Plaintiffs in a high-profile case that's uncovered evidence of collusion between Big Tech and government officials to censor users are seeking to depose 10 top officials, including Dr. Anthony Fauci.
While emails and other documents uncovered in discovery have revealed an "enormous and far-reaching" censorship enterprise, the discovery "makes very clear that federal officials have frequently engaged in their most telling and probative communications with social media companies orally, not in writing," plaintiffs said in a joint statement with defendants.
"Perhaps not surprisingly, the more senior the federal official involved, the more likely they appear to have been to rely on oral, rather than written, communications to pressure social-media platforms to censor," the statement also said.
Fauci was also in touch with Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, although the content of oral communications between the two "is yet to be revealed," the new filing, dated Oct. 14, says.
Fauci hasn't made any statements under oath about his communications with big tech firms such as Facebook, despite that the judge overseeing the case ordered the government to provide answers from Fauci to questions, plaintiffs said.
Proposed SchedulePlaintiffs want U.S. District Judge Terry Doughty, a Trump appointee overseeing the case, to greenlight the 10 requested depositions. If Doughty agrees, the depositions would take place during a 30-day window.
In that order, Doughty said plaintiffs could alert defendants to any depositions plaintiffs wished to take, and that the parties would then meet to confer on any deposition requests.
If the parties didn't agree on the depositions, a joint statement would be submitted to outline their differences.
Doughty has seven days to rule on the new filing, which included objections from the government.
Department of Justice lawyers said that plaintiffs usually take no more than 10 depositions during normal discovery, and taking that many during expedited discovery would be too burdensome.
"Although a plaintiff is rarely entitled to expedited discovery, Plaintiffs here have received a substantial amount. Defendants produced more than 15,000 pages of non-privileged responsive e-mails, and they answered numerous interrogatories. Plaintiffs cannot demonstrate that still more discovery—particularly burdensome depositions—is warranted at this stage of the case," they said.
If any depositions are authorized, Doughty should exclude officials who weren't originally served with discovery requests, high-ranking officials, and certain other officials, the government lawyers said.
Plaintiffs said the arguments in opposition are meritless and should be rejected.
The descriptions of some officials as too "high-level" to be deposed is outweighed by the officials all having firsthand knowledge of the matter and the information they hold can't be obtained elsewhere, plaintiffs said, referring to a ruling in a separate case, United States v. Newman.
10 OthersPlaintiffs originally wanted to depose 20 current and former officials, but after discussions, pared their request to 10.
The initial request had included Eric Waldo, senior adviser to Murthy; Max Lesko, chief of staff at the Office of the Surgeon General; Jay Dempsey, a CDC social media team lead; Robert Silvers, a Department of Homeland Security official; Matthew Masterson, a former senior adviser at the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA); and Nina Jankowicz, former head of the shuttered Disinformation Governance Board.
Also included were Jennifer Shopkorn, a Census Bureau director; Zachary Henry Schwartz, a senior adviser to the secretary of commerce's chief of staff; Samaruddin Stewart, a former adviser for the State Department's Global Engagement Center; and Laura Dehmlow, a top FBI official.
Plaintiffs still want to depose four others in addition to Fauci, Chan, Psaki, Murthy, Flaherty, and Crawford.
They are CISA Director Jen Easterly; Lauren Protentis, an official at the security agency; Andrew Slavitt, a former White House COVID-19 adviser; and Daniel Kimmage, acting coordinator for the State Department's Global Engagement Center.