories while leaving others untouched? The TV analogy fails here, because if the brain is merely acting as a medium or an interpreter, you would not be able to target specific memories, because the article says that by damaging the brain, you would be damaging the interpretation rather than the memory itself.

    The experiment with the rats also has some problems. Sure, a rat might not be affected in its attempts to do a trick, but we know humans are very different. If I were to delete half of a humans brain, no matter what part, some functions would be much more affected then others, as a humans brain is more specified than a rats brain.

    And this “organ mind” thing is ridiculous. Say I have a liver and kidney transplant, would I suddenly lose some mental faculty or memory? Of course not. 

    Anyways, this proposal that memory lies somewhere outside the physical plane of existence is a worse explanation then the explanation it is trying to replace.

    • asha007

      Justin, how does a  magnet work?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ivan-Pentchoukov/100002377796360 Ivan Pentchoukov

    Awesome!

  • http://www.spiralyne.co.uk/ Spirulina

    Nice idea but it doesn’t make sense. In areas of high electro-magnetic distorsion people can still think, speak and remember. In these areas surely any magnetic waves around the head where memories are stored would be inaccessible.  

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ter-Lawson/100002180043839 Ter Lawson

    We are all nothing more than energy so why wouldn’t whatever field of energy that holds us in our form be more than a bread wrapper? Interesting theory. It might also explain why there appears to be a group mind. 



Selected Topics from The Epoch Times

High Performance Business Coaching with Dave Mather