France Farmers Say Will Take Protests Against Excessive Green Regulations, EU Directives Into Paris

Despite the government backing down on a proposed fuel hike, French farmers say more action is needed, as a new week of protests target the capital.
France Farmers Say Will Take Protests Against Excessive Green Regulations, EU Directives Into Paris
French farmers stop their tractors on the D338 road in Le Mans, northwestern France, on Jan. 26, 2024 as part of a nationwide day of protests called by several farmers unions on pay, tax, and overregulation. The sign on one of the tractors reads "éleveur en danger" meaning "breeder in danger." Farmers have fumed at what they say is a squeeze on purchase prices for produce by supermarket and industrial buyers, as well as complex environmental regulations. (GUILLAUME SOUVANT/AFP)
Stephen Katte
1/29/2024
Updated:
1/29/2024
0:00

French agricultural unions are prepared to mount an “indefinite siege” on Paris starting Monday, as part of ongoing protests calling for the government to roll back a range of uncompetitive regulations hurting the livelihoods of the nation’s growers and agricultural workers.

According to France’s two main farming unions, the FNSEA (Fédération Nationale des Syndicats d'Exploitants Agricoles) and the Jeunes Agriculteurs, their members are ready to converge on the French capital with their tractors and other farming equipment. All major roads will be blocked for an “indefinite period,” mimicking a medieval siege, without the bloodshed, until their grievances are solved.

Farmers from the Lot-et-Garonne region, a hotspot for the protest movement in southern France, were among the many groups intending to march on Paris and blockade the Rungis wholesale food market south of the capital, which supplies the capital and its surrounding regions with much of their fresh food.

Among the concerns being aired by the farmers are not receiving a fair price for their produce and little to no protection against supermarkets buying cheaper imports and undercutting them. Endless red tape, low fuel emissions targets, low pensions, and complex environmental laws have also been flagged as concerns by the farmers.

French farmers are forbidden from using farming products that their competitors in neighboring countries, such as Italy, still have the right to use.

As part of the environmental laws, farmers are also required to keep a portion of their land as fallow. The farming technique involves leaving tracts of land without crops for one or more growing cycles. In theory, it’s supposed to allow the land to recover and disrupt the life cycle of pests. However, the farmers are already struggling to make a living; being forced to leave land vacant and not utilizing their whole farm only adds to the issue.

French Government Mobilize Police and Paramilitary Forces

The final straw for many French farmers was the phasing-out of a tax break on diesel for farm equipment. It sparked protests that have been ongoing for the last two weeks, with over 100 blockades around the country.

Farmers have been using their tractors to block long sections of road, slow traffic, dump agricultural waste at the gates of government offices, and take a range of other actions meant to disrupt and put pressure on policymakers.

Unions in other French industries have also flagged strike action as a possibility to show solidarity. The latest escalation and possible action at the capital have caused the French government to intensify its efforts to quell the growing unrest.

Farmers unload tyres and waste to block the entrance of a Leclerc supermarket in Le Mans, northwestern France, on Jan. 26, 2024, as part of a nationwide day of protests called by several farmers unions on pay, tax and regulations. Farmers have fumed at what they say is a squeeze on purchase prices for produce by supermarket and industrial buyers, as well as complex environmental regulations. (GUILLAUME SOUVANT/AFP)
Farmers unload tyres and waste to block the entrance of a Leclerc supermarket in Le Mans, northwestern France, on Jan. 26, 2024, as part of a nationwide day of protests called by several farmers unions on pay, tax and regulations. Farmers have fumed at what they say is a squeeze on purchase prices for produce by supermarket and industrial buyers, as well as complex environmental regulations. (GUILLAUME SOUVANT/AFP)
A farmer pulls waste to block the RN 19 near Vesoul, eastern France, on Jan. 25, 2024. French farmers continued their actions on Jan. 25, 2024, and are eagerly awaiting a response from the government to their request for "immediate" aid worth several hundred million euros. (SEBASTIEN BOZON/AFP)
A farmer pulls waste to block the RN 19 near Vesoul, eastern France, on Jan. 25, 2024. French farmers continued their actions on Jan. 25, 2024, and are eagerly awaiting a response from the government to their request for "immediate" aid worth several hundred million euros. (SEBASTIEN BOZON/AFP)
Farmers of the CR47 union (Coordination rurale 47) dump slurry at the entrance to the prefecture in Agen, southwestern France, on Jan. 26, 2024. As they await the French Prime Minister's announcements on Jan. 26, 2024, farmers are blocking many major roads across France. (Christophe ARCHAMBAULT/AFP)
Farmers of the CR47 union (Coordination rurale 47) dump slurry at the entrance to the prefecture in Agen, southwestern France, on Jan. 26, 2024. As they await the French Prime Minister's announcements on Jan. 26, 2024, farmers are blocking many major roads across France. (Christophe ARCHAMBAULT/AFP)

Interior Minister Gerald Darmanin revealed during an emergency meeting at 7 p.m. on Jan. 28 that over 15,000 police officers and paramilitary gendarmes have been mobilized to prevent further escalation and prevent the proposed siege of Paris, while expressing “understanding” towards the farmers’ protest.

“The posture remains the same: the police must act with great moderation,” he said.

According to Mr. Darmanin, orders have been given to stop the blockades of Rungis International Market, protect Paris airports, and prevent any convoy of farmers from entering the capital and any other big city, which would be considered crossing a red line. Helicopters are monitoring the known conveys of farmers en route.

Farmers block the Iroise bridge in Brest, western France, on Jan. 24, 2024, as they protest against taxation and falling incomes. France's powerful agricultural unions met with the French prime minister on Jan. 22, after threatening the government with a week or more of protest action if their demands were not met. (Fred TANNEAU/AFP)
Farmers block the Iroise bridge in Brest, western France, on Jan. 24, 2024, as they protest against taxation and falling incomes. France's powerful agricultural unions met with the French prime minister on Jan. 22, after threatening the government with a week or more of protest action if their demands were not met. (Fred TANNEAU/AFP)

However, Mr. Darmanin said it’s a real possibility that all eight highways heading to Paris will be blocked, urging car and truck drivers to anticipate blockades in the coming days.

France’s gendarmes have been deployed with armored vehicles. Unlike the police, a civilian law enforcement agency, gendarmes are a military force with law enforcement duties that fulfill defense missions. Mr. Darmanin claims the mobilized troops have been told to act with “moderation” and not to attack any roadblocks unless they risk public safety.

Prime Minister’s Efforts to Appease Farmers Falls Flat

French Prime Minister Gabriel Attal (front row C), French Agriculture and Food Sovereignty Minister Marc Fesneau (C-L) and French Minister for Ecological Transition and Territories' Cohesion Christophe Bechu (C-R) listen to a farmer during a visit in a farm in Montastruc-de-Salies, southwestern France on Jan. 26, 2024, as several farmers unions called for a nationwide day of protests and Attal is expected to make announcements to respond to their demands on pay, tax and regulations. (Miguel MEDINA/AFP)
French Prime Minister Gabriel Attal (front row C), French Agriculture and Food Sovereignty Minister Marc Fesneau (C-L) and French Minister for Ecological Transition and Territories' Cohesion Christophe Bechu (C-R) listen to a farmer during a visit in a farm in Montastruc-de-Salies, southwestern France on Jan. 26, 2024, as several farmers unions called for a nationwide day of protests and Attal is expected to make announcements to respond to their demands on pay, tax and regulations. (Miguel MEDINA/AFP)
Newly-crowned French Prime Minister Gabriel Attal recently announced several measures to halt the protests, which fell flat with farmers. During a visit to a farm in the west of the country over the weekend, he acknowledged his first raft of measures last week were inadequate. He promised “other decisions” to be made in the coming weeks to address farmers’ concerns.

“I want us to clarify things and see what extra measures we can take to meet farmers’ complaints that they face unfair competition,” he said.

“I am determined to move forward, move forward resolutely, move forward quickly.”

Previously, Mr. Attal said the scheme to phase out state support on diesel would be scrapped and red tape simplified. He planned to apply for a waiver with the European Union on bloc-wide rules on fallow land as well.

President of the CR47 union (Coordination rurale 47) Jose Perez (L) and vice-president of the CR47 Karine Duc listen to the broadcast press conference of the French Prime minister after their action outside the prefecture in Agen, southwestern France, on Jan. 26, 2024. France's top farmers' union on Jan. 26 began blockading major routes into Paris, upping the pressure on the government to respond to their demands on pay, tax and regulations. Facing his first major crisis, Prime Minister Gabriel Attal was expected to offer concessions as ministers scramble to keep discontent from spreading months ahead of European Parliament elections. (Christophe ARCHAMBAULT/AFP)
President of the CR47 union (Coordination rurale 47) Jose Perez (L) and vice-president of the CR47 Karine Duc listen to the broadcast press conference of the French Prime minister after their action outside the prefecture in Agen, southwestern France, on Jan. 26, 2024. France's top farmers' union on Jan. 26 began blockading major routes into Paris, upping the pressure on the government to respond to their demands on pay, tax and regulations. Facing his first major crisis, Prime Minister Gabriel Attal was expected to offer concessions as ministers scramble to keep discontent from spreading months ahead of European Parliament elections. (Christophe ARCHAMBAULT/AFP)

Mr. Attal also announced that France would remain opposed to signing the Mercosur free-trade deal, which farmers say will flood the country with cheaper Latin American meat and produce.

Opposition leader Marine Le Pen of the National Rally said in comments to local media that the farmers were protesting the policies of “Macron’s Europe” and the Members of Parliament who voted for “all of the free trade agreements,” adding they were now seeing the challenges posed to farmers fighting against unfair competition.

A tractor bears a placard which reads "Macron, answer! #saveyoufarmer" a protesting farmers blockade the A10 autoroute during a protest against taxation and declining income, near the Peage de Saint-Arnoult-en-Yvelines toll gates southwest of Paris, on Jan. 26, 2024, as part of a nationwide day of protests called by several farmers unions on pay, tax and regulations. (Dimitar DILKOFF/AFP)
A tractor bears a placard which reads "Macron, answer! #saveyoufarmer" a protesting farmers blockade the A10 autoroute during a protest against taxation and declining income, near the Peage de Saint-Arnoult-en-Yvelines toll gates southwest of Paris, on Jan. 26, 2024, as part of a nationwide day of protests called by several farmers unions on pay, tax and regulations. (Dimitar DILKOFF/AFP)
An aerial view shows tractors positioned to read "STOP !" during a farmers' protest over a number of issues affecting their sector, in Maille, central France, on Jan. 23, 2024. (GUILLAUME SOUVANT/AFP)
An aerial view shows tractors positioned to read "STOP !" during a farmers' protest over a number of issues affecting their sector, in Maille, central France, on Jan. 23, 2024. (GUILLAUME SOUVANT/AFP)

Some farmers were happy with the proposals but many more were not. FNSEA and the Jeunes Agriculteurs said that the protests would continue because the government’s plan didn’t go far enough to address other issues like “water management,” “economic viability,” and “anxiety” among farmers.

“Gabriel Attal responded to 1 percent of the problem, since he lifted one barrier out of 100,” said Sébastien Chenu, vice president of the National Rally.

FNSEA President Arnaud Rousseau said Mr. Attal’s announcements have “not calmed the anger, we need to go further.”

Meanwhile, the general secretary of the Pas-de-Calais FDSEA branch, Lucie Delbarre, said the situation is at a delicate stage and could explode at any minute.

“We have a government that doesn’t care about its farmers; as you can see, it’s a pressure cooker ready to explode,” Ms. Delbarre said.

A banner reads "We support the agricultural movement" as farmers block the A64 highway in protest against taxation and declining income, near Carbonne, south of Toulouse, on Jan. 22, 2024. Since January 18, 2024, farmers have been blocking the A64 motorway in Carbonne near Toulouse. In France, as elsewhere in Europe, there has been an increasing number of farmers' demonstrations in recent weeks. (Valentine CHAPUIS/AFP)
A banner reads "We support the agricultural movement" as farmers block the A64 highway in protest against taxation and declining income, near Carbonne, south of Toulouse, on Jan. 22, 2024. Since January 18, 2024, farmers have been blocking the A64 motorway in Carbonne near Toulouse. In France, as elsewhere in Europe, there has been an increasing number of farmers' demonstrations in recent weeks. (Valentine CHAPUIS/AFP)
A slogan which reads "Hunger will be our fate" is displayed on a tractor as farmers block the entrance of a Leclerc supermarket in Le Mans, northwestern France, on Jan. 26, 2024, as part of a nationwide day of protests called by several farmers unions on pay, tax and regulations. Farmers have fumed at what they say is a squeeze on purchase prices for produce by supermarket and industrial buyers, as well as complex environmental regulations. (GUILLAUME SOUVANT/AFP)
A slogan which reads "Hunger will be our fate" is displayed on a tractor as farmers block the entrance of a Leclerc supermarket in Le Mans, northwestern France, on Jan. 26, 2024, as part of a nationwide day of protests called by several farmers unions on pay, tax and regulations. Farmers have fumed at what they say is a squeeze on purchase prices for produce by supermarket and industrial buyers, as well as complex environmental regulations. (GUILLAUME SOUVANT/AFP)

France isn’t the only country in the grips of civil unrest at the moment over globalist policies biting into local farmers’ hip pockets. In recent weeks, protests have been spreading across agricultural heartlands in the European Union. Farmers in Germany, the Netherlands, Poland, Belgium, and Romania have all staged protests as well.

All are voicing similar concerns to their French counterparts, such as restrictive environmental regulations and increases in taxes on diesel fuel, which they rely on to run their equipment.