Authoritarian Regimes Will Start ‘Copying’ China’s Overseas Police Stations, MPs Hear

A building in a business park in Markham, Ont., is seen on Oct. 31, 2022, one of three locations in the Greater Toronto Area identified by Spain-based human rights group Safeguard Defenders as being among the sites of at least 54 unofficial police stations allegedly run by police bureaus in China. (The Canadian Press/Cole Burston)

Beijing’s operation of over 100 overseas police stations worldwide—with some allegedly used for transnational repression—has inspired other authoritarian regimes to “copy” such efforts, MPs on the House Canada-China committee heard on March 20.

Expert witness Laura Harth, campaign director for human rights NGO Safeguard Defenders, was asked by Liberal MP Peter Fragiskatos at the committee meeting if China was the only country to have established clandestine police service centres abroad. In response, she said while no other authoritarian countries have yet done so, they are starting to learn from China’s experience.

“Transnational repression is definitely being used by all authoritarian regimes and to a growing extent, which is another reason why we believe it’s so important to be very clear that this will not be accepted, because we do see countries learning from each other. Also, smaller authoritarian countries are starting to learn from those efforts and copying,” she said at the committee meeting.

“The scale on which the Chinese Communist Party is operating these [overseas police service centres] is unparalleled.”

In two reports published in September and December 2022, Safeguard Defenders identified a total of 102 unofficial Chinese police service centres operating in 53 countries, based on open-source online information from Chinese authorities or state media. Among them, five of those stations have listed addresses in Canada, three in the Greater Toronto Area, and two in the Metro Vancouver area.

The RCMP previously announced that four of those police stations—three in the GTA and one in Vancouver—have ceased operation. The Epoch Times previously inquired about whether the RCMP is also looking into the fifth location in B.C. but didn’t hear back.

The RCMP has recently announced an investigation into two other Chinese police stations in Quebec’s Brossard and Montreal areas, saying it’s received at least 15 serious tips in relation to those two locations.

Safeguard Defenders previously said its reports have prompted 14 countries to launch investigations into the alleged Chinese police service stations within their jurisdictions.

“There have been some more countries that have announced investigations, not all of them are very open on the extent to which they are doing that,” Harth told MPs.

The Sino-Quebec Center in Brossard, Quebec, is seen on March 9, 2023. RCMP said it's investigating this location, along with the Chinese Family Service of Greater Montreal, which are allegedly clandestine overseas Chinese police service stations. (Noé Chartier/The Epoch Times)

Harth noted that Beijing’s interference in Canada has long been documented, but warnings from dissidents and rights groups have gone unaddressed by authorities, leading to increasingly “brazen violations of national sovereignty” by Beijing.

“I think Canada—as any other democracy in the world—has for too long a time closed its eyes to everything that’s going on, maybe hoping it would go away if we just didn’t look at it,” she said. “That has obviously only allowed these operations to grow, putting us today at increased risk.”

However, she noted that the police and public responses to the news of Chinese police stations in Canada “are among the best that we’ve seen in the world.”

“It’s painful, it’s going to be hard getting through this, but it’s important that this [interference] is out in the public and that the society can take stock of everything that’s going on because awareness is the first step to actually addressing the issue,” Harth said.