Feds Say Online News Act Could Bring In Over $200M a Year From Tech Giants

Feds Say Online News Act Could Bring In Over $200M a Year From Tech Giants
The logos of mobile apps Facebook and Google on a smartphone on Dec. 9, 2020. (The Epoch Times)
Matthew Horwood
9/1/2023
Updated:
9/1/2023
0:00

The Department of Heritage has announced proposed regulations to implement the Online News Act, which include estimates that the legislation could raise $172 million per year from Google and $60 million from Facebook.

“Those are estimates based on publicly available information and obviously the regulatory process is designed to be able to discuss this and consult with affected parties more openly and adjust the formula as needed,” a senior official from Heritage Canada said during a technical briefing on Sept 1.

“But the formula has been designed to be consistent with the modelling that the government department is throughout the Parliamentary process.”

Bill C-18 has become a controversial piece of legislation since its passage resulted in Canadians losing access to news links on Facebook and Instagram. Google has also threatened to remove links to Canadian news from its “Search, News, and Discover products,” after claiming that Bill C-18 remained “unworkable” and that Ottawa had failed to give assurances that the regulatory process could resolve structural issues in its legislation.
The Online News Act (Bill C-18), which received royal assent on June 22, mandates that tech companies pay Canadian media outlets for news content linked on their platforms. The legislation would also give the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) the power to require media organizations to follow a “code of ethics” in order to be eligible for news-sharing negotiations with digital platforms.
In a statement on Sept. 1, Heritage Minister Pascale St-Onge said tech platforms had to “act responsibly and support the news sharing they and Canadians both benefit from.”

“The Online News Act requires these dominant platforms to bargain fairly with news businesses—both big and small. The consultation on the proposed regulations today helps to provide clarity for platforms and news organizations while opening a dialogue toward real results,” she said.

During the briefing, the Heritage Canada official said the bill would apply to platforms that meet three criteria: they must earn a total global yearly revenue of $1 billion or more and operate in the search engine or social media market “involving the distribution and access of online use content in Canada.” They must also have 20 million or more Canadian average monthly unique visitors or average monthly active users.

After a platform determines that the act applies to them, they must notify the CRTC within 30 days.

The official added that the compensation provided by tech giants could also include non-monetary contributions such as training or advertising inventory.

“These are some of the things that the platforms indicated are part of their relationships with these businesses. As noted it will be necessary to put a dollar amount on those, and obviously both parties negotiating the agreement will need to be in agreement with that,” the official said.

Beginning on Sept. 2, the regulations and accompanying Regulatory Impact Analysis Statement will be published in the Canada Gazette, Part I for a 30-day public consultation period involving businesses, academics, and all Canadians. Following that consultation, the final regulations will be published in the Canada Gazette, and the CRTC will be bound by them after further finalization.

‘Viable Framework’

When asked by reporters what would happen if a tech giant decided not to negotiate with news outlets, the Heritage Canada official said a news business could come forward and seek mandatory bargaining from the platform.

“As we have seen, there is a question of whether platforms remove themselves entirely from the digital news marketplace to avoid being subjected to the act,” he said.

“The government remains focused through this regulatory process on putting forward what it sees as a reasonable, viable framework for digital news intermediaries for platforms to come to the table and bargain fairly with us.”

Shortly after the briefing, a spokesperson from Meta said Canada’s proposed regulations would not impact its decision to end news availability in Canada.
The Canadian Press contributed to this report.