Central Bank Governor Admits Errors Were Made Fighting Inflation

Central Bank Governor Admits Errors Were Made Fighting Inflation
Bank of Canada governor Tiff Macklem speaks during a news conference following an interest rate announcement, in Ottawa on Oct. 25, 2023. (The Canadian Press/Adrian Wyld)
William Crooks
2/21/2024
Updated:
2/21/2024
0:00

Mistakes were made fighting recent inflation, Bank of Canada Governor Tiff Macklem has detailed in a new essay.

Mr. Macklem said he and his team underestimated the inflationary risk from the mix of supply shocks and high consumer demand during the COVID-19 pandemic.

He also said that the bank’s models were not accurately adjusted to gauge price pressures across the economy, and officials did not pay enough attention to the potential sharp increase in inflation.

“We need to be humble, when humility is due,” Mr. Macklem wrote in the essay in “Monetary Policy Responses to the Post-Pandemic Inflation” published by the Centre for Economic Policy Research.

“This means explaining our forecast errors, and their implications, openly and clearly. Being open is always important, but it is especially crucial in uncertain times—and as we work to bring inflation back to our 2 percent target.”

Mr. Macklem cites circumstances surrounding COVID-19 as the ultimate cause of “pronounced” supply shocks.

“Post-pandemic, the inflation response was different,” he wrote, “we were faced with a series of negative supply shocks just as the economy was reopening, and the effects of these supply shocks on prices and inflation were faster and more pronounced than usual.”

This, coupled with heightened consumer demand during the pandemic, led to an underestimation of inflationary risks, Mr. Macklem wrote.

He attributed the underestimation to Central Bank modelling flaws which did not take into account periods of “excessive demand.”

Besides poor modelling, Mr. Macklem acknowledged the inadequate timing of rate hikes due to the misjudgment of inflationary pressures that they considered, at the time, to be “transitory.”

Mr. Macklem’s essay is a part of widespread effort by central banking heads across the West to come to terms with the past years’ inflation woes and aim for better future responses.

Inflation has caused food and shelter prices to rise sharply in recent years, putting pressure on Canadians’ pocketbooks. Though food price inflation is receding from a high of 11.4 percent in January 2023, it still remains at 3.4 percent as of January 2024, according to a Statistics Canada report released Feb. 20. A StatCan annual review in January showed shelter prices rose 5.6 percent in 2023.
The Consumer Price Index (CPI), which measures overall inflation, rose 2.9 percent on a year-over-year basis in January, declining from 3.4 percent in December, according to a Feb. 20 StatCan release.

‘Deficit Spending’

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre has criticized the Bank of Canada for its monetary policy in response to the pandemic and has pledged to fire Mr. Macklem if he becomes prime minister. Mr. Poilievre has also blamed rising inflation primarily on government spending, as well as Liberal policies such as the carbon tax.
He pointed the finger at the Liberals’ spending as the chief reason for high inflation during his Jan. 28 speech to caucus.

“After eight years of Justin Trudeau, everything costs more with the worst inflation in 40 years,” he said. “After eight years of Justin Trudeau promising debt was consequence-free because interest rates were low, they’ve shot up in the fastest relative terms in Canadian history and they are a direct result of his deficit spending.”

Mr. Poilievre has promised to “cap government spending and cut government waste” to balance the budget and bring down inflation rates if his party forms the next government.

Economist Franco Terrazzano also blamed government spending for inflation in a 2023 article for the Canadian Taxpayer’s Federation.
“There are many factors that cause inflation,” he wrote. “But Ottawa’s never-ending deficits, tax hikes and money printing helped push inflation to a 40-year high. Without this inflation, the Bank of Canada would have little reason to raise rates, and Canadians wouldn’t be worried about their mortgage payments going through the roof.”
Jennifer Cowan contributed to this report.