“Affirmative action is the systemic racism that’s still here in America today,” Vivek Ramaswamy says. “And I’m sorry to say, it will then create the new kind of anti-black racism that we had spent so many decades moving on from.”
In this recent episode of “American Thought Leaders,” host Jan Jekielek sat down with entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy, author of the 2021 bestseller “Woke, Inc.: Inside Corporate America’s Social Justice Scam.” The two men also discussed Ramaswamy’s new book, “Nation of Victims,” which looks at America’s grievance culture—on both the left and the right—and how Americans have lost a sense of identity and purpose. This, Ramaswamy says, has paved the way for the politicization of business and the rise of “woke” capitalism.
But when we impose these top-down political and social agendas on those businesses, they’re less good at making the widgets that people buy from them, which in turn creates less valuable businesses and a less prosperous society. This isn’t just a threat to capitalism, it’s also a threat to democracy.
In a democratic society, citizens are supposed to settle political differences through free speech and open debate, where everyone’s voice and vote count equally. When we delegate the authority to make those political decisions, whether and how to fight climate change or systemic racism, for example, what we’re really saying is that business elites in corporate boardrooms get to make those decisions, which sucks the air and the lifeblood out of a democracy.
In “Woke, Inc.,” I look at the merger between government and private enterprise, doing together what neither could do on its own. I even trace the ways government is using private companies to do through the back door what government couldn’t do through the front door and the Constitution. At the same time, the question I ask in the second book is, “What is it about our culture and our national psyche that creates an entire generation that’s buying up this nonsense?”
The kinds of things that used to fulfill that purpose, such as patriotism, hard work, family, and faith, have slowly receded from modern life. That leaves a black hole of identity in its wake, which allows wokeism to find its home in the heart of the American soul.
We need to fill that identity vacuum with something based on the shared pursuit of excellence as part of what it means to be American. But the path getting from A to B is a complicated one, running through some uncomfortable terrain.
Not everyone is going to reach the finish line at the same time. Not everyone is even going to get to the same finish line, whether that’s on the basketball court, in the classroom, or in the system of free-market capitalism. We’re not going to have a system where everyone wins and loses equally if we have a true culture of excellence. They don’t go together.
Go upstream and fix those problems instead of using this cosmetic band-aid on the back end of the process. Because if affirmative action worked, then you wouldn’t have the same racial minority groups needing it to get into boarding school or college, the exact same racial minority groups that then need it to get into graduate school or the workforce.
I was at Harvard for college. I was at Yale Law School. I saw it firsthand. The same groups require the same affirmative action programs every time, which is a good sign that it’s not working. It’s also a disservice to qualified members of those minority groups who get positions because of merit. They’re going to be judged in an unfair way by their non-favored peers.
It’s a form of anti-white and anti-Asian racism. One of the things that I talk about in “Nation of Victims” is the last rigorous study conducted on this. Thomas Espenshade found that when you looked at 10 elite colleges, there was a more than 400-point gap between SAT scores that an average Asian applicant would have to score versus the average black applicant.
Now, nobody talks about affirmative action for the NBA, but if you were to apply this, it would be the equivalent of asking someone who’s black to make a half-court shot, but someone who’s Asian gets a stair step right up to the hoop for a slam dunk.
We shouldn’t think it’s any different in science or engineering classrooms. It’s an assault on merit and excellence, and an assault on merit and excellence is an assault on the American soul. Part of what it means to be American is to be able to pursue excellence unapologetically.
Affirmative action, I can confidently say, is the single greatest form of institutionalized racism in the United States today. It’s anti-white, anti-Asian racism, which then creates a backlash wave of new anti-black racism among the people who were penalized by it.
You get on an airplane, and you see a black pilot and you wonder if you’re in the hands of a slightly less qualified pilot because an affirmative action mandate to achieve racial equality eliminated testing requirements. That’s no one’s fault other than the people who created the system that makes such inferences possible. That’s what I call true systemic racism. Affirmative action is the systemic racism that’s still here in America today. And I’m sorry to say that it will then create this new kind of anti-black racism that we had spent so many decades moving on from.
Think about student loan forgiveness as an example. That’s recently in the news. Somebody who borrowed money to buy a truck and build a career as a trucker didn’t get their loans forgiven for buying that truck, even though somebody who went to Bryn Mawr College did for being a humanities major. People like the trucker are left holding the bag. Such justified reasons for victimhood and frustration resulted in the election of Trump in 2016.
Now go to the left-leaning version of this conversation. Take the war on drugs. Everyone has talked about this stuff ad nauseam, but there’s a difference in arrest rates for crack cocaine versus non-crack cocaine. One is more disproportionate and prevalent in the black community. They’ll say, “You blame us for having unstable family structures. Well, you’re the guys who took the father figures and put them in jail.”
This black victimhood epidemic is now creating an epidemic of white victimhood culture in our country. Second-generation Asian kids are trying to describe themselves as persons of color, inventing hardships for themselves that they didn’t go through but that their parents or their grandparents had in coming to this country.
We have this victimhood metastasis where everyone wants to think of themselves as a victim. At some point, we must recognize that there’s no winner in America’s oppression Olympics. If there is a gold medalist, maybe it’s China because of our assault on merit. It’s America that loses in the end.
We have to get past this grievance tug of war to forget about victimhood and reclaim excellence. That’s what we need to revive in our culture.
Friends Read Free