Smart Outraged by Planned Release of 1 of Her Kidnappers

September 13, 2018 Updated: September 13, 2018

SALT LAKE CITY—Elizabeth Smart said on Sept. 13 the news that one of her kidnappers will be released from prison next week was “a big shock,” and she hopes there is a way the woman can be committed to a treatment facility since there is no legal recourse to keep her behind bars.

Wanda Barzee is expected to be freed next week after 15 years in custody, following a surprise announcement that Utah authorities had miscalculated the amount of time the 72-year-old woman should serve.

Standing on the steps of the Utah state capitol, Smart, now 30, recalled some of the horrors she experienced when she was snatched from her home in 2002.

“She is a woman who had six children yet could co-conspire to kidnap a 14-year-old girl, and not only sit next to her while being raped but encourage her husband to continue to rape me,” Smart said. “So do I believe she’s dangerous? Yes.”

She said Barzee “saw me as her slave. She called me her handmaiden. She never hesitated to let her displeasure with me be known.”

Barzee is expected to be freed next Sept. 19.

Attorney Scott Williams has said Barzee has been diagnosed with several mental illnesses, but he’s not concerned about her being a danger to the community. Williams did not immediately return a message seeking comment Sept. 13.

The Utah Board of Pardons and Parole set a January 2024 release date in June, but her attorney questioned whether that included time she’d served in a federal prison. On Sept. 11, the board decided that she had served her sentence.

Elizabeth Smart Kidnapper Prison Release
This April 8, 2016, file photo, provided by Utah State Prison shows Wanda Barzee. Barzee, the woman convicted of helping a former street preacher kidnap Elizabeth Smart as a teenager from her Salt Lake City bedroom in 2002 and held her captive, will be released from prison next week. The surprise move announced Sept. 11, 2018, comes after authorities determined they had miscalculated the time Barzee previously served in federal custody. (By Utah State Prison/AP)

“I only found out shortly before everybody else,” said Smart, who is now a married mother and activist for victims’ rights. “And yes, it was a big shock. Only months ago, I was on my way to a parole hearing and was told she would never be let out before 2024.”

Her father Ed Smart also questioned why authorities didn’t give her more warning about the impending release.

Smart said she is taking unspecified steps to protect her family, but that she refuses to live in a “state of fear.”

Elizabeth Smart Kidnapper Prison Release
In this April 24, 2015, kidnapping survivor Elizabeth Smart looks on during a news conference in Sandy, Utah. Wanda Barzee, a woman convicted of helping a former street preacher kidnap Smart in 2002 will be freed from prison more than five years earlier than expected, a surprise decision that Smart called “incomprehensible” on Sept. 11, 2018. (Rick Bowmer/AP Photo)

If Barzee had shown more clear signs of rehabilitation, she would likely feel differently about her release, Smart said.

“I do believe in forgiveness. I am Christian,” she said. She also urged authorities to reconsider the process for release decisions to put greater weight on potential threat as well as time served.

Elizabeth Smart Kidnapper Prison Release
Elizabeth Smart speaks during a news conference while her father Ed Smart looks on Sept. 13, 2018, in Salt Lake City. Smart says it appears there is no viable, legal recourse she can take to stop the release of one of her kidnappers. Smart said at a news conference Thursday in Salt Lake City that she only found out about 72-year-old Wanda Barzee’s release shortly before the public did. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)

Smart was abducted from her Salt Lake City bedroom at knifepoint by street preacher Brian David Mitchell, who came in through an open kitchen window. The kidnapping triggered waves of fear around the country.

Smart was found while walking with Barzee and Mitchell on a street in the suburb of Sandy, Utah, by people who recognized the couple from media reports.

Mitchell is serving a life sentence after being convicted of kidnapping and raping Smart. He and Barzee were married at one point.

Barzee was convicted of both state and federal crimes, and transferred to the Utah state prison in April 2016 after finishing a federal sentence in Texas. She will be under federal supervision for five years after her release from prison.

If she violates the conditions of her release, which will include mental health treatment and an order not to contact Smart’s family, she could go back to prison, said Smart’s attorney Brett Tolman.

Tolman was previously the U.S. Attorney for Utah who prosecuted Mitchell, and is now in private practice.

Barzee’s family could also request a possible civil commitment to a mental-health facility, if that’s warranted, he said.

By Lindsay Whitehurst

RECOMMENDED