Hurricanes Keep Ruining Beach Hotels. Investors Like Them Anyway

Hurricanes Keep Ruining Beach Hotels. Investors Like Them Anyway
A photo taken on September 6, 2017 shows damage outside the "Mercure" hotel in Marigot, on the Bay of Nettle, on the island of Saint-Martin in the northeast Caribbean, after the passage of Hurricane Irma. Lionel Chamoiseau/AFP/Getty Images
|Updated:

Frenchman’s Reef, the largest resort on St. Thomas, was smashed by Hurricane Irma, which breached roofs, caved-in walls, and felled trees across the oceanfront property. Two years later, the hotel remains closed as its owner quarrels with insurers over millions in damages.

It sounds bad, but it’s business as usual in the Caribbean, where resort owners balance room rates against insurance premiums and brace for the next disaster. Frenchman’s Reef is a good example. It closed for extensive repairs in 1997 after hurricanes battered the property in previous years.