Poland Urges EU Sanctions on Russian, Belarusian Farm Products

The production standards in Ukraine, Russia, and Belarus are lower, and pesticides and fertilizers are incredibly cheap, according to the Polish prime minister.
Poland Urges EU Sanctions on Russian, Belarusian Farm Products
Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk attends a joint statement to the media with French President Macron (not pictured) as part of their meeting at Elysee Palace, Paris, France, 12 February 2024. (Christophe Petit Tesson/Pool via Reuters)
Ella Kietlinska
3/5/2024
Updated:
3/5/2024
0:00

Poland, seeking to meet the needs of protesting farmers, plans to ask the European Union to put sanctions on Russian and Belarusian agricultural products, Prime Minister Donald Tusk said on March 4 during a visit to Vilnius, the Lithuanian capital.

Like much of Europe, Poland has been gripped by protests in recent weeks as farmers demonstrate against the EU’s regulations to tackle climate change and unfair competition from Ukraine after the EU waived duties on Ukrainian food imports to help the country after Russia’s invasion.

“I would like to inform you that today I will turn to the Speaker of the [Polish] Parliament with a proposal for a resolution calling on the European Commission to impose full sanctions on agricultural and food products from Russia and Belarus,” Mr. Tusk said during a joint conference with Lithuanian Prime Minister Ingrida Simonyte.

He said joint EU decisions would be more effective than measures introduced by individual countries. Ms. Simonyte said Vilnius would support the initiative.

Last week, Mr. Tusk said market disruptions were also caused by agricultural products from Russia and Belarus and didn’t rule out introducing a ban.

“We will want to somehow limit the export of Ukrainian grain and agricultural products to Poland,” he said at a press conference on Feb. 29, but at the same time, Russian and Belarusian agricultural products should not go unrestricted in the Polish market.

Mr. Tusk explained his proposal by pointing out that the structures of agriculture and technology in Ukraine, Russia, and Belarus are completely different from those in Europe.

The production standards are lower, there are no climate restrictions there, and pesticides and fertilizers are incredibly cheap, he pointed out.

“In Russia and Belarus, especially since they have problems with selling gas, they turn this gas into fertilizers,” Mr. Tusk said. “It is an illusion that anyone in Europe would be able to compete with Russian, Belarusian, but also Ukrainian food and products.”

Meeting With Polish Farmers

Polish farmers protest near the border with Ukraine over price pressures, taxes, and green regulation, grievances shared by farmers across Europe, in Hrubieszow, Poland, on Feb. 9, 2024. (Jakub Orzechowski/Agencja Wyborcza.pl via Reuters)
Polish farmers protest near the border with Ukraine over price pressures, taxes, and green regulation, grievances shared by farmers across Europe, in Hrubieszow, Poland, on Feb. 9, 2024. (Jakub Orzechowski/Agencja Wyborcza.pl via Reuters)
On Feb. 29, Mr. Tusk met with representatives of Polish farmers’ organizations and trade unions to discuss farmers’ demands and grievances.

The problems farmers face in Poland are “exceptionally severe,” he told reporters.

More than a year ago, Polish farmers could sell wheat they produced at about 300 euros ($326) per metric ton, but today Polish farmers can count on about 150 euros ($163) per metric ton, provided that they find a buyer, according to Mr. Tusk.

Production costs, such as the cost of artificial fertilizers, have increased over the past two or three years, and energy costs have doubled.

“And suddenly, the green deal and further restrictions are imposed on top of it,” he said.

The farmers’ representatives at the meeting had high hopes that Mr. Tusk would be able to negotiate a solution with the EU, but the Polish prime minister said it “is not an easy task.”

According to the Polish Ministry of Agriculture, the price that farmers were able to sell wheat at in January 2022 was 309 euros ($336) per metric ton. About a year later it had dropped to 196 euros ($213) per metric ton. Polish agricultural portal Cenyrolnicze.pl reported the average price of wheat on March 4 was down to 170 euros ($185) per metric ton.

Supporting Ukraine

When speaking at a press conference after meeting with the farmers’ representatives on Feb. 29, Mr. Tusk expressed support for Ukraine in its war with Russia but said that this cannot be done at the expense of the Polish farmer. However, “the border crossings [to Ukraine] must be absolutely safe and open for military transports, military equipment, [and] humanitarian aid for Ukraine.”

He said the EU’s climate regulations must be more flexible and shouldn’t force compliance under the threat of losing subsidies.

Mr. Tusk also said he supports the farmers’ demand for the EU to finance the purchase and transport of grain from European markets for other countries in need, noting that the grain surplus in Europe is nearly 30 million metric tons.

While Ukraine definitely deserves support, “the interests of several dozen large companies, the so-called Ukrainian agro-holdings, cannot be more important than the interests of Europe and our farmers,” he said.

“It has nothing to do with Ukraine’s security,” Mr. Tusk said.

Jakub Piecuch, an economics professor at the University of Agriculture in Krakow, Poland, told Polish media outlet Onet that “allowing [Ukrainian] grain into Poland does not mean support for Ukrainians.”

More than a dozen giant companies are operating in Ukraine producing various foods, including grain, that aren’t owned by Ukrainians but by German, Dutch, or Middle Eastern capital, according to Mr. Piecuch. Apart from the physical labor provided by Ukrainians to these companies, the country gains little from exporting grains, as global food corporations earn “huge amounts of money from it.”

Reuters contributed to this report.