Doctor Quits UBC After 30 Years Over Concerns of Anti-Semitism

Doctor Quits UBC After 30 Years Over Concerns of Anti-Semitism
The UBC sign displayed at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver in a file photo. (The Canadian Press/Jonathan Hayward)
Chandra Philip
1/4/2024
Updated:
1/5/2024

A physician with the University of British Columbia (UBC) Faculty of Medicine has quit, saying the school is not doing enough to deal with anti-Semitism on campus.

“I didn’t do it lightly,” Dr. Ted Rosenberg told The Epoch Times. “It was done with a very heavy heart. But I felt like I had no choice.”

Dr. Rosenberg is a Victoria-based geriatrician who has been a clinical professor at UBC for 30 years.

He said he raised the issue with the school that anti-Semitism is not included as part of UBC’s diversity and inclusivity policies, but was told he should file a human rights complaint.

“It’s been basically ignored. And just saying deal with it the way you would deal with any other human rights complaint,” Dr. Rosenberg said.

UBC’s medical school emailed a statement to The Epoch Times that said “antisemitism, or discrimination of any kind, is completely unacceptable.”

“We are committed to creating a safe and respectful environment for all of our community members and will continue to take steps to do so,” it added, noting that UBC’s discrimination policy includes provisions against discrimination based on religion, race, and place of origin.
The statement also pointed to a Nov. 6, 2023, message from UBC President Benoit-Antoine Bacon and a Dec. 19 statement from Faculty of Medicine Dean Dermot Kelleher, both addressing the need to be respectful to others on campus and to work to foster inclusion and dignity.

However, Dr. Rosenberg said the school did not identify the Jewish community directly in its policies.

“There are some unique nuances related to anti-Semitism that need to be addressed. And it needs to be recognized by the university because they’re not recognized in any of their programs.”

Petition

In his Jan. 1 resignation letter addressed to Dr. Kelleher, Dr. Rosenberg said he was concerned about the lack of recognition of anti-Semitism.

“I checked the recommended links to your and the President’s statements on respect and compassion, as well as the EDI site,” he wrote.

“Two words are conspicuously absent from all these documents: 1. Jew(ish) and 2. Antisemitism. Moreover, I searched the UBC DEI/REDI site for the words ‘antisemitism’ and did not find this word, amongst the multitude of other ‘anti’s’ that appeared.”

Dr. Rosenberg said he raised the issue in a letter to Mr. Bacon, Dr. Kelleher, and other senior UBC officials at the end of November but was dissatisfied with the response. On Dec. 21, nearly 300 other doctors at UBC wrote a joint letter to the dean about the issue.

“A group of the Jewish doctors and other doctors at UBC … 284 signed a letter to the dean requesting that he acknowledged that anti-Semitism is an issue, come up with guardrails, like the IHRA [International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance] guardrail for dealing with anti-Semitism, and more clearly define what hate speech is, to give guidance for that, and then to develop some workshops to improve education,” Dr. Rosenberg explained.

The doctors’ letter raised concerns about a petition they said was signed by some 225 medical students, titled “A Call to Action on Gaza.”

The petition called for a ceasefire while also condemning Israel. It accused Israel of “indiscriminate bombing of civilians” and said “Palestinian people have been continually abused, traumatized, and killed by the settler state of Israel and its Western allies for over 75 years,” reported the Canadian Jewish News.

The doctors wrote in their joint letter: “We question the validity of such a petition existing at all, because the petition contains many inaccuracies, is one-sided, is unrelated to medical care, and is causing deep divisions within the medical student community.”

“We urgently request that you respond to this petition by taking action to protect the integrity of the medical school and the safety of medical students and staff,” it added.

Resignation

Dr. Rosenberg said that, “basically, again, we got a very suboptimal response.”

It was then that he decided to resign.

In his resignation letter, he said “one third of the medical students and some faculty, have publicly expressed their contempt towards me, as a Jew. I cannot take the risk of being accused of implicit harassment or racism, which is indefensible, by a ‘triggered’ student.”

“Unfortunately, I have no faith in due process in a faculty that does not even acknowledge the existence or presence of antisemitism/Jew-hatred, or my right to work in a depoliticized environment,” he wrote.

UBC’s email to The Epoch Times said the Faculty of Medicine plans to offer opportunities to learn inclusivity and respectfulness.

“In response to concerns raised by faculty and learners, the Faculty of Medicine is also working expediently to develop educational opportunities for inclusive learning and respectful dialogue within the faculty in areas that directly reflect our stated values, including how we address issues such as discrimination, harassment, and hate speech,” the email said.

Dr. Rosenberg said his resignation is effective Jan. 2.

“It deeply saddens me to end my academic career on this note,” he wrote to the dean.

‘We’ve Got a Problem’

Dr. Rosenberg said he is concerned about the amount of violence and aggression he has been seeing.

“There’s nothing wrong with legitimate protest or legitimate advocacy. But when the protest turns into aggressive protests that are demonizing people here in town, recommending boycotts and isolation and marginalization, we’ve got a problem.”

He said the problem is in society and universities.

“My concern was that UBC, up until now, has done nothing, and it’s created this toxic environment—or at least has not created a toxic environment, is tolerating the toxic environment.”

According to the Department of Canadian Heritage, Canada is home to the fourth-largest Jewish community in the world.