Sharp Sanders Cuts Through Gauntlet of Doubt as Browns Top Panthers

The high-profile rookie turns in a prime-time performance in his NFL preseason debut to earn more snaps for the Browns.
Sharp Sanders Cuts Through Gauntlet of Doubt as Browns Top Panthers
Quarterback Shedeur Sanders of the Cleveland Browns runs off the field following their victory over the Carolina Panthers in the NFL Preseason 2025 game at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte, N.C., on Aug. 8, 2025. Jared C. Tilton/Getty Images
|Updated:
0:00

Cleveland Browns rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders was primed and ready for the intense spotlight during his National Football League preseason debut on Friday night.

Perhaps the most talked-about fifth-round, fourth-string quarterback in the history of the league, he performed well amid the pressure of the moment, playing a leading role as starting pro passer in a convincing 30–10 victory over the Carolina Panthers.

And he did it much unlike his flamboyant father, Pro Football Hall of Famer and Colorado Buffaloes coach Deion Sanders, nicknamed “Prime Time” because he stood out so much despite playing the mostly veiled position of cornerback.

The younger Sanders, who has the glory/blame position of QB, doesn’t need to be showy to garner attention. In fact, attention seeks him.

Sanders, though, soaked in his first experience, and with his holistic approach to the game.

“Even though it’s a preseason game—typically, people don’t take [things] too ... serious, but like, that’s our Super Bowl,” Sanders admitted about his start during postgame media availability.

“Change is a family thing. You got to be able to go to war with each and every guy, and understand that we’re not playing for ourselves, we’re playing for each other. [That means] not making selfish mistakes, not doing that type of stuff, getting through reads, handing the ball off and doing what you do. Everybody [does] their job, and that’s how we believe in one another.”

The comments reflected the way Sanders played. He didn’t look rushed, out of place, or overwhelmed. Sanders posted a 106.8 quarterback rating, connecting on 11 of 18 passes with two touchdowns in the first half.
He didn’t turn the ball over and wasn’t detrimental to the Cleveland offense as he stepped up and balled out. Sanders completed 14 of 23 passes for a modest 138 yards but two impressive TDs.
There have been plenty of doubts about Sanders’ arm strength and his ability to run a pro offense against NFL defenses. Still, a number of draft experts graded Sanders as a first-round talent. And the Browns had a crowded QB room when they made Sanders the No. 144th selection in the April NFL Draft.
Shedeur Sanders (12) of the Cleveland Browns passes the ball during the second half of an NFL Preseason 2025 game against the Carolina Panthers at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte, N.C., on Aug. 8, 2025. (David Jensen/Getty Images)
Shedeur Sanders (12) of the Cleveland Browns passes the ball during the second half of an NFL Preseason 2025 game against the Carolina Panthers at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte, N.C., on Aug. 8, 2025. David Jensen/Getty Images

Cleveland added the signal caller not out of necessity but because of the value the team said it saw in a player who had dropped so low in the draft that he ended up being the victim of a prank call.

That particular moment was perhaps the worst of Sanders’ career. But there was also a strong amount of speculation that his moment as a starter, albeit preseason, would never come. Pre-draft reports were rampant about how the Sanders family didn’t want to join certain clubs, was ill-prepared for interviews with other teams and was generally overconfident about his ability to play in the NFL.

Many outlets cited those as the reasons why he tumbled all the way to the fifth round in the draft.

Then, Cleveland decided to put him on its roster, throwing him in a long line behind veteran Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett, and third-round selection Dillon Gabriel. And if not for injuries to Gabriel and Pickett that helped elevate Sanders up the depth chart, he might not have gotten his nearly three full quarters of action in a starting role on Friday.

The truth is that fourth-string QBs rarely get first-half snaps in preseason games. So for Sanders to experience a start was quite a feat for a player who some thought might be in danger of falling off the roster. Now, he’s close to locking up a spot on the team.

Browns coach Kevin Stefanski was much like Philadelphia Eagles star running back Saquon Barkley dodging tacklers as he avoided quarterback-controversy talk in his postgame press conference.

“Pleased with Shedeur, pleased with the offense,” Browns coach Kevin Stefanski said after the victory. “Again, not perfect, plenty that we can work on, but I thought the guys did a really nice job ... of operating, and guys making plays. So, again, a ton to teach off of.

“We’re really just focused on developing our players, we’re in evaluation mode. I’m really pleased with where the guys are, but I’m not diving into a quarterback competition,” Stefanski said, shutting down questions about who the Week 1 starter might be or where Sanders appears now on the depth chart.

Sanders wasn’t really expected to be in the running for a starting role, but Stefanski delivered calm praise toward the rookie after a very capable effort.

“Honestly, I’m pleased with the way Shedeur played, I’m pleased with the way the offense operated tonight. All things moving forward as we continue to practice, we’ll be focused on all of our guys’ development and getting these guys ready to play for the season,” Stefanski said, later cutting Sanders slack on a couple of wayward tosses.

“You’re not going to make every throw, and that’s part of this game.”

Sanders might soon be ready for prime time.

Google LogoMark Us Preferred on Google
John E. Gibson
John E. Gibson
Author
John E. Gibson has covered pro baseball in Japan for about 20 years and brings great knowledge and insight across the sports spectrum. His experience includes stints at The Orange County Register, The Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, The Redlands Daily Facts and The Yomiuri Shimbun’s English newspaper in Tokyo.