The Epoch Times
The Epoch Times
AD
The Epoch Times
Support Us
SHARE
USUS News

Conservatives Say Christian Nationalism Used by the Left to Paint Them as Extremists and ‘White Supremacists’

Commentator and author says it provides a club with which to bludgeon the Right.
Copy
Facebook
X
Truth
Gettr
LinkedIn
Telegram
Email
Save
Conservatives Say Christian Nationalism Used by the Left to Paint Them as Extremists and ‘White Supremacists’
Crowds of people gather as U.S. President Donald Trump speaks to supporters from The Ellipse near the White House on Jan. 6, 2021. Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images
Darlene McCormick Sanchez
By Darlene McCormick Sanchez
9/28/2023Updated: 9/28/2023
0:00

Christian nationalism is being portrayed as a right-wing boogeyman by left-wing pundits in an attempt to tie Christianity and conservatism to violence and racism, according to conservatives.

Anti-Christian rhetoric has increased in mainstream media outlets based on the perceived threat of Christian nationalism, a manufactured term from the Left used against conservatives, according to Carol Swain, a commentator on politics and author of several books such as “Be the People: A Call to Reclaim America’s Faith and Promise.”

“[Christian nationalism] was an invention and word game by the Left to keep Christians out of politics,” Ms. Swain told The Epoch Times.

Conservative commentator James Lindsay, author of numerous books including “Race Marxism,” told The Epoch Times he believes Christian nationalism has many different meanings because he suspects its purpose is to lay a trap for conservatives.

“The federal government is trying to weaponize the term,” Mr. Lindsay said.

On Sept. 22, the Texas Tribune news outlet, once a New York Times partner, hosted a discussion in Austin titled “God and Country, the pernicious rise of Christian nationalism.”

Related Stories
IN-DEPTH: Christians Say Government Targets Them Because They Oppose Left-Wing Agenda
4/25/2023
IN-DEPTH: Christians Say Government Targets Them Because They Oppose Left-Wing Agenda
Biden Speech the Latest Example of anti-Christian Discrimination in US: National Religious Broadcasters
9/19/2022
Biden Speech the Latest Example of anti-Christian Discrimination in US: National Religious Broadcasters

The panel discussion was part of the Texas Tribune Festival lineup of journalists, newsmakers, and political speakers over three days.

The Tribune’s moderator defined Christian nationalism as the idea that the United States was a God-ordained country founded on Christian traditions and institutions, and laws should favor and reflect Christian values.

Pastor Paula White-Cain delivers the invocation at the inauguration of Donald Trump as the 45th president at the U.S. Capitol in Washington on Jan. 20, 2017. (Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
Pastor Paula White-Cain delivers the invocation at the inauguration of Donald Trump as the 45th president at the U.S. Capitol in Washington on Jan. 20, 2017. Joe Raedle/Getty Images

That definition could describe many Christians who are also patriots but who would never identify as violent, racist, or against democracy. And that is part of the trap, Mr. Lindsay said.

Others have described Christian nationalism as allowing one theological view to be reflected in law and policy, and merging church and state instead of keeping them separate.

The Texas panelists described Christian nationalism’s connection to the Jan. 6 Capitol “insurrection” and “white supremacy.”

The panel’s characterization of Christian nationalism fits a pattern that developed in 2022 when several news organizations published stories that used it to portray Christians as far-right extremists and bigots.

Time, a news publication, published an article that year under the banner: “Jan. 6 May Have Been Only the First Wave of Christian Nationalist Violence.“

The Time article stated: “We are forgetting that Jan. 6 was very much a religious event—white Christian nationalism on display. We must remember that fact. Because evidence is mounting that white Christian nationalism could provide the theological cover for more events like it.”

Likewise, ABC News published: “’Christian Nationalism' Threatens Democracy, Some Experts Say,“ and interviewed ”experts“ who said there were ”links between Christian nationalism and far-right groups or movements.”
Texas Tribune reporter and moderator Robert Downen (L) poses questions to panelists Amanda Tyler (2nd L), executive director of the Baptist Joint Commission in Washington, Bart Barber (C), president of the Southern Baptist Convention, and Anthea Butler (R), who chairs the religious studies department at the University of Pennsylvania, on Christian nationalism in Austin, Texas, on Sept. 22, 2023. (Darlene McCormick Sanchez/The Epoch Times) <span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>
Texas Tribune reporter and moderator Robert Downen (L) poses questions to panelists Amanda Tyler (2nd L), executive director of the Baptist Joint Commission in Washington, Bart Barber (C), president of the Southern Baptist Convention, and Anthea Butler (R), who chairs the religious studies department at the University of Pennsylvania, on Christian nationalism in Austin, Texas, on Sept. 22, 2023. (Darlene McCormick Sanchez/The Epoch Times)  
Salon magazine article headlined “How Christian Nationalism Drove the Insurrection: A Religious History of Jan. 6“ cited Christian speeches and symbols during the Jan. 6 riots and stated that ”no matter how explicit—and violent—the religious rhetoric swirling around ‘Stop the Steal’ was, it was little recognized before the Jan. 6 attack.”

Anthea Butler, who chairs the religious studies department at the University of Pennsylvania, told Salon that Christianity in politics “hasn’t just been this alliance of how to get people elected, but has had this element of things that have fed upon each other to create a monster that threatens democracy.”

Ms. Butler appeared with Amanda Tyler, executive director of the Baptist Joint Commission in Washington, on the Texas panel.

Both women contributed to the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty and the Freedom From Religion Foundation report on the link between Christian nationalism and the Jan. 6 Capitol breach.

Comments in the mainstream media led Mr. Lindsay to believe Christian nationalism is providing the Left with a club to bludgeon those on the Right.

This July, speakers at a Florida conference “With Liberty and Justice for All” held at Countryside Baptist Church in Clearwater, Florida, cautioned that Christian nationalism could be a trojan horse for a global theocracy or even a false flag operation.

President Donald Trump (C) hosts a dinner celebrating evangelical leadership in the State Dining Room of the White House in Washington on Aug. 27, 2018. (Samira Bouaou/The Epoch Times)
President Donald Trump (C) hosts a dinner celebrating evangelical leadership in the State Dining Room of the White House in Washington on Aug. 27, 2018. Samira Bouaou/The Epoch Times

The fuzzy nature of even defining Christian nationalism makes it likely to be used as a trap for conservatives, said Mr. Lindsay, who also spoke at the event.

During his Florida speech, Mr. Lindsay said the Left will “weaponize” Christian nationalism to target conservatives.

“So just to remind you, political warfare means using political means to get your opponent to do what you want with hostile intent,” Mr. Lindsay said.

“Federal agents or leftists posing as Christians” could carry out a false flag operation by “whipping up the Christian nationalist movement to make them do something stupid,” he said.

During the Texas discussion, panelists connected Christian nationalism with Jan. 6.

“This kind of Christian nationalism that is being put forth now is in the area of violence, taking America back by force, talking about people being demons,” Ms. Butler said.

“A lot of the imagery was Christian imagery” during Jan. 6, she added.

A protester in an American War of Independence uniform at the E. Barrett Prettyman federal courthouse after former President Donald Trump was arraigned on Jan. 6 charges in Washington on Aug. 3, 2023. (Madalina Vasiliu/The Epoch Times)
A protester in an American War of Independence uniform at the E. Barrett Prettyman federal courthouse after former President Donald Trump was arraigned on Jan. 6 charges in Washington on Aug. 3, 2023. Madalina Vasiliu/The Epoch Times

Ms. Tyler said understanding Christian nationalism was key to understanding the Capitol breach.

“I think we have to talk about Christian nationalism and white Christian nationalism in the sense that Christian nationalism does provide cover for white supremacy and racial subjugation. It uses the gospel as respectability, for the racism, for the exclusion,” she said.

She said those who showed up on Jan. 6 thought they were “following God’s direction to save democracy by uniting all these disparate actors who were there from all different kinds of groups and conspiracy theories and hate groups.”

“And we can look right here in the state of Texas, at the God and country worship services that happened at First Baptist Dallas, as an example of Christian nationalist worship that’s happening in a place of worship,” she said.

Robert Jeffress, pastor of First Baptist Dallas, has unapologetically invited President Donald Trump and Vice President Mike Pence to speak at the evangelical megachurch.

Southern Baptists make up a core part of the white evangelical Christian bloc that overwhelmingly votes Republican.

Ms. Butler went even further, surmising that a Christian religious march in Washington on Dec. 20, 2020, laid the groundwork for the Jan. 6 Capitol breach.

She said President Trump’s spiritual adviser Paula White, who opened his Jan. 6 rally, was also at the Jericho March “where most of this planning happened.”

Word Games

Mr. Lindsay said the Left is very good at word association. For most Americans, there’s no real distinction between Christian nationalism and white nationalism.

Ms. Swain said that the far Left needs to vilify Christianity because they want to destroy America by attacking its Judeo-Christian roots and the religious values of the Founding Fathers.

She and Mr. Lindsey said that tearing down American institutions is part of the cultural Marxist movement pushed by far-Left activists.

“Christians have become the boogeyman,” Ms. Swain said. “It’s a rejection of American culture.”

Epoch Times reporters Kevin Stocklin and TJ  Muscaro contributed to this report
Darlene McCormick Sanchez
Darlene McCormick Sanchez
Reporter
Darlene McCormick Sanchez is an Epoch Times reporter who covers border security and immigration, election integrity, and Texas politics. Ms. McCormick Sanchez has 20 years of experience in media and has worked for outlets including Waco Tribune Herald, Tampa Tribune, and Waterbury Republican-American. She was a finalist for a Pulitzer prize for investigative reporting.
Author’s Selected Articles

US States Look to Ban Chinese Technology While Protecting University Research

May 23, 2025
US States Look to Ban Chinese Technology While Protecting University Research

Democrats and Republicans Clash Over New Jersey Rep Facing Charges After Scuffle Outside ICE Facility

May 20, 2025
Democrats and Republicans Clash Over New Jersey Rep Facing Charges After Scuffle Outside ICE Facility

Republicans Ask Secretary Noem to Reconsider Border Wall Budget

May 20, 2025
Republicans Ask Secretary Noem to Reconsider Border Wall Budget

US Attorney’s New Program Gets Around California’s Sanctuary Laws Shielding Illegal Immigrants From ICE

May 19, 2025
US Attorney’s New Program Gets Around California’s Sanctuary Laws Shielding Illegal Immigrants From ICE
Related Topics
racism
White Supremacy
January 6
Christian Nationalism
Save
The Epoch Times
Copyright © 2000 - 2025 The Epoch Times Association Inc. All Rights Reserved.