The Next Steps for Canada’s Magnitsky Act

The Magnitsky Act and China are ‘an obvious fit,’ says human rights lawyer David Matas
November 2, 2017 12:23 am Last Updated: November 10, 2017 9:31 pm

OTTAWA—Former Liberal MP and justice minister Irwin Cotler is pleased to finally see passed into law legislation that he pioneered as a private member’s bill back when he was a parliamentarian.

Cotler was among the dignitaries who welcomed Sergei Magnitsky’s widow and son to Ottawa on Nov. 1 to mark the passing of the legislation two weeks ago. The act is named after Magnitsky, a Russian lawyer who uncovered the largest tax fraud in his country’s history and subsequently died as a result of torture in 2009 while detained in Moscow.

Under the legislation, foreign individuals responsible for gross human rights violations similar to those that occurred in Magnitsky’s case can be sanctioned. Sanctions could include barring targeted individuals from entering Canada, engaging in financial transactions in Canada, or engaging in financial transactions with Canadians outside of Canada.

Other jurisdictions, including the United States, the U.K., and Estonia have also enacted their versions of a Global Magnitsky Act.

“We are very thankful that this law carries the name of Sergei Magnitsky, and he is not forgotten by the people,” Magnitsky’s widow, Natalia, said in Russian at a press conference, translated by their 16-year-old son, Nikita.

“However, we would like to highlight the fact that this law is global, because the fight against corruption and human rights violations is a top priority of any modern government.”

Senator Raynell Andreychuk, who introduced the Senate bill which eventually passed to become the current Justice for Victims of Corrupt Foreign Officials Act, said at the press conference that she made sure the legislation would apply globally and not just to Russia.

“I took this bill from what Irwin Cotler had done, and I wanted to ensure that it is global,” she said. “We in Canada want to stand behind this effort and make it a global issue.”

Senator Raynell Andreychuk speaks at a press conference with MP Hélène Laverdière (R), Sergei Magnitsky’s widow Natalia, and their son Nikita in the background in Ottawa on Nov. 1, 2017. (Limin Zhou/NTD Television)

That was exactly the vision of Cotler as well, whose motion passed unanimously in Parliament in 2015 supporting sanctions against any foreign nationals responsible for human rights violations, a move toward establishing a Magnitsky law.

“Canada will not be a haven for those who are engaging in cultures of corruption and criminality, where there is impunity in their countries and they’re not brought to account in their countries,” Cotler said in an interview. “Whether it’d be in Russia or China or whatever, we in Canada are prepared to hold them to account here.”

But having the legislation passed is just the beginning. The next step, says Andreychuk, is going after the human rights violators with the new law. “This is not the end of the bill. It is the start of the implementation,” she said.

Canada Taking the Lead

Winnipeg-based international human rights lawyer David Matas believes Canada can “take a lead in the world by starting with something other than Russia.”

“China and the bill are an obvious fit,” he said.

Given the large number of human rights violations in the world, Matas says it’s important to apply the law strategically.

“I would think, in terms of priorities, go for the worst violators first, and go for the naming that will have the most difference,” he said, adding that a good place to start is with the ongoing persecution of adherents of the Falun Gong meditation practice in China.

“What you have with Falun Gong is a terrible violation: widespread, big numbers. Anything that will cause the violators to pause is going to have a big effect. So I think that would be an important, early-priority use of this law.”

Falun Gong, or Falun Dafa, is a peaceful meditation discipline that has been severely persecuted by the Chinese communist regime since 1999. Matas cites some of the main perpetrators of the campaign of persecution against Falun Gong as examples of individuals who can be sanctioned under the legislation.

International human rights lawyer David Matas. (Gerry Smith/NTD Television)

That includes Jiang Zemin, the former leader of the Chinese Communist Party who started the persecution, and his proteges Luo Gan and Bo Xilai, Chinese officials who played major roles in the persecution and forced removal of organs from Falun Gong prisoners of conscience.

Coincidentally, Bo, who is now serving a life sentence under current leader Xi Jinping’s anti-corruption crusade, had deep ties with notable figures in Canada’s business community.

“It’s a way of preventing any Canadian connection to the human rights violations,” Matas said.

Used Anywhere Applicable

Cotler says the fact that China is Canada’s second-largest trading partner shouldn’t make any difference in applying the legislation where it is warranted.

“It’s not because they’re Chinese, it’s not because we’re targeting the Chinese government. We’re saying we don’t want the spillover of any cultures of corruption and criminality in any country which does not bring their violators to justice, to have it happen in Canada,” he said.

Being concerned about the human rights situation in China is, in fact, being pro-Chinese, Cotler said.

“We do care about the human rights situation in China because I see that as being … pro-Chinese people. In any country where human rights violations exists, and the people who commit those violations are not brought to justice, then the people suffer from that impunity.”

Same Standards

Conservative MP Rob Nicholson said he was happy to see the Magnitsky bill passed into law, as it was one of the bills he had his eye on right before the last federal election, when he served as the minister of foreign affairs.

“It’s an important one—one more tool for Canada to crack down on those individuals involved with illegal activity,” he said.

Nicholson said all countries should abide by internationally recognized human rights standards, and the Magnitsky Act applies to everyone.

“It’s not a question of whether we have a trade relationship—everybody has to comply with the standards, whether it’d be Russia or China or anyone else.”

Conservative MP James Bezan said the bill adds another tool to the toolbox of the government to target corrupt foreign officials.

“Whether it’s oligarchs in Russia, the Kremlin kleptocrats, or maybe it’s somebody in Ukraine, people that are harvesting organs from the Falun Gong in China, the Vietnamese communist government, or what we’re seeing right now in Myanmar … they should get the message that Canada will not tolerate these gross human rights violations,” he said.