Television Review: ‘Upstairs, Downstairs’

April 10, 2011 Updated: October 1, 2015

UPSTAIRS DOWNSTAIRS: An updated version of the series from the 1970s, 'Upstairs Downstairs'.(L-R) Eileen Atkins as Lady Maud Holland, Claire Foy as Lady Persie, Nico Mirallegro as Johnny Proude, Art Malik as Amanjit Singh, Ellie Kendrick as Ivy Morris, Neil Jackson as Harry Spargo, Keeley Hawes as Lady Agnes Holland, Ed Stoppard as Sir Hallam Holland, Adrian Scarborough as Mr. Pritchard, Jean Marsh as Rose Buck, and Anne Reid as Mrs. Thackeray. (Courtesy of BBC Masterpiece)
UPSTAIRS DOWNSTAIRS: An updated version of the series from the 1970s, 'Upstairs Downstairs'.(L-R) Eileen Atkins as Lady Maud Holland, Claire Foy as Lady Persie, Nico Mirallegro as Johnny Proude, Art Malik as Amanjit Singh, Ellie Kendrick as Ivy Morris, Neil Jackson as Harry Spargo, Keeley Hawes as Lady Agnes Holland, Ed Stoppard as Sir Hallam Holland, Adrian Scarborough as Mr. Pritchard, Jean Marsh as Rose Buck, and Anne Reid as Mrs. Thackeray. (Courtesy of BBC Masterpiece)
The year 1936 will be a difficult year for the British Empire. The economy is stagnant, fascism is sweeping Europe, and a scandal will soon rock the Royal Family. The effects of these grand historical events will be felt by the new owners of 165 Eaton Place, perhaps the best loved address in television history, as well as their domestic staff.

Nearly 40 years after its initial American debut, Upstairs, Downstairs returns to PBS’s “Masterpiece Classic” this Sunday for three weeks of appointment television.

It has been 30-some years since the final episode of the original series, but only six years since upstairs maid Rose Buck left the service of the Bellamy family. Since that time, she opened her own employment agency for domestics. Times are tough in 1936, but it is still hard to find good help.

However, when the new lady of the house at number 136 engages her agency’s services, Mrs. Buck also agrees to serve as housekeeper, at least temporarily.

Though Lady Agnes Holland tries to staff the house on the cheap, Mrs. Buck (no longer known as Rose) is able to recruit a serviceable staff.

However, the footman and chauffeur seem to guard secret pasts, while the veteran cook sometimes has trouble acquiescing to her authority. Meanwhile, there is plenty of drama upstairs, too. Particularly troublesome are Lady Agnes’s churlish young sister and Lord Hallam’s imperious mother, Lady Maud.

Coming in the wake of The King’s Speech, American audiences should be well versed in the events leading up to the abdication of Edward VIII. As it happens, the Duke of Kent makes a few appearances at 165, seeking Sir Hallam’s council regarding his brother and that Simpson woman. The events of Europe hit close to home for the staff as well, when the Hollands hire a formerly well-to-do Jewish émigré as one of their upstairs maids.

It also offers a rather unvarnished look at the appeal of British fascist orator Sir Oswald Mosley, whose rallies were one of the few places where the upper and lower classes mixed (while the middle class had the good sense to steer well clear).

Once again, Jean Marsh supplies the heart of Eaton Place as Mrs. Buck, conveying the honest dignity of service. However, she steps back a bit, leaving most of the major plotlines to her co-stars. In a case of being together again for the first time, Eileen Atkins, who co-created the original Upstairs, Downstairs with Marsh but was unable to accept an acting role due to prior commitments, now appears as the high-handed Lady Maud, clearly delighting in her sharp dialogue and regal air.

Yet, perhaps the most compelling character evolution comes from Ed Stoppard as Lord Hallam. Though initially portrayed as a cautious balance-of-power school of diplomat, it seems evident that he is ready to chuck in his lot with Churchill’s Conservative antifascist backbenchers as the new Upstairs, Downstairs progresses, in part due to events he witnesses in his own household. He also starts to stand up to his domineering mother and self-centered wife, for much the same reasons.

The original Upstairs, Downstairs created such a strong emotional bond with viewers, it is hard to speculate how the faithful will receive this return to Eaton Place. However, for those coming in cold, the new series is an engagingly performed, richly produced period drama that sets the hook right from the start.

Though it finishes strong, the new series still leaves at least one major loose end dangling, suggesting there may yet be more Upstairs, Downstairs in the future.

Thoroughly entertaining (at least for us newbies), Upstairs, Downstairs should have a similar appeal as Masterpiece’s breakout hit of the year, Downton Abbey. These two series, along with the rebroadcast of last year’s highly cinematic remake of the The 39 Steps makes this one of the best seasons of "Masterpiece Theater" in perhaps decades.

Eminently classy but also simply good fun, the new Upstairs, Downstairs airs over the next three successive Sunday nights (April 10, 17, and 24).

Joe Bendel writes about independent film and jazz and lives in New York. To read his most recent articles, please visit jbspins.blogspot.com.