The caller had informed the authorities that she tried to get the visitors to leave to no avail, the reports said.
Annette Dopplick, a spokesperson for the Steamboat Springs Police Department, said that when police arrived, the guests refused to leave or give their names.
Three men who were arrested were later identified as Ryan Albert, 25, Travis Pettit, 34, and Joseph Thompson, 28, according to the police report. They were arrested on bond after spending a night in jail.
“Mr. Thompson immediately refused and argued what he believed was the right interpretation of the stay-at-home order,” the police report stated. “Mr. Thompson was incorrect about his interpretation of the stay-at-home order. Mr. Thompson argued that he and his friends were practicing social distancing and had been ‘in quarantine’ for some time.”
Officers tried to explain the stay-at-home order but the friends would not leave.
“Officers were never given the opportunity to explain the details of the public health order because … the three subjects repeatedly argued, interrupted and yelled at officers their interpretation of the public health order,” the report stated.
They were taken into police custody for failing to comply with a public health order.
A fourth man, Robert Rees, 46, faces charges of third-degree assault and obstructing an officer. He was not arrested, officials said.